General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Comey: The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly [View all]
I dont care about politics. I dont care about expediency. I dont care about friendship. I care about doing the right thing.
-- James Comey; US Senate confirmation hearings, October 2003.
On May 29, 2013, it was announced that President Obama would appoint James Comey to replace Robert Mueller III as the director of the FBI. This does not come as a surprise, since Comey is one of President Obamas potential next choices for a seat on the US Supreme Court. It seems fair to say, however, that not all Democrats are pleased with Comey being appointed as FBI director, and that the possibility of his being placed on the USSC would be viewed negatively by those same folks.
Not surprisingly, a number of forum members here have voiced opposition to yesterdays White House announcement. Likewise, some expressed support, and still others are taking a wait-and-see position. Because of this, I thought it might be worthwhile for me to contribute an essay that takes an objective look at Comey.
There are enough good and bad things about James B. Comey, Jr., that Im confident this can only serve to reinforce the opinions people have already had about him. In fact, Id be shocked if anything that I know about him changes anyones thinking about him being selected to serve as the director of the FBI. But I did notice that a few opinions that have been expressed about Comey suggested that he is relatively unknown to many forum participants.
Comey graduated from the College of William and Mary in 1982. He majored in chemistry and religion. Curiously, for his thesis, he wrote a comparison of the theology of Reinhold Niebuhr and Jerry Falwell, a snake oil salesman who was exercising significant political influence at that time. In my opinion, that was an interesting topic for a 22-year old to consider at the time.
Three years later, he earned his degree at the University of Chicago Law School. He served as a clerk to US District Court Judge John Walker, Jr.; and then joined a law firm. Comey also taught at the University of Richmond School of Law.
From 1996 to 2001, Comey was a deputy at the US Attorneys Office in the Southern District of New York. He prosecuted the Gambino crime family, and was lead prosecutor in the Khobar Towers bombing case.
In 2001, NY Senator Chuck Schumer helped get Comey appointed as the US Attorney for the Southern District, NY. He started in that position in January, 2002. His primary focus there was prosecuting corporate crimes. One of the cases that came up involved Martha Stewart, who was being investigated for securities fraud and obstruction of justice. Comey would prosecute Stewart for the obstruction charge.
On December 11, 2003, Comey became second in charge of the Office of the Attorney General. Being selected by the Bush White House to serve John Ashcroft gives us good reason to question if President Obama is making a terrible choice now. Lets take a minute to consider why he was picked then, and how he served Ashcroft.
Lets start by agreeing that John Ashcroft is a bad example of humanity, and an even worse politician. Uptight, judgmental, and a close personal friend of Injustice Clarence Thomas, Ashcroft is the type of christian who would reject Reinhold while embracing Falwell. As two-term governor of Missouri, Ashcroft was a typical law and order republican: he increased the number of both police, and inmates serving long sentences in state prison. And he was strongly opposed to hate crimes legislation.
Ashcroft also served in the US Senate. His primary role was being a lap dog for industry. However, he did join Russ Feingold in holding hearings on racial profiling, and stated that it was clearly unconstitutional. Ashcroft even recommended that police be ordered to keep statistics on those they pulled over, etc.
Now, lets be clear: John Ashcroft did not do this for the right reason. Rather, he was ambitious, believing that he had the right stuff to win the presidency. After Al Gore won the 2000 presidential election, and Clarence and friends over-ruled the American voters by installing George W. Bush instead, Ashcroft took the position of Attorney General. He hoped it would add to his list of qualifications for high office in the future.
The Bush-Cheney administration included two sects (which did have some overlap). There were Cheneys necroconservatives, in charge of foreign policy ( this included oil interests and war hawks). Another group, which included Ashcroft, had domestic policy as their primary interest; this group included several Yale skull & bones fellows, by no coincidence.
This is not to suggest that Ashcroft would oppose the Cheneyites war policies in the Middle East. Indeed, his perverted form of christianity was invested in the very concept. However, by mid-2003, the administration was involved in the war in Afghanistan and in Iraq, and dealing with both the Patriot Act and the Plame Scandal at home. This created problems for Ashcroft. Friends told journalists that these events caused as much trouble for poor John as his wifes discovering that he was engaged in a kinky sexual affair with Michelle Bachman. (Okay: I just made that last part up
.not so much out of thin air, as being the result of the cold beer I am consuming in the 90+ degree upstate New York weather. Still, I have no evidence that it is NOT true, enough to convict many in America.)
It wasnt only people like Karl Rove and Scooter Libby who were becoming the focus of controversy. Alberto Gonzales and others closer to Ashcroft than Cheney were also sitting on the hot seat. Ashcroft brought in Comey so that he could recuse himself from certain controversies -- a practice that should not inspire trust in Attorney Generals, in my view. And, again, it is important to keep in mind that at this time, Ashcroft was still intent upon a future presidential run.
In March, 2003, the Justice Department deemed the domestic spying program Stellar Wind to be illegal. The following day, Ashcroft became seriously ill with pancreatitis, and was hospitalized in rough condition. Comey, as acting director of the Justice Department, refused to sign on to the spy program. Thus, Andrew Card and Alberto Gonzales were dispatched to the Washington University Hospital to have Ashcroft sign on to Stellar Wind.
Alerted to this, Comey and Jack Goldsmith (also from Justice), rushed to the hospital to keep Ashcrofts limp, semi-conscious body from signing the papers Card and Gonzales were bringing. At the time, the limp and para-conscious corporate media hinted at what was going on, but it wasnt until Comeys May 16, 2007 testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee that Comey confirmed what had happened.
Comey testified that both Robert Mueller and he were prepared to resign in protest, if President Bush had signed the objectionable parts of the NSAs domestic surveillance program into law. Bush was alerted to the potentially damaging resignations -- more were preparing to join Mueller and Comey -- and so he met with Comey. (His testimony indicated that Comey was shocked at how uninformed Bush was of what was the Cheneyites policy.) Bush made minor changes, and over-ruled Justice.
Certainly, one can make a solid case that Comey should have opposed the Patriot Act, and programs like Stellar Wind more forcefully, and resigned when Bush decided to follow most of VP Cheneys unconstitutional plan for the militarization of American society. And that is an important point -- at least in my opinion: the USA is not a police state today, its a military state. And as a military state, that Bill of Rights is being crushed and destroyed.
Comey was involved in the investigation of a related series of crimes, known collectively as the Plame Scandal. During his confirmation hearings, Senator Schumer had asked James pointedly what he was prepared to do about the scandal? Comey said that he would have an answer for Schumer in early January. In fact, he would appoint Patrick Fitzgerald as the special prosecutor to handle the case.
There were republicans who strongly opposed Fitzgeralds being appointed to anything. Two examples are Peter Fitzgerald (Senator) and Dennis Hastert ( Governor/ Congressman).Hastert, for younger readers, was a sad excuse for a Speaker of the House. After Newt Gingrich stepped down in utter disgrace in 1998, the republican party picked Bob Livingston to serve as Speaker; Hustler magazine put an end to that. Their next choice was Dick Armey; he was exposed as being himself. Next, they looked to Tom DeLay. Finally, they agreed upon the 4th choice -- Dennis Hastert. (See the September 2005 article in Vanity Fair per Sibel Edmonds information on Hasterts friendship with a Turkish target of intelligence surveillance.)
On December 30, Comey named Fitzgerald to handle the Plame Scandal; Will Pitt wrote what I consider the best article on the scandal to date; and I joined the Democratic Underground.
The investigation began as an effort to determine if the leak of Valerie Plames name had violated the Intelligence Identities Security Act. Early on, Fitzgerald saw that there was a coordinated effort -- coming specifically from the Office of the Vice President -- to cover-up accurate information on the scandal. Hence, Fitzgerald approached Comey, and convinced him to write a letter that officially expanded the scope of the investigation -- to include going after those engaged in the cover-up.
The rest of that chapter is fairly well-known. Fitzgerald was successful in prosecuting Cheneys top aide, Scooter Libby, on numerous felony charges. I had hoped that he would also prosecute Cheney, even though it was possible, even likely, that Dick would have been found not guilty. (Also, like his soul mate Dick Nixon per Watergate, Cheney believed that multiple claims of national security would have prevented his criminal prosecution.) Fitzgerald did offer his documentation of the case to Congress, should the House be interested in considering impeachment.
Since serving during the Bush administration, Comey has been employed by large corporations. Obviously, I think that is a big minus; the overlap between industry and government is the most dangerous threat to the United States. He is a registered republican, and donated to the campaigns of McCain and Romney.
In a perfect world, there would be no need for an FBI. In todays world, the actual needs for justice should result in someone with the character of Senator Elizabeth Warren serving as the agencys director -- or as Attorney General. But that isnt going to happen. And its not only because of the repulsive republican jackasses in Washington. Its because this administration includes people like Eric Holder.
Because of the limited options -- not to mention that people like you and I have no say whatsoever in this -- I think that Jim Comey is probably the very best choice that President Obama could make. At least Comey has, to an extent that exceeds almost any Democrat in DC, stood up on principle a few times. He has advocated prosecuting criminals from the bowels of the corporate government. And, while he is probably not someone that most of us would enjoy having a beer with, he appears to have some respect for the Bill of Rights.
Peace,
H2O Man