Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: All hands on deck. A call for national service. [View all]bluecollar2
(3,622 posts)112. No they wouldn't...n/t
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
120 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Not saying we do not need an Infrastructure Project. The American Society of Civil Engineers
c-rational
Jul 2018
#4
I have loved the idea for years...National Service could make this nation heal old wounds...
Moostache
Jul 2018
#3
Because every bill that has been introduced has required (military) basic training
Ms. Toad
Jul 2018
#42
No we are citizens - teacher's assistants, health care helpers, park helpers, and many more.
c-rational
Jul 2018
#10
Conscription is the most undemocratic thing a representative government can do - (obviously
Midwestern Democrat
Jul 2018
#78
WWII got us out of the Depression and we aren't in the Depression and were those men forced into
braddy
Jul 2018
#30
I knew they weren't forced, and they and the depression aren't relevant to this threads proposal, or
braddy
Jul 2018
#57
Employers are desperate for workers and working for welfare is held as a no go, we are not in the
braddy
Jul 2018
#76
Are you on the right thread? ""mandatory national service. All Americans are required to serve.""
braddy
Jul 2018
#82
Voluntary isn't what the thread is about and voluntary is called a job, we have plenty of those now,
braddy
Jul 2018
#88
We are in all but name, when the majority of Americans can't even lay their hands on $400 ...
Hekate
Jul 2018
#75
You are the only one in this thread who blathers on about slavery.Nobody is proposing any such thing
Hekate
Jul 2018
#79
LOL, no, and I didn't know that was required to disagree with being drafted as a slave to the gov.
braddy
Jul 2018
#85
My grandfather was an electrician in the CCC after he lost his business in the Depression...
Hekate
Jul 2018
#67
Yes, I believe it should be mandatory like jury duty. I see it as an equalizer.
c-rational
Jul 2018
#11
National service will lead to the deportation of all Asian Americans to China, got it.
braddy
Jul 2018
#26
It was the continued answer to my question responding to post 13, which left out the Asians,
braddy
Jul 2018
#38
I see it differently but post your reasons. Programs like this have worked before.
brush
Jul 2018
#37
I'm not suggesting anything of the sort. Those details are not unsolvable problems.
brush
Jul 2018
#55
There are actually progressive organizations that structure their pay that way
Ms. Toad
Jul 2018
#94
Not at all. I for one do not believe the unemployment numbers given. I believe there are a lot
c-rational
Jul 2018
#63
Thank you. I like your structure also, and the title universal service obligation.
c-rational
Jul 2018
#71
Agreed it would take a lot of work to make it work well and fairly, and a task worth undertaking imo
c-rational
Jul 2018
#72
Right now we need to get rid of the GOP. If they try their hands at this it will be a nightmare...
Hekate
Jul 2018
#73
This is not a call for voluntary service. All are included and you get paid. One year of service
c-rational
Jul 2018
#97
Do not know what an SIL is, but I am pro union. This is not meant to compete with private sector
c-rational
Jul 2018
#107
I will not indenture myself to a government that controls so many aspects of my life.
Orsino
Jul 2018
#113
I disagree with the unemployment figures published, but the idea for national service is not just
c-rational
Jul 2018
#117