Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 01:30 PM Jul 2017

Not mocking, Catholic statue of Mary: The earrings gave me pause

I'm *lapsed* and consider myself a secular humanist, but still have a bit of nostalgia the way the generations after Henry VIII's split from the church pined for "the olde religion." So there was this news item about a newly commissioned statue of Mary and first the CONVENTIONAL "beauty" of the features struck me, but then the *earrings* - talk about high maintenance!1 Would a celestial being need further adornment over and above the presumed state of ineffable otherness?

I did a small Google on Athena and, while her depictions include crownlike helmets, the quick Search brought up no earrings. Just, hmmm.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Not mocking, Catholic statue of Mary: The earrings gave me pause (Original Post) UTUSN Jul 2017 OP
Guurrrllll, Love the Hair... Raster Jul 2017 #1
That, too!1 UTUSN Jul 2017 #4
Did you happen to see the Athena statue in the Parthenon in Nashville? Lars39 Jul 2017 #2
You must be psychic - I *have* been there!1 but either the statue was not installed or UTUSN Jul 2017 #3
She wasn't painted and gilded until 2002. Lars39 Jul 2017 #6
So the statue was originally installed around 1990... Docreed2003 Jul 2017 #8
Not about the building, litigation over the statue (copyright?) iirc UTUSN Jul 2017 #10
That's what I'm saying... Docreed2003 Jul 2017 #12
Wow!1 UTUSN Jul 2017 #13
I don't know if it's related to the lawsuit, but his Athena looks a heck of a lot Lars39 Jul 2017 #17
A thought: the forehead piece and earrings might suggest the Trinity. UTUSN Jul 2017 #5
Maybe we only think they're earrings... defacto7 Jul 2017 #7
Next you'll be telling me the saints aren't wearing hubcaps on their heads. Iggo Jul 2017 #9
They do look like earrings, don't they? red dog 1 Jul 2017 #11
Am curious as to what else they might be. UTUSN Jul 2017 #14
Some of the symbolism on the 'earrings' are similar to those found on Mayan ear flares ... Donkees Jul 2017 #15
"earrings" in quotes!1 Second reference in thread that they're something besides earrings!1 What?!1 UTUSN Jul 2017 #16
They are earrings on the statue, but they carry the symbolism and design of mayan ear-flares ... Donkees Jul 2017 #18
Mayan ear-flare design similar to statue's earring design Donkees Jul 2017 #19
So... like small "ear trumpets" (with a spiritual angle)? UTUSN Jul 2017 #21
I think so :) Donkees Jul 2017 #24
Thanks for setting me on a path to follow up on. Bearing in UTUSN Jul 2017 #20
Lastly, here is a photo of the ancient earth goddess Tonanzin having ear-flares ... Donkees Jul 2017 #22
Wow, gotta say u gave me new eyes! Thanks! UTUSN Jul 2017 #23
I looked up the sculptor, but unfortunately he passed away. However, I did find this video Rhiannon12866 Jul 2017 #25
Thanks for that, didn't know he died: Edmund RABANSER UTUSN Jul 2017 #26
Baby Jesus would rip those things right out of her head Orrex Jul 2017 #27
Now now... UTUSN Jul 2017 #28

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
3. You must be psychic - I *have* been there!1 but either the statue was not installed or
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 01:59 PM
Jul 2017

it was covered up off limits because of litigation - back in the '90s.

****Whoa, just looked at your link and that's quite a hair and makeup job!1 Looks like earrings might be included but can't tell.

Lars39

(26,109 posts)
6. She wasn't painted and gilded until 2002.
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 02:14 PM
Jul 2017

I can't remember if she had ear rings or not. From the photo it could be her hair.
She and little Nike are pretty cool up close.

Docreed2003

(16,858 posts)
8. So the statue was originally installed around 1990...
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 02:53 PM
Jul 2017

I remember taking a school field trip down there to see it. At that time, the statue was all white. It wasn't until later that the historical rendering of the statue was completed. Perhaps that was ongoing when you visited, because I can't recall there ever being litigation related to the Parthenon, but I could be mistaken.

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
10. Not about the building, litigation over the statue (copyright?) iirc
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 03:14 PM
Jul 2017

I've got pics of myself at the building, but *my* image is protected - haha!1

Docreed2003

(16,858 posts)
12. That's what I'm saying...
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 04:37 PM
Jul 2017

The only time that I know of that the statue was off limits or unable to be viewed was when artists were working on it after the initial installation.

It went from this:



To this:



UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
13. Wow!1
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 04:43 PM
Jul 2017

And I'm not disputing/arguing, but the detail about copyright has remained stuck in my otherwise ever fading mind, and is not something I would think up on my own, and have never done any reading up on about this site, so...


That said, this Athena is dolled up more than Mae WEST!1 And with bracelets (can't see earrings). I realize that in ancient Greece the buildings and statues were painted (wildly?), and assuming that the Nashville is a homage/replica, is this what the original looked like?!1


Lars39

(26,109 posts)
17. I don't know if it's related to the lawsuit, but his Athena looks a heck of a lot
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 07:11 PM
Jul 2017

like the Time Life's artist's rendition of the statue (Greece, page 115). I'd scan and upload but supper is calling.

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
5. A thought: the forehead piece and earrings might suggest the Trinity.
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 02:14 PM
Jul 2017

Last edited Sun Jul 2, 2017, 03:41 PM - Edit history (2)

Top piece Big, other two subordinate. Symbolism is big in the church.


*******My bringing Athena into it was just from wondering whether physical adornments are common in actual antiquities of deities, am thinking yes, but it stuck out regarding Mary. To clarify, the Mary here is a brand new commission, not an oldie.



UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
14. Am curious as to what else they might be.
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 05:49 PM
Jul 2017

I get the image of the lady sitting on a cloud, putting on earrings and applying lipstick, but then, presumably personal assistants - I mean, *angels* - would be involved!1

But the real incongruence in my mind is the Vanity Clause, as in personal adornment being vanity. I'd better stop at this stage of my blaspheming!1

Donkees

(31,392 posts)
15. Some of the symbolism on the 'earrings' are similar to those found on Mayan ear flares ...
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 05:56 PM
Jul 2017

... the flares being thought of as 'spiritual conduits'.

There are Tree of Life, fertility and protection symbols on the statue, and the crescent shape at her feet in this photo is similar to the naja squash blossom design.

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
16. "earrings" in quotes!1 Second reference in thread that they're something besides earrings!1 What?!1
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 06:51 PM
Jul 2017

Curiosity is consuming me!1

Donkees

(31,392 posts)
18. They are earrings on the statue, but they carry the symbolism and design of mayan ear-flares ...
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 07:38 PM
Jul 2017

In my opinion, the ancient design is a cultural artifact of Mayan ear-flares (ear plugs) signifying a spiritual conduit. Imagine the flares as amplifying 'hearing the cries of the world'. Here is one form of an ancient ear-flare. It looks like the top of the earrings the statue is wearing.




Here is another version of an ear-flare:

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
20. Thanks for setting me on a path to follow up on. Bearing in
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 08:01 PM
Jul 2017

mind that the artist is Italian, although he might base himself on research?

Donkees

(31,392 posts)
22. Lastly, here is a photo of the ancient earth goddess Tonanzin having ear-flares ...
Sun Jul 2, 2017, 08:19 PM
Jul 2017

Ear-flares evolved into hoop earrings, but the design elements remain. An artist creating a modern icon for a culture, would be familiar with that culture's visual language.






Tonanzin transformed into Our Lady of Guadalupe

Rhiannon12866

(205,282 posts)
25. I looked up the sculptor, but unfortunately he passed away. However, I did find this video
Mon Jul 3, 2017, 05:12 AM
Jul 2017

Of his previous project, the Stations of the Cross at the same shrine, the Basilica of Our Lady of San Juan del Valle National Shrine in San Juan, Texas, depicted by life sized statues. These sculptures look much simpler, but the amount of work that must have gone into creating this is astonishing!

Video:

UTUSN

(70,686 posts)
26. Thanks for that, didn't know he died: Edmund RABANSER
Mon Jul 3, 2017, 10:25 AM
Jul 2017

********QUOTE*******

http://catholicliturgicalarts.blogspot.com/2016/05/in-memory-of-our-dear-friend-edmund.html

In Memory of Our Dear Friend Edmund Rabanser
May 28 2016


It was nearly half a century ago when Rudolf Rohn discovered a brilliant young artisan who had the God-given talent of carving masterpieces out of wood. Rudolph had such great faith in this young woodcarver he presented him with his first large commission. That brilliant artisan was Edmund Rabanser and he became one of the preeminent master woodcarvers in the world.

Today, it is with heartfelt sympathy that Rolf Rohn informs you that this brilliant artisan, trusted colleague and dear friend, has passed away. Rolf and his team have had the pleasure and honor of working with Edmund on projects around the world. He was an artist who took pride in creating magnificent one-of-a-kind works of art using simple Old World craftsmanship in his treasured Ortisei studio, in his home overlooking the Italian Alps.

Edmund’s work is proudly displayed in churches across the globe, including these in collaboration with our studio:

USCCB Chapel in Washington DC – Crucifix
Holy Family Institute in Pittsburgh, PA – Holy Family statue and Saint with Children
Chapel of the Incarnate Word, San Antonio TX – Crucifix and low relief carvings with the history of the congregation
Co-Cathedral of the Sacred Heart, Houston TX – Crucifix and saint statues in the Narthex
St. John Neumann, Austin TX – Crucifix
Church of the Resurrection, Rio Rancho, NM – Crucifix
Bishop's Ricken Chapel in Green Bay – Cimbaue Cross and Tabernacle
Basilica of Our Lady of St. Juan del Valle National Shrine, San Juan, TX – Life-size bronze Stations of the Cross
Blessed Sacrament Church, Alexandria – Crucifix
St. Joseph Parish, York, PA – Emmaus carving sanctuary wall
Father of Mercy Chapel, Franciscan Sisters, T.O.R., Toronto, OH – Carved sanctuary wall
St. Louise of Marillac, Pittsburgh, PA – Sanctuary wall and tabernacle door
St. James Cathedral, Orlando, FL - Crucifix

He is survived by his wife, Concetta; three children, George, Oskar and Helen; and six grandchildren

********UNQUOTE********
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Not mocking, Catholic sta...