Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

JPZenger

(6,819 posts)
Tue Jun 5, 2012, 07:54 PM Jun 2012

Corbett promising $1.7 BILLION in tax breaks to Shell Corp. to build new chemical plant

Our Governor keeps saying that he can't possibly restore any of the $1 BILLION of cuts to public schools because "I don't have the money."

Meanwhile, today the Lt. Governor let slip that Corbett is seeking $1.7 BILLION of state tax credits for the Shell Corp. (Shell made $33 billion in profits last year, by the way).

This is on top of his previously announced deal to Shell that their new plant in southwest PA. would not have to pay any state or local taxes for 15 years.

Corbett at his inaguration actually said he wants to model PA. after Texas. His goal is to have an entire economy driven by fracking and chemical plants. The fracking provides the gas that fuels the Shell Corp. "cracker" plant that then makes chemicals that are used in other chemical plants that then make more chemicals, that then increase demand further for the gas.

http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/business/news/corbett-seeking-1675-billion-tax-break-deal-for-shell-638916/

Excerpts:

"The ethane tax credit will be aimed at attracting more facilities that process gas liquids, said Steve Kratz, a spokesman for the Department of Community and Economic Development. Those companies would be eligible for a credit of 5 cents per gallon of ethane purchased in Pennsylvania, for up to 20 percent of their eligible tax liability.

Companies also would be able to sell those credits to others involved in the ethane supply chain, he said.

"It's all part of a push to develop natural gas uses in the commonwealth," Mr. Kratz said. "If we passively sit and hope the market develops, we could have our natural resources piped out of state."

---------------------

Great column on this issue:

http://yinzercation.wordpress.com/2012/06/05/can-shell-educate-our-kids/

Excerpts:

"Talk about hypocrisy. Governor Corbett has been running around the state telling everyone who will listen that Pennsylvania is broke. About our schools staggering under historic budget cuts he says, “we can’t give them money we don’t have.” And he asks, “So if I’m going to propose increasing money for education, who do we take it from?” Turns out he had that backwards. Now the governor is proposing to take money from education and give it to Big Oil.

Yesterday we learned that Governor Corbett intends to give Shell Oil Co. $1.675 BILLION of our taxpayer dollars to do business in Pennsylvania. He proposes handing out $67 million a year for twenty-five years starting in 2017, ensuring that our children and grandchildren will be paying this boondoggle for years to come. This is the man who cut $1 BILLION from our schools, claiming we don’t have money, but now finds he can hand out almost twice that much to his buddies in the fracking business. Does Gov. Corbett have no shame?

The natural gas industry has contributed $1.6 million to the governor’s campaign coffers. From 2009 to 2010, Shell Oil donated more than $300,000 to Gov. Corbett. That’s a pretty big payback: put in a few hundred thousand up front, get over a billion back. If only our kids had that kind of money to donate to political campaigns to buy their own schooling. The cruel irony here is that education is the one place where a little up front investment really does pay off in a big way, for both the individual student and society as a whole.

Now the issue is not so much that the governor sweetened a deal to get a company to build a factory in our state. That’s what governors do all the time. But we’re talking about handing away our children’s future so that Shell will build a petrochemical facility here in Southwest Pennsylvania to process the natural gas that will be extracted – from here in Southwest Pennsylvania. Are we really to believe that Shell needed an extra $1.6 BILLION to be convinced that they ought to process the stuff coming out of the ground in a nearby plant?

Even taxpayers who are not horrified by the fracking process should be livid at what that $1.6 BILLION will actually buy us. That shiny new Shell plant is estimated to employ up to 10,000 people with several hundred full-time employees eventually operating the factory. Sounds nice until you consider that Pennsylvania schools eliminated or left vacant over 14,000 jobs last year alone, with thousands more teachers receiving pink slips this spring.

Seems to me we could have kept our money in our public school system and kept real people employed right now. These are well-educated professionals, key members of our communities, and critical people in the lives of our children. Governor Corbett has slashed these valuable jobs that benefit our students and society now, in favor of potentially creating fewer jobs in the future, at enormous public expense.

That’s not fiscally conservative or protecting Pennsylvania’s best interests. The only one benefiting here appears to be Big Oil. As Governor Corbett continues to de-fund public schools, is he planning to have Shell educate our children?"

7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Corbett promising $1.7 BILLION in tax breaks to Shell Corp. to build new chemical plant (Original Post) JPZenger Jun 2012 OP
Just what they need. elleng Jun 2012 #1
I hate this guy so much. I can't wait to vote the ass out of office. lookingfortruth Jun 2012 #2
On a completely unrelated topic, 350 jobs being eliminated by the Reading City School District JPZenger Jun 2012 #3
"Corbett to Shell: Here Have Everything" JPZenger Jun 2012 #4
The man is a total POS. blue neen Jun 2012 #5
This is absolutely sickening. femmocrat Jun 2012 #6
Good editorial by the Harrisburg newspaper JPZenger Jun 2012 #7

JPZenger

(6,819 posts)
4. "Corbett to Shell: Here Have Everything"
Wed Jun 6, 2012, 12:04 PM
Jun 2012
http://broadandpennsylvania.blogspot.com/2012/06/corbett-to-shell-here-have-everything.html

Excepts:

"Look, I'm not against developing the natural gas, or even getting this plant, on the surface. I'm against a dumb deal. In a state that is cutting deeply into county human service budgets, slashing teachers by the thousands, and forcing local governments into tax increases, does it make any sense for our state government to cut a deal with a company from out of state that gives them more tax credits per job than we are likely to collect in income tax revenue from the new workers created? In other words, would you give away a dollar-fifty to get a dollar back in your wallet? No, you wouldn't. This is not a bad idea, but this is a bad deal, and if it's not improved, it's one the legislature should walk away from."

-----
Here's another post: Corbett Must Have Just Won the Powerball MegaMillions Lottery to suddenly have all these hundreds of millions to give to Shell in terms of reduced state taxes.

http://jjadhoc.blogspot.com/2012/06/wow-did-governor-corbett-win-lottery.html

Excerpt:

"Pennsylvania’s broke. That’s what Governor Corbett and his surrogates have been saying for months. Last Wednesday he said this in response to a question about education funding, “So if I’m going to propose increasing money for education, who do we take it from?” he asked.

Last Sunday, the governor’s budget secretary, Charles Zogby was quoted as saying, “The governor’s philosophy going into the budget negotiations is we can spend no more than we have and we must budget and save for the future so that we’re not continually running structural deficits year after year,” Harley said.

And this morning Lt. Gov. Cawley said, “It might be a family with an autistic child, or a person struggling with addiction,” he said. “We need to be there for them. But that harsh reality is coupled with another harsh reality. And it is simply this: we can no longer spend money we don’t have.”

So I’m figuring that the governor must have won the lottery in order to be able to afford to give the Shell Oil Company, one of the richest corporations on earth, $67 million a year for 25 years for a grand total of $1.7 billion. $67 million a year - that’s more than this year’s proposed state funding for the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Aging. It’s only about $10 million less than state funding for the Department of Health.

The governor said that he wants to make sure that shiny new cracker plant gets built in Pennsylvania and creates 20,000 jobs. At $1.7 billion, he wants to give Shell $85,000 per job to come here.

The governor has already decided to cut back investments in education which enhances the quality of our society and ensures an educated workforce for the future. So he must have won the lottery or something that has given him the unlimited resources to splurge on a cracker plant. "

blue neen

(12,324 posts)
5. The man is a total POS.
Wed Jun 6, 2012, 07:35 PM
Jun 2012

He is a total corporate whore, the likes of which Pennsylvania has never seen.

Tom Corbett will rot in hell...there will be no saving his soul, simply because he doesn't have one.

femmocrat

(28,394 posts)
6. This is absolutely sickening.
Wed Jun 6, 2012, 07:38 PM
Jun 2012

I'm sure they have a cushy seat on the board waiting for him as soon as he leaves office.

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Pennsylvania»Corbett promising $1.7 BI...