Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
The NFL as a Workplace: The Prospect of Applying Occupational Health and Safety Law to NFL Workers
The NFL as a Workplace: The Prospect of Applying Occupational Health and Safety Law to Protect NFL Workers
Arizona Law Review, Vol. 60, p. 291, 2018
San Diego Legal Studies Paper No.18-344
Harvard Public Law Working Paper No. 18-26
78 Pages ● Posted: 17 Apr 2018 ● Last revised: 7 Nov 2018
Adam M. Finkel
Wharton Risk Management & Decision Processes Center, University of Pennsylvania; University of Michigan School of Public Health
Chris Deubert
Berg & Androphy
Orly Lobel
University of San Diego School of Law
I. Glenn Cohen
Harvard Law School
Holly Fernandez Lynch
Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania
Date Written: April 17, 2018
Abstract
The athletes who participate in professional football call themselves (and the public calls them) football “players,” not football “workers,” reflecting the reality that as exhausting and high-pressure as their efforts are, they are ultimately playing a sport. Nevertheless, we should not forget that these athletes indeed are workers; they have trained extensively to perform their roles, they do intense physical labor as part of their jobs, they are salaried employees of National Football League (“NFL”) clubs, and they are represented by a labor union, the National Football League Players Association (“NFLPA”).
This Article is the first to explore in depth what might happen if our society treated professional football like a workplace, subject to government regulation, public–private cooperation or other “soft law” mechanisms, or required information disclosure to facilitate more informed understanding of the variety of safety and health risks these workers face to provide fans with entertainment. Specifically, it examines how recognizing the NFL as a workplace, governed by the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”) and the law surrounding occupational health and safety, can transform our understanding of the NFL and player safety. This topic has gained considerable and growing public attention, particularly regarding the recent and controversial concerns over the possible long-term risks of neurological damage in these workers.
The Article explains that OSHA clearly has the authority to regulate the NFL. Nevertheless, there is little to no precedent or guidance for OSHA to insert itself into the on-the-field aspects of professional sports. We discuss in detail the small body of case law that bears on OSHA’s authority in entertainment and sports, which opens some doors for OSHA to issue standards but also sets limits on its ability to alter the nature of the entertainment or sport. But more importantly, there are a host of political and practical reasons we discuss, which make it very unlikely that OSHA will attempt to regulate the NFL. Nevertheless, there are a wide variety of ways for OSHA to intervene or involve itself without regulating, as discussed at length in the Article. Adding a public institution like OSHA as a party to existing labor-management discussions concerning health and safety may be the best natural evolution of the issue.
Many in the public seem to believe that football must become safer to thrive and hope that it will. Regulations or “soft law” approaches have sometimes worked well even in complicated, uncertain, and fraught issues. OSHA understands evidence from a public health lens, and it is the institution empowered by Congress and the courts to help balance the competing goals of worker protection versus cost and liberty in an open setting. So we place the onus on OSHA in this Article: the agency should be more willing to step up to this challenge and less conflicted about offering to participate in an issue where it has expertise complementary to that which the NFL and NFLPA bring, as well as a unique opportunity to help bring about constructive change.
Keywords: NFL, NFLPA, OSHA, concussions, CTE, CBA
Suggested Citation:
Finkel, Adam M. and Deubert, Chris and Lobel, Orly and Cohen, I. Glenn and Lynch, Holly Fernandez, The NFL as a Workplace: The Prospect of Applying Occupational Health and Safety Law to Protect NFL Workers (April 17, 2018). Arizona Law Review, Vol. 60, p. 291, 2018; San Diego Legal Studies Paper No.18-344; Harvard Public Law Working Paper No. 18-26. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3161763
Arizona Law Review, Vol. 60, p. 291, 2018
San Diego Legal Studies Paper No.18-344
Harvard Public Law Working Paper No. 18-26
78 Pages ● Posted: 17 Apr 2018 ● Last revised: 7 Nov 2018
Adam M. Finkel
Wharton Risk Management & Decision Processes Center, University of Pennsylvania; University of Michigan School of Public Health
Chris Deubert
Berg & Androphy
Orly Lobel
University of San Diego School of Law
I. Glenn Cohen
Harvard Law School
Holly Fernandez Lynch
Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania
Date Written: April 17, 2018
Abstract
The athletes who participate in professional football call themselves (and the public calls them) football “players,” not football “workers,” reflecting the reality that as exhausting and high-pressure as their efforts are, they are ultimately playing a sport. Nevertheless, we should not forget that these athletes indeed are workers; they have trained extensively to perform their roles, they do intense physical labor as part of their jobs, they are salaried employees of National Football League (“NFL”) clubs, and they are represented by a labor union, the National Football League Players Association (“NFLPA”).
This Article is the first to explore in depth what might happen if our society treated professional football like a workplace, subject to government regulation, public–private cooperation or other “soft law” mechanisms, or required information disclosure to facilitate more informed understanding of the variety of safety and health risks these workers face to provide fans with entertainment. Specifically, it examines how recognizing the NFL as a workplace, governed by the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”) and the law surrounding occupational health and safety, can transform our understanding of the NFL and player safety. This topic has gained considerable and growing public attention, particularly regarding the recent and controversial concerns over the possible long-term risks of neurological damage in these workers.
The Article explains that OSHA clearly has the authority to regulate the NFL. Nevertheless, there is little to no precedent or guidance for OSHA to insert itself into the on-the-field aspects of professional sports. We discuss in detail the small body of case law that bears on OSHA’s authority in entertainment and sports, which opens some doors for OSHA to issue standards but also sets limits on its ability to alter the nature of the entertainment or sport. But more importantly, there are a host of political and practical reasons we discuss, which make it very unlikely that OSHA will attempt to regulate the NFL. Nevertheless, there are a wide variety of ways for OSHA to intervene or involve itself without regulating, as discussed at length in the Article. Adding a public institution like OSHA as a party to existing labor-management discussions concerning health and safety may be the best natural evolution of the issue.
Many in the public seem to believe that football must become safer to thrive and hope that it will. Regulations or “soft law” approaches have sometimes worked well even in complicated, uncertain, and fraught issues. OSHA understands evidence from a public health lens, and it is the institution empowered by Congress and the courts to help balance the competing goals of worker protection versus cost and liberty in an open setting. So we place the onus on OSHA in this Article: the agency should be more willing to step up to this challenge and less conflicted about offering to participate in an issue where it has expertise complementary to that which the NFL and NFLPA bring, as well as a unique opportunity to help bring about constructive change.
Keywords: NFL, NFLPA, OSHA, concussions, CTE, CBA
Suggested Citation:
Finkel, Adam M. and Deubert, Chris and Lobel, Orly and Cohen, I. Glenn and Lynch, Holly Fernandez, The NFL as a Workplace: The Prospect of Applying Occupational Health and Safety Law to Protect NFL Workers (April 17, 2018). Arizona Law Review, Vol. 60, p. 291, 2018; San Diego Legal Studies Paper No.18-344; Harvard Public Law Working Paper No. 18-26. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3161763
1 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
= new reply since forum marked as read
