Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PoindexterOglethorpe

(25,853 posts)
58. I honestly don't get this crate thing.
Mon Dec 2, 2019, 01:13 AM
Dec 2019

Here's what you REALLY need to think about:

Dogs are very attuned to humans. They need us a whole lot more than we (as individuals) need them. If you are going to take a dog into your life and then be gone more than 8 hours at a stretch, re-think having a dog. Yeah. Re-think it. Either figure out a way that the dog won't be left alone so long, or get a fish or a parrot or a cat. All of them are fine without humans around as much.

As for the crate: Would you be happy being in a cell that allows you to stand up and move around and nothing else for that many hours a day? Really? And if he's in the crate and just a few feet from you, why exactly is he in the crate? You must be a huge fan of prison cells.

Some years ago I did volunteer work at a local animal shelter, staffing the greeting desk on weekends. It was a small shelter, actually a home that had been donated and wasn't really very suitable to be an animal shelter but it was better than nothing. All of the dog walkers had to bring the dogs past me to take them outside and bring them back. I was struck by how every single dog wanted to greet every single human they passed. Wow. I have never been much of a dog person (cats, that's what I prefer) but this was an amazing and wonderful experience to learn about dogs. They evolved alongside us. They need us. Do not put them in a small prison for any part of the day. Don't.

Do you have a garage? montanacowboy Dec 2019 #1
Too cold underpants Dec 2019 #13
Nearly Impossible to freeze s healthy dog to death. Drahthaardogs Dec 2019 #38
It's a tough problem. LuckyCharms Dec 2019 #2
I'm not quite sure what the question is... but MissB Dec 2019 #3
I train dogs on the side Drahthaardogs Dec 2019 #4
That's 16 hrs outside the crate. give them love for that time. Kurt V. Dec 2019 #5
Realistically, less than 8 hours - Ms. Toad Dec 2019 #53
My dogs have run of the house - when I'm out they sleep womanofthehills Dec 2019 #6
You should commit to Doggie Daycare twice a week. LakeArenal Dec 2019 #7
Why did you get a dog? procon Dec 2019 #8
Post removed Post removed Dec 2019 #15
Post removed Post removed Dec 2019 #20
S underpants Dec 2019 #21
That sums up the whole problem...yeah? nt procon Dec 2019 #25
Off underpants Dec 2019 #29
LOL CatWoman Dec 2019 #44
It's called crate training. Geesh. nt UniteFightBack Dec 2019 #17
Does the dog have some kind of behavioral issue that mandates he be crated? Arazi Dec 2019 #9
He's been pretty good underpants Dec 2019 #22
I have never had a crate for a dog. I have 4 cats now, but I had dogs in the past. I've tblue37 Dec 2019 #30
Well...if you got a tall dog gate, one you could secure...you could put doggie in a laundry room/ Karadeniz Dec 2019 #10
I've had dogs and worked full time for decades. roody Dec 2019 #11
Get a pet sitter to come noonish. leftyladyfrommo Dec 2019 #12
Yeah I wanted to keep the post short. underpants Dec 2019 #14
I was gone 12 hours a day so I made her a little 'apartment' in my kitchen. I had her crate, UniteFightBack Dec 2019 #16
Why does the dog need to be in a crate? jcgoldie Dec 2019 #18
It's a standard thing underpants Dec 2019 #24
I dont need to answer anything jcgoldie Dec 2019 #28
😯 underpants Dec 2019 #31
It's for the dog's safety, too. Jane Austin Dec 2019 #60
whatever jcgoldie Dec 2019 #63
You don't even know me. Jane Austin Dec 2019 #65
Sorry I was using the generic "you" jcgoldie Dec 2019 #68
Try something like this... sop Dec 2019 #19
I have had dogs all my life. Tipperary Dec 2019 #23
I just got a German Shepard puppy ismnotwasm Dec 2019 #26
Why must he be crated while you are gone? Dog-proof an area and put doggy wee wee pads down. emmaverybo Dec 2019 #27
We've always crate trained our puppies. docgee Dec 2019 #32
Puppies though should not be more than 3-4 hours in the crate because their bladders emmaverybo Dec 2019 #37
I agree ismnotwasm Dec 2019 #50
Oh, nice guardians. emmaverybo Dec 2019 #56
Good stuff about crating here and aspca also a good doggie care resource. emmaverybo Dec 2019 #33
Why did you get a dog? WhiskeyGrinder Dec 2019 #34
I never crated my dogs. drray23 Dec 2019 #35
We've never had crates. Liberal In Texas Dec 2019 #36
Try setting up an area with easy clean flooring, use BABY GATES appalachiablue Dec 2019 #39
All my dogs have always LOVED their crates. Coventina Dec 2019 #40
jinx. mopinko Dec 2019 #43
LOL! GMTA! Coventina Dec 2019 #45
Mine, too. Jane Austin Dec 2019 #61
my advice is prolly dont ask about animals on du, but you are doing fine. mopinko Dec 2019 #41
I agree with you! LeftInTX Dec 2019 #46
Our chihuahua was never fully potty trained LeftInTX Dec 2019 #42
So much depends on the individual dog. defacto7 Dec 2019 #47
With an older dog, like yours is, you can ALSO pnwmom Dec 2019 #48
Uniquely american thing. drray23 Dec 2019 #49
Doggy Day Camp TruckFump Dec 2019 #51
We never crated the dog we had. LisaL Dec 2019 #52
Find a way for the crate to be the exception, rather than the norm. Ms. Toad Dec 2019 #54
You may not need to crate the dog at all. Liberty Belle Dec 2019 #55
Get a copy of The Loved Dog by Tamar Geller. madaboutharry Dec 2019 #57
I honestly don't get this crate thing. PoindexterOglethorpe Dec 2019 #58
We crated our puppy until about 18 months ribrepin Dec 2019 #59
Not all dogs are the same. StarryNite Dec 2019 #62
Excellent question & sorry you are getting so much flack. Hekate Dec 2019 #64
We adopted our little terrier between blizzards, and she never went outside Croney Dec 2019 #66
People have a tendency to project human values onto animals. madaboutharry Dec 2019 #67
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Dog - crate - sorry it's ...»Reply #58