Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 05:19 PM Feb 2023

Pentagon releases selfie taken by US pilot showing Chinese spy balloon in air

Source: CNN Politics


A US Air Force pilot looked down at the suspected Chinese surveillance balloon as it hovered over the Central Continental United States February 3, 2023. Recovery efforts began shortly after the balloon was downed. (Photo courtesy of the Department of Defense)


CNN — The US Defense Department has released a selfie taken in the cockpit of a U-2 spy plane, as an airman flew above the Chinese surveillance balloon that was shot down by the US military earlier this month. The selfie, taken by the pilot of the U-2, shows the shadow of the aircraft on the balloon and a clear image of the balloon’s payload as it crossed across the continental United States. CNN first reported the existence of the selfie.

The balloon was first spotted by the US on January 28 and ultimately shot down by the US military off the coast of South Carolina after crossing the country. A senior State Department official said earlier this month that fly-bys “revealed that the high-altitude balloon was capable of conducting signals intelligence collection operations.”

Officials said they’d decided against shooting the balloon down over the US because of its size, fearing falling debris could hurt civilians or property on the ground. Gen. Glen VanHerck, commander of US Northern Command and North American Aerospace Defense Command, later said the balloon was 200 feet tall with a payload that weighed a couple of thousand pounds.

Officials also maintained that the balloon was not capable of conducting significant intelligence collection, in part because the US took steps to protect against it immediately upon spotting it.

Read more: https://www.cnn.com/2023/02/22/politics/pentagon-china-balloon-selfie/index.html





24 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Pentagon releases selfie taken by US pilot showing Chinese spy balloon in air (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 OP
Who cares, great pics tinymontgomery Feb 2023 #1
Well the pic in the comments section was from the movie "Top Gun" so... BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #2
Thunderbird solo pilots fly canopy-to-canopy IRL LastLiberal in PalmSprings Feb 2023 #24
So, Where Are The Pictures of the Other Objects? ruet Feb 2023 #3
I don't think any of those have or will even be recovered BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #4
The Pictures Will Never Be Recovered? -NT- ruet Feb 2023 #5
I wouldn't rule it out BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #6
I Don't Understand What Any of This Has to Do With... ruet Feb 2023 #7
I think they were trying to confirm who they belonged to first BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #8
Who Cares Who They Belong To? ruet Feb 2023 #9
Since DOD BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #11
Again, Where Are The Pictures? ruet Feb 2023 #12
It's only been just under a week BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #13
Still Waiting. ruet Feb 2023 #22
Two of the objects were shot down over Canadian territory BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #23
Or maybe they can't tell us what they are Polybius Feb 2023 #16
I still think one may have been the latest verson of this BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #17
Is that Glenda? Midnight Writer Feb 2023 #10
They still fly U2s? GreatShakes66 Feb 2023 #14
Yes, that surprised me too IronLionZion Feb 2023 #15
Research as well as surveillance. cab67 Feb 2023 #18
I'm still surprised that the Chinese would use a balloon for surveillance. cab67 Feb 2023 #19
They are cheaper than satellites BumRushDaShow Feb 2023 #20
I appreciate the information. cab67 Feb 2023 #21

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
2. Well the pic in the comments section was from the movie "Top Gun" so...
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 06:01 PM
Feb 2023


(it's what the "selfie" thing reminded me of although when "Top Gun" came out, they didn't have cell phones).



24. Thunderbird solo pilots fly canopy-to-canopy IRL
Mon Feb 27, 2023, 04:04 PM
Feb 2023


The USAF Thunderbirds solo pilots perform the famous mirror formation, with Thunderbird 5 inverted
above Thunderbird 6.

ruet

(10,039 posts)
3. So, Where Are The Pictures of the Other Objects?
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 06:12 PM
Feb 2023

The ones that were "tied to commercial or research entities and therefore benign". No cute "selfie" to release for those?

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
4. I don't think any of those have or will even be recovered
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 06:26 PM
Feb 2023

They were only a fraction of the size of that Chinese balloon.

U.S., Canada suspend search for objects shot down over Alaska, Lake Huron and Yukon


By Andrew Jeong and Kyle Rempfer

Updated February 18, 2023 at 7:53 a.m. EST|Published February 17, 2023 at 11:47 p.m. EST


U.S. and Canadian authorities suspended recovery operations for debris from the aerial objects they shot down last week over Alaska, Lake Huron and the Yukon, officials from both countries said Friday, as the chances of recovery narrowed and it became more likely that the objects were innocuous research or recreation balloons.

The move to suspend searches in Alaska and Lake Huron was recommended by the U.S. Northern Command and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin concurred with the decision. It came after American troops, federal agencies and Canadian officials discovered “no debris from airborne objects” after a search using airborne imagery sensors as well as subsurface scans in Lake Huron and the Alaskan town of Deadhorse, according to the release.

Later, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police also announced that they would suspend their search efforts in the Yukon for the aerial object shot down on Feb. 11 after not finding the debris.

“Given the snowfall that has occurred, the decreasing probability the object will be found and the current belief the object is not tied to a scenario that justifies extraordinary search efforts, the RCMP is terminating the search,” the Canadian national police service said in a statement.

(snip)

https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/02/17/balloon-recovery-alaska-lake-huron/


There is a good working theory that one of the objects may have been an amateur radio group's Pico balloon.

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
6. I wouldn't rule it out
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 06:43 PM
Feb 2023

as there were descriptions released so no doubt they took pics for further identification.

The problem, just like those damn quadcopters ( "drones" ), is that you have all kinds of stuff being launched with some of it capable of reaching altitudes where planes are flying and I sure as hell wouldn't want one that is not registered to be there, end up getting sucked into an engine of a plane that I am in.

It's bad enough when you have the damn Canada geese that can bring a plane down, let alone just overall bird strikes -

ruet

(10,039 posts)
7. I Don't Understand What Any of This Has to Do With...
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 06:50 PM
Feb 2023

releasing pictures, that we certainly have, of objects that were "tied to commercial or research entities and therefore benign". Oh, and an AIM-9X wouldn't even be able to "see" a quadcopter or hobbyist drone.

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
8. I think they were trying to confirm who they belonged to first
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 07:01 PM
Feb 2023


Apparently one group may be the owner of one of the objects but they are trying to give time to see if their Pico balloon was actually one of things shot down or whether it is just having a communications issue if the solar power on it was insufficient and that is why it suddenly "went dark" during the same timeframe when NORAD was engaging these unknown objects.

And again, if something is flying at 40,000 feet in airspace and is not transmitting any ID, then it risks being shot down.

There was an article that had an explanation about use of those AIMs-

These Are the $439,000 Missiles the US Is Using to Shoot Down Mystery UFOs


Low De Wei and Gregory Korte
February 13, 2023 at 1:02 PM EST


As mysteries continue to swirl around the balloon and three other so-far-unidentified objects shot down by the US in recent days, at least one thing has been clear: the weaponry used to knock them out of the sky. Be it the original, alleged Chinese surveillance balloon downed off South Carolina, or the objects targeted over Alaska, Michigan and Canada, all have been shot down by the same type of missile — the AIM-9X Sidewinder.

Here’s what you need to know about it:

(snip)

Why are they being used to shoot down UFOs?

Using a missile helps minimize the risk to the pilot of the jet fighter by allowing them to stay at a much larger distance from the target, according to Iain Boyd, the Director of the Center for National Security Initiatives at the University of Colorado. “It would have to go much closer to the target to use a cannon and there have been reports of the aircraft sensors being interfered with,” he said. While the Sidewinder wasn’t designed for shooting down flying objects like balloons, they are cheaper and less likely to destroy payloads on the flying object that officials want to recover, unlike a radar-guided weapon like the AIM-120 AMRAAM medium-range missile, said retired US Air Force Colonel Michael Pietrucha. Their heat-seeking abilities may also make them more well-suited for doing so, he said. "You've got two conditions. In the daytime, you have the sun heating the balloon -- you're shooting from up-sun because it sees this giant sunlight reflection and will absolutely guide on that. And at night the balloon is warmer compared to the night sky," said the former irregular warfare operations officer and electronic warfare instructor who flew 156 combat missions in F-4G and F-15E jets. Even if the flying object does not generate heat, the missile will still be able to find it as “it’s the relationship to the background that matters more,” Pietrucha added. "The way you shot down balloons back in the day was incendiary ammunition against a hydrogen balloon. But that was 100-plus years ago."

(snip)

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-13/us-is-shooting-down-unidentified-objects-ufos-with-439-000-missiles


It's interesting to see half of DU whine about why something "wasn't shot down before crossing the U.S." and the other half whining about why something was "shot down" at all.

ruet

(10,039 posts)
9. Who Cares Who They Belong To?
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 07:08 PM
Feb 2023

Not a matter of national security and there is no expectation of privacy in public. They should be released.

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
11. Since DOD
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 07:26 PM
Feb 2023
made changes to their radar sensitivity and have been updating protocols for that change, then it behooves that whatever is done and how it is released, is per that protocol.

And it does matter "who it belongs to" for future engagements and awareness of what is actually in the airspace which might prompt cross-cutting work with the FAA to consider revising or drafting new Rules for such objects, including devising a communications mechanism for the owners to the FAA if one goes off course.


ruet

(10,039 posts)
12. Again, Where Are The Pictures?
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 07:46 PM
Feb 2023

Not the radar returns, the pictures. As far as the FAA drafting new rules for liaising with a private entity... That's not classified information and doesn't have anything to do with pictures of objects deemed to be "tied to commercial or research entities and therefore benign". I just don't get how everyone is acting as if it's perfectly fine for the DOD to release a picture of an actual national security threat, that the US used the pinnacle of the technology in its arsenal to destroy, when mum's the word about objects "tied to commercial or research entities and therefore benign". It makes no logical sense.

I'm going to leave it there as we are just going around in circles at this point.

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
13. It's only been just under a week
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 08:06 PM
Feb 2023

when a decision was made that any debris from those smaller objects might not be recoverable.

There was an almost 3 week gap in time between when this spy balloon was spotted and that pic was taken and when that photo was released. I.e., the photo was taken Feb. 3 and today is Feb. 22.

The other objects were spotted and eventually shot down Feb. 10, 11, 12, so it's not out of the realm of possibility for any pics that might have been taken and are clear enough to make sense to release, to eventually be released. In a couple cases (Yukon and Lake Huron), those objects were over Canadian airspace and any info release may be subject to Canadian law/discretion.

I think you are conflating issues now to make a silly political point and waving it away by characterizing it as "going in circles" is a bunch of nonsense.

ruet

(10,039 posts)
22. Still Waiting.
Sun Feb 26, 2023, 01:54 PM
Feb 2023

I'm not making any point other than I want those pictures. There's simply no reason for them to be withheld from us if they are as innocuous as we are being told. How do you reconcile the points you're trying to make with something like this? ...taken a day or two ago BTW.




WHERE ARE THE PICTURES?

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
23. Two of the objects were shot down over Canadian territory
Sun Feb 26, 2023, 02:24 PM
Feb 2023

so I expect that is up to Trudeau as to how much info would be released about them.

One of these may have been a Pico balloon and the owners have apparently been waiting to confirm either way as they claim there have been times when it has gone "silent" before resuming communications.

IronLionZion

(45,534 posts)
15. Yes, that surprised me too
Wed Feb 22, 2023, 11:41 PM
Feb 2023

They've been around a while. The latest model was upgraded in 2012. We don't hear about it lately since the famous cold war shoot down over the Soviet Union.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_U-2

cab67

(3,007 posts)
19. I'm still surprised that the Chinese would use a balloon for surveillance.
Thu Feb 23, 2023, 01:24 PM
Feb 2023

They're slow, not very maneuverable, and easily tracked and shot down once spotted. I can't imagine they would have included classified technology, given these vulnerabilities.

In fact, I seriously questioned whether this was a spy balloon when the story first emerged. It just seemed too prone to ending badly. I thought it might be some sort of spoofing mission, with the Chinese testing our detection capabilities. I now realize it actually was a spy balloon, but it took me a while to really accept that.

We used surveillance balloons early in the Cold War, but most would have operated over US airspace (the intent being to detect evidence for a nuclear explosion in the USSR), and they were replaced by surveillance aircraft and satellites as soon as these were developed. China has a space program, so I'd have thought they were also using satellites.

BumRushDaShow

(129,493 posts)
20. They are cheaper than satellites
Thu Feb 23, 2023, 01:42 PM
Feb 2023

and even trying to do geostationary satellites would add additional cost.

They are not the only ones doing this. My early looking this up found companies here in the U.S. who are hawking the same type of stuff and for the same reason - "surveillance". In fact, Mark Kelly had at one time been involved in one such company as one of the original founders and left before becoming a Senator (World View).

I had posted the below in a couple threads including here - https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1014&pid=3029172



https://worldview.space/

Pioneers of the stratosphere

Since 2014, World View has led the way in remote sensing and Earth observation from the stratosphere, completing scores of successful flights for a variety of scientific, commercial and government enterprises. Our proprietary stratospheric balloon flight technology delivers better insights with far lower costs and lead times than satellites and other traditional aerial sources.

Focused on the future

World View's remote-controlled Stratollites fly five times closer to Earth than satellites, capturing high-resolution imagery with much greater detail. And since they can persistently hover over a target area for months, they provide a clearer picture of changes on the ground than satellites that only fly over a target area at the same time every day.

Our Stratollites operate at altitudes of up to 95,000 ft. (~29 km) for days, weeks and months on end. They offer 250W of power and a payload capacity of 50kg (with heavier capacities available soon.) They combine the benefits of geostationary satellites, LEO satellites, and high-altitude drones – offering the ideal mix of resolution, accuracy, and persistent viewing of key targets. All at a fraction of the cost.

Persistence and Resolution

Our stratospheric technology allows World View to transit the stratosphere with sensors that loiter over large areas of interest and provide persistent observation and data collection for a wide variety of applications, without the limitations of satellite orbit paths or short duration flight vehicles.


If you go to World View's website, you can find a longer version of the above video and it is also has a narration overlay that describes the surveillance capabilities and why it would be useful.
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Pentagon releases selfie ...