The Lost Morality of Economics
Recalling the Wisdom of Richard Henry Tawney and Others
by John Andrews / February 11th, 2019
One of the most powerful and effective tools in the hands of capitalist economists is the suggestion that economics in general and capitalism in particular is some sort of science. This illusion and illusion it is is strongly assisted by the fact that modern economics is taught with the aid of impressive-looking mathematical equations and proofs. Economic textbooks are cluttered with tables, statistics, and graphs which make the books look like physics textbooks, or maths books even. Therefore economics must also be a science, right?
Well, no, actually. For the very simple reason that real sciences, such as physics and chemistry, demand a standard of proof and intellectual rigour that not only doesnt exist in modern economics, it has never existed at all since the earliest days when some sort of economic theory could be perceived. Early economic principles were conceived in religion, and religion strongly influenced economic practices for at least two thousand years. Capitalism, the dominant economic belief of today, is still more of a religion than a science, because it demands from its adherents a level of blind faith which is little different from any other religious fanatic.
In the beginning
As an atheist Im not much impressed by the bible, or any other religious work. I accept that theres some limited utilitarian value in such books, for the slight contribution they make to studying the essential subject of history, but the main purpose they have always served tools of psychological oppression for the rich to control the thoughts and actions of the poor is reprehensible, and devalues any use they may have as lessons of history. The bibles usefulness as a collection of historical documents is helpful for this discussion not because of any particular value to economic thought in the stories themselves, but in the almost undeniable fact that those stories were told, and presumably believed, a very long time ago.
RH Tawney was an economic historian whose work was well known in the first half of the last century, and was strongly influential on the embryonic ethical values of Britains Labour Party. He was a devout Christian and lifelong friend of William Temple, who became the Archbishop of Canterbury. Unsurprisingly he clearly felt no conflict of interest between his Christian faith and his staunch support of socialism, and if Tawneys work is now largely unknown its probably due more to the latter fact than the former. However, much of what he had to say is as relevant today as it was in Tawneys day if not even more so.
More:
https://dissidentvoice.org/2019/02/the-lost-morality-of-economics/