Put the NSA on trial
With potential perjury by top officials, and new questions about spying, let's stop assuming everything is legal
When the president does it that means it is not illegal. These infamous words from Richard Nixon appear to summarize the public legal justification for the Obama administrations unprecedented mass surveillance operation. Perhaps worse, Permanent Washington would have us believe that this rationale is unquestionably accurate and that therefore the National Security Administrations surveillance is perfectly legal.
For example, Richard Haas of the Council on Foreign Relations said of Edward Snowden: Whistleblower is person who reveals wrongdoing, corruption, illegal activity. none of this applies here even if you oppose U.S. government policy. Likewise, the Boston Globes Bryan Bender insists, I wish media would stop calling Snowden a whistleblower it maligns those who truly reveal corrupt or illegal activity. And the New Yorkers Jeffrey Toobin definitively states: These were legally authorized programs.
The idea here, which has quickly become the standard talking point for partisans trying to defend the NSA program and the Obama administration, is that while you may object to the NSAs mass surveillance system, it is nonetheless perfectly legal as is the conduct surrounding it. Therefore, the logic goes, Snowden isnt an honorable whistle-blower hes a traitorous leaker, and the only criminal in this case is Snowden and Snowden alone.
The first and most simple way to debunk this talking point is to simply behold two sets of testimony by Obama administration national security officials. In one, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper categorically denies that the government collect(s) any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans. In another, the Guardian reports that NSA Director General Keith Alexander denied point-blank that the agency had the figures on how many Americans had their electronic communications collected or reviewed.
http://www.salon.com/2013/06/11/put_the_nsa_on_trial/