Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cartoonist

(7,316 posts)
Sun Mar 1, 2015, 10:36 PM Mar 2015

Atheist book review



Last month I finished reading The Black Tower by Louis Bayard. It was a novel set in 19th century France. It concerned the dauphin and a detective name Vidocq. I enjoyed the reading. I like historical novels, and this one had its humorous moments, so I was eager to read another novel by Bayard.



This one really went straight to my heart as it concerned historical figures that were of interest to me. Alas, this one lacked the humor of its predecessor. It also went back and forth from the past to the present. The characters in the present were, for the most part, unlikeable and uninteresting. Still, I soldiered on and am now in the final chapters. I may or may not finish it, but I want to quote from it, so I won't wait until I reach the end.

The main characters in the past were in a group of atheists that formed a club later given the name The School of Night. Its two main fugures were Sir Walter Ralegh and Thomas Harriot. The latter is an interesting figure. I went to my library to see if there was a biography about him, but they didn't have one. I'll have to go somewhere else to track one down.

Here are a few paragraphs he says in the later chapters about his experience with the native Americans:

-Oh, you may look with scorn upon these savages, so like unto sheep. But now I ask you my friends. Were you and I any different in how we came to God? Were we not, as children, seduced by tricks--by music and incense and signs and omens? Were we not dazzled by power? Our parents, our priests, our kings and queens, all claiming a divine sanction for their sovereignty over us? Were we any less credulous than the natives of Virginia? Any less quick to obey?

-From the very moment of our birth, we were played upon. And we were conquered, gentlemen, just as surely as the Algonkins. Why? Because without our consent, without the consent of all men, a society--a church--a monarchy--cannot hope to endure. It follows, then, that said consent must be secured by the quickest and surest means to hand. Which is to say . . . God.

-Tonight, then, I ask you. Has God ever spoken to you? His mouth to your ear? Or was God just the birch rod that brought you to your knees?
1 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Atheist book review (Original Post) Cartoonist Mar 2015 OP
lots of hits on Amazon RussBLib Mar 2015 #1

RussBLib

(9,008 posts)
1. lots of hits on Amazon
Mon Mar 2, 2015, 06:09 PM
Mar 2015

My library has only one book, "Thomas Harriot: Science Pioneer" and it's classified as a Kids book.

blurb about the book:

Although during his lifetime the bulk of his work went unpublished, Renaissance scholar Thomas Harriot is now recognized as a major contributor to many fields of learning, such as mathematics, astronomy, and botany. Harriot's theories, inventions, and discoveries were as groundbreaking as they were controversial. From his daring exploration of the New World to his scientific findings on subjects as diverse as alchemy and the moons of Jupiter, Harriot's accomplishments reflect the endless curiosity of a remarkable mind. The author draws on the diary entries of Harriot's close friend, Thomas Buckner, and Harriot's own maps, diagrams, and handwritten notes, to capture the authentic flavor of an extraordinary time, as well as the enigmatic character of a genius.


From the very moment of our birth, we were played upon. And we were conquered, gentlemen, just as surely as the Algonkins. Why? Because without our consent, without the consent of all men, a society--a church--a monarchy--cannot hope to endure. It follows, then, that said consent must be secured by the quickest and surest means to hand.

get 'em while they're young

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»Atheist book review