Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

dpibel

(2,831 posts)
34. Legislation is not a "dry erase board"?
Thu Jun 30, 2022, 05:32 PM
Jun 2022

I have to be entirely misreading you.

It appears to me that you are arguing that legislative acts are less mutable than court decisions.

I'm not aware why it's stronger to have Congress declare Roe to the the law of the land than to have the Court do so. Do you actually think that this Court would have hesitated to strike down a codification of Roe?

Plus, legislation is subject to attack not just by the Supremes, but by any contrary Congress that comes along with enough votes to repeal a statute.

If you are arguing that the antidemocratic intransigence of the legislative process protects against such repeal, then you are making the point that others have made in this thread: When was the moment when that intransigence could have been overcome to enact a Roe law?

I must be missing something in your argument.

The court can and does overturn laws that congress passed, so I guess I don't understand your post emulatorloo Jun 2022 #1
Codifying Roe is the biggest example at hand Sympthsical Jun 2022 #2
I still don't understand your post. This court would have overturned a Roe v Wade law. emulatorloo Jun 2022 #10
What's your evidence of this? Sympthsical Jun 2022 #17
We need to vote Democratic in order to change the make up of the courts. emulatorloo Jun 2022 #32
Where I agree inthewind21 Jun 2022 #12
It is not ALWAYS the final stop Effete Snob Jun 2022 #30
Congress can and does pass laws that supersede court decisions Effete Snob Jun 2022 #29
Thanks appreciate it. emulatorloo Jun 2022 #33
Yes and no. unblock Jun 2022 #3
Congress inthewind21 Jun 2022 #13
Well yes, an act of congress allowing federal funds for abortion unblock Jun 2022 #21
Congress can get rid of the Hyde amendment Effete Snob Jun 2022 #31
Another blame the Democrats post...and we will accomplish nothing if we lose elections...and courts Demsrule86 Jun 2022 #4
Exactly. Kingofalldems Jun 2022 #6
You're doing a fine job of illustrating my point Sympthsical Jun 2022 #11
Nah your proving their point. You're condemning 'congress as a whole', but you're acting as if emulatorloo Jun 2022 #14
I'm not sure if we're thinking about the same issues. BlueCheeseAgain Jun 2022 #5
The reliance on executive orders is a big problem Sympthsical Jun 2022 #15
I was going to (and probably still will) write a post that gets at what you posted In It to Win It Jun 2022 #7
Your OP is very good. It is pragmatic and strategic n/t emulatorloo Jun 2022 #19
Thank you! In It to Win It Jun 2022 #25
When was this magical window when Roe could have been codified? maxsolomon Jun 2022 #8
When is there ever a magical window for anything? Sympthsical Jun 2022 #16
Your Party loyalty should remain because there is no other choice. maxsolomon Jun 2022 #20
Isn't that "Who's better?" question illustrative of the problem Sympthsical Jun 2022 #23
McConnell 'does fine' because of the fillibuster. Biden is trying to get Senate Democrats to kill emulatorloo Jun 2022 #22
Simple question: Will we have 60 senators after November? Sympthsical Jun 2022 #24
Burden of Competent Governing Aepps22 Jun 2022 #27
That is true to a great extent Effete Snob Jun 2022 #9
Mainly because of the F'ing fillibuster... Kill the supermajority BS JCMach1 Jun 2022 #18
Dumb Americans want everything to be black and white BootinUp Jun 2022 #26
This is all very true. PTWB Jun 2022 #28
Legislation is not a "dry erase board"? dpibel Jun 2022 #34
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I can't shake the feeling...»Reply #34