Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Study: You Can't Change an Anti-Vaxxer's Mind [View all]proverbialwisdom
(4,959 posts)92. Are you from Maine? Seen this Op-Ed? Don't be afraid to read in full & please check out links, too.
http://www.pressherald.com/2014/09/02/maine-voices-breakdown-in-accountability-at-heart-of-decline-in-vaccinations/
September 2, 2014
Maine Voices: Breakdown in accountability at heart of decline in vaccinations
Opposition to the current U.S. vaccination program is based on its failures, denial and bad law and policy.
By Ginger Taylor
BRUNSWICK I was interviewed for an Aug. 9 front-page article by Joe Lawlor, titled More Maine families are skipping or delaying childhood vaccines. What was published was a complete misrepresentation of the interview I gave him.
As I told Mr. Lawlor, Im neither anti-vaccine nor opposed to vaccination, and I vaccinated my children. My opposition is to the current U.S. vaccine program, which has become corrupted by bad law and policy, the failure to disclose known risks to families, the failure to pre-screen children who are showing symptoms that they are at risk for vaccine reactions and the denial of vaccine injury cases rather than the proper recognition, diagnoses and treatment of vaccine-injured children.
In 1986, Congress gave liability protection to all vaccine interests pharmaceutical companies, government agencies, doctors, nurses, etc. so no one in this country can sue for vaccine injuries or deaths. As a result of this disregard of Americans Seventh Amendment rights, a vaccine injury case hasnt been brought before a jury in almost 30 years, there is no longer accountability in vaccine safety and the vaccine program has fallen into massive corruption.
The effectiveness of vaccines is overstated, safety claims made are overstated and parents no longer get accurate risk information. Instead, vaccine consumers are offered a single sheet of information in the doctors office that leaves out almost all of the side effects listed on the vaccine package insert, on the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Vaccine Injury Table and the disorders that HHS has concluded can be caused by a given vaccine.
Doctors are not trained on federal guidelines for vaccine injury, nor are they required to know the side effects listed on the vaccine package insert. Therefore, few physicians know how to recognize adverse reactions in their patients. As a result, such cases are usually ignored or misdiagnosed and are rarely properly medically assessed, and patients can become victims of medical neglect for a lifetime.
Further, the vaccine schedule has tripled since 1986, so a child born today will receive more doses of vaccine by the time hes 6 months old than I did by the time I went to college. There is almost no long-term safety testing of vaccines, and no safety testing of the overloaded schedule as a whole.
This breakdown in the U.S. vaccine programs accountability to consumers is at the heart of the countrys decline in vaccinations, because when parents take the time to look into physicians safety claims, they find theyre being given incorrect and biased information.
Case in point: The claim that the vaccine-autism controversy began as the result of one debunked study is utter misinformation. In fact, more than 80 research papers demonstrate the associations between vaccines and autism, and the mechanisms by which vaccines can cause autism.
When Mr. Lawlor asked me why I believed my son was vaccine-injured, I directed him to the HHS Vaccine Injury Compensation Table and walked him through the symptoms of pertussis-vaccine-induced encephalopathy, the medical term for brain damage, which my son exhibited following his 18-month shots:
My sons case is not unusual. Because few doctors have ever read the federal vaccine injury table, children exhibiting symptoms of vaccine-induced brain damage are often diagnosed with autism without ever being evaluated for this vaccine reaction.
The Press Herald has published a follow-up article and an editorial that make clear its agenda is to not investigate and report the facts on this issue, but to coerce families who have safety concerns into vaccinating according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Preventions recommended schedule against their better judgment, by removing their legal right to exercise informed consent in medicine.
Parents are not declining vaccines because of Jenny McCarthy or because of a 15-year-old British research paper. Parents are justifiably hesitant because the vaccine program has become overly aggressive, dosing is one-size-fits-all, promoters dont disclose true risks to patients and program managers are not taking responsibility for helping the countless children and adults who have serious adverse vaccine reactions. Parents like me found out the hard way that once your child suffers a vaccine injury, you are on your own.
Special to the Press Herald
September 2, 2014
Maine Voices: Breakdown in accountability at heart of decline in vaccinations
Opposition to the current U.S. vaccination program is based on its failures, denial and bad law and policy.
By Ginger Taylor
BRUNSWICK I was interviewed for an Aug. 9 front-page article by Joe Lawlor, titled More Maine families are skipping or delaying childhood vaccines. What was published was a complete misrepresentation of the interview I gave him.
As I told Mr. Lawlor, Im neither anti-vaccine nor opposed to vaccination, and I vaccinated my children. My opposition is to the current U.S. vaccine program, which has become corrupted by bad law and policy, the failure to disclose known risks to families, the failure to pre-screen children who are showing symptoms that they are at risk for vaccine reactions and the denial of vaccine injury cases rather than the proper recognition, diagnoses and treatment of vaccine-injured children.
In 1986, Congress gave liability protection to all vaccine interests pharmaceutical companies, government agencies, doctors, nurses, etc. so no one in this country can sue for vaccine injuries or deaths. As a result of this disregard of Americans Seventh Amendment rights, a vaccine injury case hasnt been brought before a jury in almost 30 years, there is no longer accountability in vaccine safety and the vaccine program has fallen into massive corruption.
The effectiveness of vaccines is overstated, safety claims made are overstated and parents no longer get accurate risk information. Instead, vaccine consumers are offered a single sheet of information in the doctors office that leaves out almost all of the side effects listed on the vaccine package insert, on the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Vaccine Injury Table and the disorders that HHS has concluded can be caused by a given vaccine.
Doctors are not trained on federal guidelines for vaccine injury, nor are they required to know the side effects listed on the vaccine package insert. Therefore, few physicians know how to recognize adverse reactions in their patients. As a result, such cases are usually ignored or misdiagnosed and are rarely properly medically assessed, and patients can become victims of medical neglect for a lifetime.
Further, the vaccine schedule has tripled since 1986, so a child born today will receive more doses of vaccine by the time hes 6 months old than I did by the time I went to college. There is almost no long-term safety testing of vaccines, and no safety testing of the overloaded schedule as a whole.
This breakdown in the U.S. vaccine programs accountability to consumers is at the heart of the countrys decline in vaccinations, because when parents take the time to look into physicians safety claims, they find theyre being given incorrect and biased information.
Case in point: The claim that the vaccine-autism controversy began as the result of one debunked study is utter misinformation. In fact, more than 80 research papers demonstrate the associations between vaccines and autism, and the mechanisms by which vaccines can cause autism.
When Mr. Lawlor asked me why I believed my son was vaccine-injured, I directed him to the HHS Vaccine Injury Compensation Table and walked him through the symptoms of pertussis-vaccine-induced encephalopathy, the medical term for brain damage, which my son exhibited following his 18-month shots:
- Decreased or absent response to environment (responds, if at all, only to loud voice or painful stimuli).
- Decreased or absent eye contact (does not fix gaze upon family members or other individuals).
- Inconsistent or absent responses to external stimuli (does not recognize familiar people or things).
My sons case is not unusual. Because few doctors have ever read the federal vaccine injury table, children exhibiting symptoms of vaccine-induced brain damage are often diagnosed with autism without ever being evaluated for this vaccine reaction.
The Press Herald has published a follow-up article and an editorial that make clear its agenda is to not investigate and report the facts on this issue, but to coerce families who have safety concerns into vaccinating according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Preventions recommended schedule against their better judgment, by removing their legal right to exercise informed consent in medicine.
Parents are not declining vaccines because of Jenny McCarthy or because of a 15-year-old British research paper. Parents are justifiably hesitant because the vaccine program has become overly aggressive, dosing is one-size-fits-all, promoters dont disclose true risks to patients and program managers are not taking responsibility for helping the countless children and adults who have serious adverse vaccine reactions. Parents like me found out the hard way that once your child suffers a vaccine injury, you are on your own.
Special to the Press Herald
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
209 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
How happy do you think parents were, in the late 50's, when a polio vaccine became available...
SidDithers
Oct 2014
#17
I was born in '64. I know how happy parents were about the polio, MMR and other vaccines.
REP
Oct 2014
#22
I also had the smallpox vac and was happy to get it. I have met people who survived smallpox.
Shrike47
Oct 2014
#106
Everyone that I know who has not vaccinated their children has a Masters degree or higher
Tumbulu
Oct 2014
#57
Steve Jobs was similar to an antivaxer. He waited to cure himself and then it was too late.
randome
Oct 2014
#153
Too many times people that are enormously successful in one facet of their lives believe they
Ikonoklast
Oct 2014
#183
Which explains why so many successful parents fall for the anti-vax bullshit.
zappaman
Oct 2014
#184
And it seems many such as those parents are the ones with "Indigo Children".
Ikonoklast
Oct 2014
#186
Weary sigh. The two sources I've seen promoting that meme are Dr. Nancy Snyderman & Dr. Paul Offit.
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#185
not in this case. this anti vaccine shit is also a problem with college educated upper middleclass
La Lioness Priyanka
Oct 2014
#122
But everyone on DU wants to thump their chest and claim it is only the fundamentalists
Tumbulu
Oct 2014
#135
no, this is the lefts version of climate change denial. i feel like i wrote an op about this
La Lioness Priyanka
Oct 2014
#150
Some one just has to give up on, logic fails on them. One hopes that with their idiocracy they
RKP5637
Oct 2014
#4
They don't like to be compared to a cult, but that's what it looks like to me. eom
Blanks
Oct 2014
#32
Mumps causes sterility. The Illuminati don't want the kids of smart people like you to reproduce...
hunter
Oct 2014
#87
I was engaged in extensive discussions on Facebook on the 'CDC whistleblower' story...
Blanks
Oct 2014
#29
So, if you can't actually change their minds, why spend so much effort trying to?
Electric Monk
Oct 2014
#34
Google allows you to know your allies & their shifting rationalizations. Do their arguments hold up?
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#113
I'd prefer another more serious unedited interview w Dr. Melinda Wharton but I haven't seen one.(nt)
proverbialwisdom
Apr 2015
#209
Probably not even then. I can easily see a paranoid conspiracy theory being spun...
Silent3
Oct 2014
#68
LOL. The US Vaccine Injury Compensation Court paid out $276,424,636.81 in fiscal year 2013.
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#79
I said "Regardless of the source of the injury." Please reread my post, thanks. nt
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#97
If there's a statement you'd like to challenge, please quote it directly, thanks. nt
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#104
No such connection therein stated or implied, as demonstrated once already. Please read carefully:
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#108
Unsupported & easily disproven talking points do not a thorough refutation make.
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#152
Since 1989, the US Vaccine Injury Compensation Court has paid $2,857,926,807.60 in damages.
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#81
every parent is given information about the vaccine injury fund when they consent to vaccination.
missingthebigdog
Oct 2014
#134
$2,857,926,807.60 in vaccine injury damage awards should give you your answer. nt
ucrdem
Oct 2014
#154
You really don't understand the difference between science and courts of any kind, do you?
HuckleB
Oct 2014
#161
Are you from Maine? Seen this Op-Ed? Don't be afraid to read in full & please check out links, too.
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#92
Here on DU, one's decisions about one's body belong to the Pompous Brigade,
closeupready
Oct 2014
#93
Chris Mooney is a 37 yo Yalie; here's an older Yalie, Dan Olmsted. Each earned BA degree in English.
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#98
The editorializing in Mooney's article is unsupported & offensive. The study is worth reading, OTOH.
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#126
Do you regard as problematic everyone on earth except those following the exact 2014 CDC schedule?
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#101
I like accuracy. Please point out a concrete example of "misdirection/half-truths about vaccination"
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#116
CDC Whistleblower Text Exchange With Mrs. Wakefield: “Your husband’s career was unjustly damaged..."
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#124
Keep trying. Wakefield is a fraud and continues to be a dangerous asshat...
SidDithers
Oct 2014
#125
AUTISM SPEAKS: Regressive Autism Reported Twice as Often among African American Children
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#138
Anti-vax bullshit should get a poster banned, under the Crazy Talk part of the TOS...
SidDithers
Oct 2014
#149
Dr Gorski read the following & provided comments. Skim it, skip the parts you regard as insufferable
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#166
#CDCwhistleblower #hearthiswell - unreported in the MSM, but not credible? Really? (nt)
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#174
Worth the automatic hide and thread lock-out for citing blacklisted site, HuckleB; this is tedious.
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#171
Why are you spamming debunked nonsense, and making baseless claims about other items?
HuckleB
Oct 2014
#173
My youngest brother got measles and chicken pox at the same time. He almost died.
appleannie1
Oct 2014
#103
Yes, Quarantine all those who should be vaccinated and are not. They pose a risk to public health
on point
Oct 2014
#190
You misunderstand. The can leave quarantine anytime they like. Get vaccinated or get sick.
on point
Oct 2014
#199
If one does not challenge their claims, those who do not know enough can be conned.
HuckleB
Oct 2014
#175
Are you calling these Harvard & other MDs baseless names & suggesting they should be made pariahs?
proverbialwisdom
Oct 2014
#207
Seems it would take plenty convincing for someone to even become an anti-vaxxer in the first place
JonLP24
Oct 2014
#200
All Anti Vaxers should be sentenced to spend at least one day in the late fifties.
alphafemale
Oct 2014
#205