General Discussion

La Lioness Priyanka

(53,866 posts)

73. in ayn rand?

Reply to redqueen (Reply #71)

Mon Jul 28, 2014, 06:26 PM

Jul 2014

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

144 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Here is my question about criticism. Do i have to read a whole book in order to criticize it? [View all] La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 OP

I think it's fair to say, "It was terrible, I couldn't get past x." PeaceNikki Jul 2014 #1

agreed, this one is terrible nadinbrzezinski Jul 2014 #3

That's how I felt about Twilight, which I understand 50 Shades of Grey is based on. Louisiana1976 Jul 2014 #81

Depends on the book imo. Rex Jul 2014 #2

I couldn't get all the "begats" in the bible LOL snooper2 Jul 2014 #4

The Bible is FAR more violent and misogynistic than 50 Shades. I've read both. PeaceNikki Jul 2014 #7

If it begins,"It was a dark and stormy night . . ." flamin lib Jul 2014 #5

Depends The Straight Story Jul 2014 #6

You know what is funny? nadinbrzezinski Jul 2014 #8

feel better soon nadin! La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #12

There's a Vancouver, Washington, too Scootaloo Jul 2014 #23

Could be, given that I know the one in Canada nadinbrzezinski Jul 2014 #25

There is no border checkpoint in Vancouver, Washington. pnwmom Jul 2014 #62

Well, I knew only of the one in Canada nadinbrzezinski Jul 2014 #69

WSU does not have a campus in Canada Brother Buzz Jul 2014 #137

But is that one ever referred to as plain "Vancouver"? Ron Obvious Jul 2014 #107

Yes, among people who have reason to go there. I often have to ask people which Vancouver pnwmom Jul 2014 #112

I think you should feel free to have an opinion on whatever you like el_bryanto Jul 2014 #9

A man(!) once told me the only things I *have* to do is die and pay taxes Tuesday Afternoon Jul 2014 #10

You don't have to pay taxes. Dying is about it. nt Logical Jul 2014 #17

you go right ahead and let me know how that goes for you, okie dokie. Tuesday Afternoon Jul 2014 #20

Your relevance is superseded only by your depth... LanternWaste Jul 2014 #27

Ahh, you are mad about something else I assume. Nt Logical Jul 2014 #31

No, otherwise, reading Ayn Rand would have bored us all to tears and madness long ago. nt Zorra Jul 2014 #11

oh so very true. nt La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #13

Best answer! pnwmom Jul 2014 #65

It depends on your basis for criticism. lumberjack_jeff Jul 2014 #14

Why wouldn't it be sufficient to read the glorified rape scene in chapter 8? pnwmom Jul 2014 #66

Because if you only read the parts of Huck Finn mythology Jul 2014 #77

The Chapter would provide plenty of context. n/t pnwmom Jul 2014 #93

I think it goes with the territory, even in your example what you are critical of is based on what TheKentuckian Jul 2014 #15

no. just don't claim to know more specific plot details than somebody who has read the whole thing. m-lekktor Jul 2014 #16

fair point La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #70

During my PhD study, I took a class on Victorian Literature alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #18

If reading something was required before jumping into a discussion on DU, MerryBlooms Jul 2014 #19

so true. i posted an article just the other day and many people disagreed with it La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #34

Exactly. The part that makes me laugh the most, MerryBlooms Jul 2014 #39

No, it's entirely possible to judge a work's quality through some reading Scootaloo Jul 2014 #21

I felt the same way about the Earth's children. bravenak Jul 2014 #29

Yeah... Scootaloo Jul 2014 #32

Well damn. bravenak Jul 2014 #33

They don't call him "The Great Bearded Glacier" for nothing. Scootaloo Jul 2014 #38

That was great!! bravenak Jul 2014 #45

i had all but forgotten about clan of the cave bear, but i remember loving it as a a teenager La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #30

deja vu. That's how I feel about L Ron Hubbard's 'Mission Earth dekalogy'. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jul 2014 #40

Nope. Iggo Jul 2014 #22

NO marions ghost Jul 2014 #24

Go read the Anne Rice Beauty books. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jul 2014 #42

I looked her books up, not familiar... marions ghost Jul 2014 #53

i enjoyed the Beauty books. La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #58

We do change over time. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jul 2014 #61

I loved them :) Marrah_G Jul 2014 #94

Different strokes for different folks, I guess. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jul 2014 #116

No, just like you don't have to eat the whole steak to know the meat is bad...nt SidDithers Jul 2014 #26

Criticize all you want bluestateguy Jul 2014 #28

Only the dirty bits. Warren Stupidity Jul 2014 #35

I'd be overjoyed to write something that angers a lot of people. conservaphobe Jul 2014 #36

Depends what you are criticizing. kiva Jul 2014 #37

Of course not and those claiming so now never have in the past, which is quite revealing. redqueen Jul 2014 #41

TH-TH-TH-THIS!!!! Iggo Jul 2014 #46

I'm seriously amazed at the number of people refusing to see that these particular emperors redqueen Jul 2014 #86

I think a sampling will be good enough. Otherwise your head might explode. Avalux Jul 2014 #43

LOL. La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #51

without reading it all, of course you can criticize it... poorly. unblock Jul 2014 #44

.. La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #52

Depends. One should at least have read up until the point of objectionable content ecstatic Jul 2014 #47

Of course that approach can lead to someone walking out of A Clockwork Orange because it's just... JVS Jul 2014 #97

It depends on whom you are trying to impress Dreamer Tatum Jul 2014 #48

The every word crowd never went to grad school BainsBane Jul 2014 #49

SO TRUE. *or frankly any exam in grad school. La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #50

The grad school crowd knows to read enough so that we are conversant on msanthrope Jul 2014 #64

Excuse me? BainsBane Jul 2014 #67

I'd be willing to bet pintobean Jul 2014 #74

I try. nt msanthrope Jul 2014 #80

I dunno alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #68

I'm sure fields vary BainsBane Jul 2014 #72

We are talking about a single primary source. If you were assigned msanthrope Jul 2014 #83

If I were assigned schlock for my PhD orals? BainsBane Jul 2014 #104

When I wrote my graduate thesis on Fray Servando nadinbrzezinski Jul 2014 #138

Monographs and articles are generally secondary sources alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #85

Obviously. And one reads secondary sources for comprehensive exams BainsBane Jul 2014 #95

That's no doubt true alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #109

Yes, but we are not talking about a literature seminar BainsBane Jul 2014 #122

Also true alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #123

I again think that relates to discipline BainsBane Jul 2014 #124

My own alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #130

Then you read the portions pertinent to your research BainsBane Jul 2014 #131

Different schools of thought, I guess alcibiades_mystery Jul 2014 #133

I went to grad school. Twice. Hissyspit Jul 2014 #126

If everyone's a consenting adult, you can do pretty much whatever you want. Warren DeMontague Jul 2014 #54

Difference between criticism and critique. nolabear Jul 2014 #55

very true. La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #57

I agree and I think that is what I thought as I read some of these OPs/threads stevenleser Jul 2014 #118

I suppose this depends in large part on what is being criticized arcane1 Jul 2014 #56

I think as long as you're upfront about the amount you read, you're good to go steve2470 Jul 2014 #59

If you want to write a few thosand words about what the unreadable book means Bluenorthwest Jul 2014 #60

ok. i think that is fair. i too couldn't go on an on about something i have not read well La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #63

Are you able to say that there's glorified, romanticized rape in Atlas Shrugged? redqueen Jul 2014 #71

in ayn rand? La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #73

Yes, I just went back and added a link for context. redqueen Jul 2014 #75

that arguments cites the paragraph that contains the rape, so yes, i would La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #76

Thanks. redqueen Jul 2014 #78

I didn't see the link and have read all three books... one_voice Jul 2014 #87

Then there's also the one in 50 Shades of Grey, which many have described, redqueen Jul 2014 #84

Did you read the book? newcriminal Jul 2014 #99

Holy carp (intended). Is that seriously it? DirkGently Jul 2014 #105

Well it is awful. Warren Stupidity Jul 2014 #114

I agree it's awful, but it isn't rape. newcriminal Jul 2014 #117

Yes, I've read these posts with great amusement ... NanceGreggs Jul 2014 #119

There was no rape. It has nothing to do with a contract. newcriminal Jul 2014 #121

Maybe Capt. Obvious Jul 2014 #79

I was once asked to write a review of a book Maeve Jul 2014 #82

If you're doing a full critique, yes, you must read it all. If... HuckleB Jul 2014 #88

I think so. LWolf Jul 2014 #89

How much of any of Dinesh D'Souza's books or Ann Coulter's books do we need to read Proud Liberal Dem Jul 2014 #90

read one of ann coulter's book halfway through at a b&n. swore to myself to never be so mean La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #91

I want to try to be "open minded" and listen to opposing viewpoints Proud Liberal Dem Jul 2014 #96

None, but I wouldn't claim that they are examples of poor writing. Warren Stupidity Jul 2014 #115

You only read one page? What book was that? edbermac Jul 2014 #92

not sure but i think it is The 3 Mistakes of My Life La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #101

Maybe one of his mistakes was writing that book! edbermac Jul 2014 #103

Yes, if you want your opinion valued. rug Jul 2014 #98

Not to "criticize." To critique. DirkGently Jul 2014 #100

i am not sure i agree on your elaboration La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #102

But it's way more than "criticizing" the idea of the thing. DirkGently Jul 2014 #106

"to scream in neck-throbbing rage that your interpretation is superior to the interpretation of Squinch Jul 2014 #128

I think it depends on what kind of criticism/critique you're talking about fishwax Jul 2014 #108

hell yes, but it's ok to bail out of bad one. You just don't have info to critique it. Liberal_in_LA Jul 2014 #110

You can criticize all you want, but ... surrealAmerican Jul 2014 #111

mostly no, but DonCoquixote Jul 2014 #113

No, you don't have to read every word treestar Jul 2014 #120

No. But your opinion wouldn't carry the same weight as someone who LittleBlue Jul 2014 #125

Two followup questions: Do you have to read the book before you can have an opinion on Squinch Jul 2014 #127

Of course not. NaturalHigh Jul 2014 #129

"I got through one page before i declared it wholly unreadable " NCTraveler Jul 2014 #132

It really depends on your purpose and what exactly you are criticizing IronLionZion Jul 2014 #134

Basing an opinion on a particular work based on hearsay alp227 Jul 2014 #135

depends... Javaman Jul 2014 #136

I have never personally read even one page of Mein Kampf - but I have a feeling its is bad Douglas Carpenter Jul 2014 #139

Post removed Post removed Jul 2014 #140

write not right and ann rice does not write horror per se. nt La Lioness Priyanka Jul 2014 #141

Frankenstein - enjoy your stay. nt redqueen Jul 2014 #142

Tried this in High School Lit. dilby Jul 2014 #143

If you haven't read much of the book, you should state that in your criticism. Jim__ Jul 2014 #144