Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Fawke Em

(11,366 posts)
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 12:47 PM Jan 2016

The “Bernie Bros” Narrative: a Cheap Campaign Tactic Masquerading as Journalism and Social Activism

(Caveat: Glenn Greenwald is a personal acquaintance of mine. I am a former member of Investigative Reporters and Editors, where we met and we speak occasionally on social media about our rescued pets. Never worked with him, but I have worked - recently, as a matter of fact - for Russ Baker. If I post any article by either, I will point out my friendships with them. I do hate it when some DUers slam Greenwald. He's really not a right-winger in any sense and don't know how anyone could possibly think that. He moved out of the damn country so he could marry David, for Pete's sake.)

The concoction of the “Bernie Bro” narrative by pro-Clinton journalists has been a potent political tactic – and a journalistic disgrace. It’s intended to imply two equally false claims: (1) a refusal to march enthusiastically behind the Wall-Street-enriched, multiple-war-advocating, despot-embracing Hillary Clinton is explainable not by ideology or political conviction, but largely if not exclusively by sexism: demonstrated by the fact that men, not women, support Sanders (his supporters are “bros”); and (2) Sanders supporters are uniquely abusive and misogynistic in their online behavior. Needless to say, a crucial tactical prong of this innuendo is that any attempt to refute it is itself proof of insensitivity to sexism if not sexism itself (as the accusatory reactions to this article will instantly illustrate).

It’s become such an all-purpose, handy pro-Clinton smear that even consummate, actual “bros” for which the term was originally coined – straight guys who act with entitlement and aggression, such as Paul Krugman – are now reflexively (and unironically) applying it to anyone who speaks ill of Hillary Clinton, even when they know nothing else about the people they’re smearing, including their gender, age or sexual orientation. Thus, a male policy analyst who criticized Sanders’ health care plan “is getting the Bernie Bro treatment,” sneered Krugman. Unfortunately for The New York Times Bro, that analyst, Charles Gaba, said in response that he’s “really not comfortable with [Krugman’s] referring to die-hard Bernie Sanders supporters as ‘Bernie Bros'” because it “implies that only college-age men support Sen. Sanders, which obviously isn’t the case.”

It is indeed “obviously not the case.” There are literally millions of women who support Sanders over Clinton. A new Iowa poll yesterday shows Sanders with a 15-point lead over Clinton among women under 45, while 1/3 of Iowa women over 45 support him. A USA Today/Rock-the-Vote poll from two weeks ago found Sanders nationally “with a 19-point lead over front-runner Hillary Clinton, 50% to 31%, among Democratic and independent women ages 18 to 34.” One has to be willing to belittle the views and erase the existence of a huge number of American women to wield this “Bernie Bro” smear.


https://theintercept.com/2016/01/31/the-bernie-bros-narrative-a-cheap-false-campaign-tactic-masquerading-as-journalism-and-social-activism/


Psst... Here's Glenn with a few of his (at my last count) 13 rescued animals (mostly dogs, some cats).

8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The “Bernie Bros” Narrative: a Cheap Campaign Tactic Masquerading as Journalism and Social Activism (Original Post) Fawke Em Jan 2016 OP
As a middle aged woman supporting Sanders TDale313 Jan 2016 #1
I find it more than irritating dana_b Jan 2016 #3
I'm 46, female and Southern. Fawke Em Jan 2016 #5
Wish I could move out of the country ErisDiscordia Jan 2016 #2
I've seen the memes on facebook - TBF Jan 2016 #4
Do you have a link that that post of hers? Fawke Em Jan 2016 #6
Go to her page on Facebook - TBF Jan 2016 #7
Well, I was polite, but not kind. Fawke Em Jan 2016 #8

TDale313

(7,820 posts)
1. As a middle aged woman supporting Sanders
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 12:55 PM
Jan 2016

I find the Bernie Bro meme lazy and kinda irritating. But hey, it seems like attacks on Bernie's supporters are all they got.

dana_b

(11,546 posts)
3. I find it more than irritating
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 01:04 PM
Jan 2016

but obviously it's a tactic and we just have to dispel this myth and blow it off.

It's insulting to anyone who isn't a young-ish man (i.e. myself) but also to the young men who are Bernie supporters. They are not all BROS and just because some are young men, it doesn't make them young meat heads with that Bro attitude.

I think the Clinton campaign is just a bit jealous that they are having difficulty getting young people - especially men - to their side.

Fawke Em

(11,366 posts)
5. I'm 46, female and Southern.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 01:39 PM
Jan 2016

It's highly amusing to me when I'm accused of being a Bernie Bro by Hillary fans on social media, especially since my avatar is of Lara from Dr. Zhivago (where my parents got my given name from). You know, coz so many "Bernie Bros" would have Lara as an avatar.

TBF

(32,057 posts)
4. I've seen the memes on facebook -
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 01:13 PM
Jan 2016

stupid establishment people calling "Bernie Bros" a sexist mob.

And this is what I have to say to Randi Weingarten (her account posted one of them):

With your salary you should be absolutely ashamed of yourself for selling out your fellow union members (and I am saying this as someone who has a household income similar to Weingarten's & probably the same types of debts that make us decidedly not 1% when we take off the mortgage and student loans). It is still, however, more money than many folks worldwide ever dream of. As I carefully pay those tuition loans, and send a little to Bernie Sanders every month, I think about all of those people who didn't have the luck we had and are no where near as fortunate as we are. We were lucky to be part of that generation that actually had reasonable tuition, factory jobs, safety nets. Now those things are falling by the wayside. And we have a choice here. We can be greedy and keep as much as we can for ourselves, fellow professionals, and keep propping up the really rich folks - OR we can do the right thing and back the candidate who has the interests of the entire country at heart. It's a very simple choice for me. And I see Randi Weingarten that your choice seems to be easy as well. Your choice is to prop up the rich folks.

TBF

(32,057 posts)
7. Go to her page on Facebook -
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 01:43 PM
Jan 2016

currently it's the 4th post down. I don't want to link because it will give my identifying information. You will see it - she posted an article from Mashable.

She says this: So many of us on social media get badgered by supposive Bernie supporters the moment we say something supportive of Hillary... please read this piece... I like Bernie and what he represents.... I believe as does my union that Hillary -not only shares those values- but would be the more effective President in pursuing an agenda of helping working class Americans....

And then like the asshole she is she links to this: http://mashable.com/2016/01/29/bernie-sanders-berniebros/#AgrGu9GAdmqm

I LOATHE her.

Fawke Em

(11,366 posts)
8. Well, I was polite, but not kind.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 01:59 PM
Jan 2016
Randi, as a FEMALE Bernie supporter, from the South, with two children in public school, I can tell you that A. I'm no Bernie Bro and B. I don't know a teacher who supports Clinton. The schools my children attend have high rates of children on free school lunches and are squarely in a middle and working class area of town, ironically where most of the union halls are located. I don't see much support for Clinton, but I do see a lot of enthusiasm for Bernie.

You're not being badgered by "sexist" Bernie Bros because you support the female candidate. You're being badgered because of your top-down "leadership" that foisted the support of her candidacy on its members without fully pushing a poll that few members knew existed.

Bernie is not a radical. His ideas are squarely those of FDR, Truman and even Eisenhower. We Bernie supporters are tired of the establishment cronyism that has led to the middle class, which includes many teachers, being nearly annihilated. It's time for a true change in direction in this country and Clinton simply doesn't represent that. In fact, if she were president in 1960, she would not have supported going to the moon because it might be "too hard" and the "powers that be" wouldn't have wanted to spend the money on it. In fact, Bernie has managed to do more in Congress than Clinton could ever dream of doing.

Finally, since you posted a ridiculous article from the likes of Mashable, I'll leave you with a more insightful article by a real investigative journalist, Glenn Greenwald, which blows that tabloid trash out of the water. I hope you make time to read it.


(And I linked this article and I linked to Glenn since he's a friend and his name auto-populated. LOL.)
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Bernie Sanders»The “Bernie Bros” Narrati...