Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: The South was not sufficiently punished after the war [View all]oneshooter
(8,614 posts)42. They are still veterans, honorably buried.
Their families received no benefits. You can not "revoke" their status as veterans. No more than you can revoke the status of German or Japanese veterans.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
129 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Excellent point. I am always saying cant we please publicly shame them, but it needed to
randys1
Jun 2015
#1
I think the op was suggesting something more like Germany after the Great War.
TheManInTheMac
Jun 2015
#11
Well put. What James McPherson refers to as the "Second American Revolution" was only
KingCharlemagne
Jun 2015
#95
There was a little of the OP's suggestions in how we treated Germany and Japan after WWII.
backscatter712
Jun 2015
#110
If we (northen born) can't forgive and get over the war, how do we expect our (southern born)
Nobel_Twaddle_III
Jun 2015
#15
Is saying that the Grant administration was the most corrupt up to that time
Art_from_Ark
Jun 2015
#127
I wouldn't bulldoze them, but I'd revoke the veteran status Confederate soliders
SpartanDem
Jun 2015
#39
Apparently there are several DUers that would willingly bulldoze a Confederate
oneshooter
Jun 2015
#125
Punishments harden people into resisting. The South need a federal education system. nt
NCjack
Jun 2015
#21
We've let the white South be in denial that their ancestors were on the wrong side
SpartanDem
Jun 2015
#24
Hirohito was symbolic...Tojo was hung, as were numerous other military leaders
alcibiades_mystery
Jun 2015
#69
Lincoln wanted to keep the United States together, punishing the South would've driven a wedge
NightWatcher
Jun 2015
#27
Agreed. If only they could have used the Allied example of 1918 as a template
Pooka Fey
Jun 2015
#36
Indeed, this is why Lincoln is one of the histories greatest disappointments to me.
ncjustice80
Jun 2015
#57
Slavery is a gross human rights violation, and I'm sure they continued operation during the war.
ncjustice80
Jun 2015
#117
You have unintentionally showed a big reason why Lincoln was such a great man (nt)
Nye Bevan
Jun 2015
#63
Next maybe you'll give us your ideas about how every white person should be made to pay for their
cherokeeprogressive
Jun 2015
#65
While blacks were not elevated mostly because the north was also racist as fuck
TheKentuckian
Jun 2015
#84
The freed slaves should have been given 40 acres and a mule. But they weren't. Why? Because the
raccoon
Jun 2015
#86
...not to mention huge amounts of Southern land passed into then hands of Northerner's ownership.
ladjf
Jun 2015
#96
It's the WEATHER! Northern refugee here, seeking to move from Illinois to Maryland.
raging moderate
Jun 2015
#103
Everyone who fought that war is long dead. Those who made it to the 1913 Gettysburg reunion
struggle4progress
Jun 2015
#119