2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumThe GOP is Gaslighting America — on National Television
https://www.texasobserver.org/how-the-gop-is-gaslighting-america/meow2u3
(24,761 posts)marked50
(1,366 posts)VOX
(22,976 posts)WhiteTara
(29,706 posts)I am going to start this piece with a statement of fact, about which I entirely refuse to entertain debate: The speech that Melania Trump gave at the Republican National Convention in Cleveland on Monday night was plagiarized from Michelle Obamas historic 2008 address to the Democratic National Convention.
I am a professional writer. I have taught college students. I know plagiarism when I see it, and thats what this is. Trump, or her speech writer, lifted whole phrases and sentences in order from the woman (notably, and well get to this, the black woman) who would go on to become the First Lady. Any student of mine would have flunked that assignment, and very likely been disciplined for violating the University of Texas code of conduct.
The Trump campaigns response has been to deny the plagiarism outright and, importantly, to question the ability of people who know the speech was plagiarized to understand, explain and identify reality. Heres Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort, talking to CNN:
Manafort denied allegations that Melania Trump plagiarized a Michelle Obama speech on the first night of the Republican National Convention, calling the accusation just really absurd.
applegrove
(118,642 posts)WhiteTara
(29,706 posts)It was such a necessary read, I was hoping more people would pick up on your OP. I wasn't sure about copy right laws, so I posted 2 excerpts.
WhiteTara
(29,706 posts)To think that she would do something like that knowing how scrutinized her speech was going to be last night is just really absurd, Manafort told CNNs Chris Cuomo on New Day.
Theres a word for what Manaforts doing there: gaslighting, as MTV News Jamil Smith pointed out on Twitter Tuesday morning. Gaslighting is a psychological tactic used by abusers, particularly but not only domestic abusers, to confuse, shame and manipulate others into believing that they cannot accurately interpret reality. Trump spokesperson Katrina Pierson echoed Manafort later on Tuesday, flat-out denying that the speech was plagiarized. She too used the word absurd.
Absurd is no accident. Its a short couple steps from crazy, and in the realm of unreal, preposterous and bizarre. The Trump campaign is using that word to call anyone who sees the blatant plagiarism in Melania Trumps speech, basically, a nutzo-whackjob.
If youve been in an abusive relationship, you know this pattern. Thinking, day after day: Today will be the day I prove that I am not crazy, that I can do things right, that the way I see things is real.
Look at the way this played out on CNN. The Trump campaign simply refuses to engage with plain truth, forcing the media, Trumps critics and anyone else who knows plagiarism when they see it to engage in an infuriating and impossible battle to win an argument over something about which they are already correct.
more at link
https://www.texasobserver.org/how-the-gop-is-gaslighting-america/