Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

SunsetDreams

(8,571 posts)
8. Manufacturing a controversy about the MMR vaccine
Tue Jun 26, 2012, 05:03 AM
Jun 2012
Here we go again with the trope that the MMR vaccine causes autism. The Daily Mail, a British middle market tabloid, has published an article, MMR: A mother’s victory: The vast majority of doctors say there is no link between the triple jab and autism, but could an Italian court case reignite this controversial debate?, that is attempting to create a controversy out of thin air about the MMR vaccine for mumps, measles and rubella. The article is referring to an insane Italian court ruling which, despite all evidence to the contrary, blamed a child’s autism on the vaccination.

Because the anti-vaccination lunacy lacks any substantial support for their various tropes about vaccines causing any number of things, including autism, it’s important to be perfectly clear:

The Cochrane Reviews state that MMR vaccine does not cause autism.
There is no scientific or medical controversy about this conclusion.
Medical and scientific experts agree.
It lead to a public health crisis based on a fraud.
Well constructed epidemiological studies also showed no link between MMR vaccine and autism in Denmark, England, Japan, Japan, Japan, Poland, and the United States.
Mr. Andy Wakefield‘s paper alleging a connection between MMR and autism has been retracted by the Lancet.
Despite claims that Wakefield’s findings were reproduced, not one single peer-reviewed paper ever supported the Wakefield’s claims.
Numerous studies actually invalidate his claim.
The Autism Omnibus trials has rejected all three test cases and subsequent appeals claiming that vaccines cause autism.


Much more at link, including hyperlinks to even more
http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php/manufacturing-controversy-mmr-vaccine/

Link between MMR Vaccines and Autism conclusively broken

Further studies proved no link between autism and MMR vaccine

There were reservations against the paper’s scientific validity even when it appeared in 1998. Critics pointed that the paper’s research was based on a small sample with no control, linked three common conditions and relied on parent’s biased testimony. The next decade a lot of ensuing studies found no link between the two. By the time the paper was retracted in 2001, there was no doubt in the minds of the scientific community that it was fatally flawed. The General Medical Council held a detailed and long hearing before giving their verdict of no confidence in the study.

Since then, there have been numerous big studies -- including one with 530,000 children and one with 1.8 million children -- and no link was found. As recently as in 2008, a Columbia University study found "no connection" between the vaccine and autism in kids. "Our results are inconsistent with a causal role for MMR vaccine as a trigger or exacerbator of either G.I. difficulties or autism," said one of the Columbia researchers, Mady Hornig, at the time.

....

The alleged link between the vaccinations and autism also took away a great deal of money, attention and energy from research into the actual cause of autism.

The effect of Wakefield’s study was so huge that parents started keeping away from the MMR and a significant rise in Measles and Mumps outbreaks have been regularly reported in the US and Europe. In fact, California in 2010 broke a 55-year-old record for the number of cases of whooping cough reports msnbc.com . That's directly related to parents who haven’t vaccinated their children.
Wakefield found a ready audience in people looking for something to blame for autism.


http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/98531/20110107/link-between-mmr-vaccines-and-autism-conclusively-broken.htm

Researcher Behind Debunked Autism-Vaccine Study Stood To Make Millions

A week after calling research that first suggested a link between autism and vaccines an “elaborate fraud” a follow-up article in the British Medical Journal now says the researcher behind the study planned to make upwards of $43 million annually selling replacement vaccines and diagnostic products.

In the report published Tuesday, journalist Brian Deer reveals that Andrew Wakefield held a patent for “a ‘safer’ single measles shot.”

Meanwhile, Deer reports that Wakefield was in talks with investors to develop a business that “was to be launched off the back of the vaccine scare, diagnosing a purported — and still unsubstantiated — ‘new syndrome.’” A business plan for the venture indicates that by year three, diagnostic kits alone were anticipated to garner $43 million per year.

...

Deer reports this week that Wakefield was asked by his superiors at the University College London in 1999 to replicate his study using a larger sampling of 150 children after they expressed concerns about a “serious conflict of interest” given his business plans.
But Wakefield did not pursue further study on the matter and ultimately left the institution, with his boss saying, “we paid him to go away.”


http://www.disabilityscoop.com/2011/01/12/wakefield-make-millions/11910/

This outlandish claim has been debunked time and time again. It is disheartening to find a judge that goes rogue ignoring all evidence to the contrary. As an RN, I find these allegations against MMR vaccine to be not only bogus without any scientific evidence to back them up, but also to be very disgusting and disturbing to say the least. Measles, Mumps and Rubella can all be very dangerous diseases in young children and pregnant women. In some cases it can even cause death. There is no link between Autism and MMR vaccine.

Here is some general information for anyone interested on the MMR Vaccine and Measles, Mumps, and Rubella.

Measles is a virus that causes a rash, cough, runny nose, eye irritation, and fever in most people. It can also lead to pneumonia, seizures, brain damage, and death in some cases.

The mumps virus causes fever, headache, and swollen glands. It can also lead to deafness, meningitis, swollen testicles or ovaries, and death in some cases.

Rubella, also known as the German measles, is generally a mild disease. However, it can cause serious birth defects in the child of a woman who becomes infected while pregnant.


http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/002026.htm
Rebuttal in reverse chronology to the stupendously oversimplistic platitudes on that locked thread. proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #1
Age of Autism? FFS... SidDithers Jun 2012 #2
Actually CNN, CBS, NPR in Boston, WNYC, and PBS are the sources for interviews with - proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #3
Sorry, this is a stupendous pile of steaming horseshit Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #7
Find a source from 2012. Hint: does not exist, the field has evolved. proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #11
I urge you to please spend some time reading this 2012 HARVARD HEALTH PUBLICATION. proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #15
Are you a scientologist? snooper2 Jun 2012 #45
Good one. (eom) proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #53
They must have had some evidence presented in Italian court? Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #16
While I can't answer to the rest of your "debunking" 1monster Jun 2012 #36
There has never been any evidence Sgent Jun 2012 #65
Watch CNN'S interview with former CDC Chief Julie Gerberding on March 31, 2008 (post #1) . proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #74
I think the transcript is sufficient, but for a copy of the video, instructions follow. proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #76
Dupe. Deleted. n/t Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #80
You are wrong about the presence of thimerosol in vaccines. Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #81
well said and posters who pile on Tumbulu Jun 2012 #69
The MMR vaccine has never had thimerosal. Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #77
Thimerosal is still contained in some childhood vaccines Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #82
"use of inaccurate facts to shut down discussion"? Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #84
"thimerosal was totally removed from all childhood vaccines in 2001" Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #87
TL:DR, but the MMR vaccine (which is specifically at issue here).. Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #111
I did not bring up thimerosal. Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #112
The original post to which I was responding DID. Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #113
If you want to go that direction, Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #114
I thought they stopped using mercury a long time ago ryan_cats Jun 2012 #98
The original paper alleging a link between vaccines and autism is a proven fraud cpwm17 Jun 2012 #21
False. This is in the weeds for me, but if you are seriously interested, examine these with care. proverbialwisdom Jul 2012 #129
This message was self-deleted by its author Luminous Animal Jun 2012 #4
Unlocking. Luminous Animal Jun 2012 #5
Truthfully, posts #6 and #8 are in the weeds for me, but not for the AoA contributors, the majority proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #9
You bet I have a personal stake SunsetDreams Jun 2012 #38
Truthfully, this subject makes me unspeakably sad and I will be stepping away for awhile. (eom) proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #63
AoA as a source? obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #54
Post #3 describes the news aggregating function by AoA from mainstream sources. proverbialwisdom Jun 2012 #71
Good. This Italian court ruling is not a conspiracy theory. n/t lumberjack_jeff Jun 2012 #29
British Medical Journal: Science rules MMR didn't trigger autism Spider Jerusalem Jun 2012 #6
Manufacturing a controversy about the MMR vaccine SunsetDreams Jun 2012 #8
You mention Japan: their vaccines have NEVER contained mercury compounds Lydia Leftcoast Jun 2012 #20
Changing diagnoses can only explain about half of the increased prevalence. lumberjack_jeff Jun 2012 #32
Research being done SunsetDreams Jun 2012 #64
Of course its environmental toxins Drale Jun 2012 #126
I have to wonder if it's something that corporations make a lot of money off of Lydia Leftcoast Jun 2012 #128
So one locked thread over anti-vaccine bullshit wasn't enough? GarroHorus Jun 2012 #10
why did you alert on a news story from the Independent, that was a fast reaction too Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #17
I have a special contempt for conspiracy theorists. n/t GarroHorus Jun 2012 #19
Pushing the antivac bullshit is killing people. Warren Stupidity Jun 2012 #33
Post removed Post removed Jun 2012 #52
I have special contempt for anti-vaxxer woo-woo. backscatter712 Jun 2012 #12
I had mumps, measles, and chickenpox as a kid GarroHorus Jun 2012 #13
+1 Chorophyll Jun 2012 #14
Amen! I had measles and chicken pox in the same year, and the secondary infections Lydia Leftcoast Jun 2012 #18
Because Vaccines have been useful in the past, we are all to now blindly believe Big Pharma Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #22
Did you see my post about Japan? Lydia Leftcoast Jun 2012 #23
Maybe there is something else in it causing the problem. How can we fix it if we live in denial? Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #26
just keep all your anti-vac friends away from my newborn granddaughter. n/t progressivebydesign Jun 2012 #37
Try a netti pot. tridim Jun 2012 #28
That's interesting, but remember, the Japanese as a nation eat a lot of fish... 1monster Jun 2012 #39
Every assertion about vaccines has been debunked GarroHorus Jun 2012 #24
Who has an interest in lying? Big Pharma or parents of children who have been harmed? Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #25
Anti-Vaccine people are out to kill everybody. GarroHorus Jun 2012 #31
There are ingredients in vaccines causing autism, denail is a republican tactic Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #34
Full debunked conspiracy theory nonsense GarroHorus Jun 2012 #35
your jury results (from juror #2) Kali Jun 2012 #43
. GarroHorus Jun 2012 #44
I was juror #3. Still trying to sufrommich Jun 2012 #47
hosts are really limited in what they can lock Kali Jun 2012 #61
delusion is another repuke trait Kali Jun 2012 #42
Wrongo obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #58
Jenny McCarthy and Andrew Wakefield and AoA obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #55
I'm sure Big Pharma makes much more on vaccines Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #68
Hey, pal, it's all good! florida evans Jun 2012 #51
Why is "trusty" in scare quotes? obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #60
What precisely is preventing you from becoming infected with/by various diseases? LanternWaste Jun 2012 #66
That will have to be answered SunsetDreams Jun 2012 #67
Probably not the first time, either...nt SidDithers Jun 2012 #72
Herd immunity. Warren Stupidity Jun 2012 #78
As someone who's liver is shot. ForgoTheConsequence Jun 2012 #27
Ah jeez proud2BlibKansan Jun 2012 #30
The Italian Court got it wrong. hedgehog Jun 2012 #40
Giuliano Mignini must have been on vacation obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #56
For those going "Huh?" hedgehog Jun 2012 #59
+1 obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #62
It's amazing how some on the Left proudly claim to be MicaelS Jun 2012 #41
Just because somebody says they are left of center or a liberal doesn't mean they are smart.. snooper2 Jun 2012 #48
Nice graphic, where did you get that? n/t MicaelS Jun 2012 #49
Just did a google image search for ( political circle ) snooper2 Jun 2012 #50
Jenny McCarthy Body Count... SidDithers Jun 2012 #46
Excellent illustration. backscatter712 Jun 2012 #79
I blame the existence of this thread on MTV obamanut2012 Jun 2012 #57
I blame groupthink on a massive brainwashing effort by the corporate media manufacturing consent Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #70
It is true that without vaccines there would be fewer children with autism. 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #73
why are the rates rising so fast? Have the pro toxic vaccines people been to a public school lately? Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #85
Many parents *think* they've witnessed the beginnings immediately after receiving vaccines. Posteritatis Jun 2012 #86
It wasn't classified as it's own disorder until the 1960s 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #88
I attended school then, have you been to a school now? Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #91
It's bogus conspiracy theory neo-Luddite bullshit GarroHorus Jun 2012 #92
And unfortunately they aren't going to be the ones who suffer 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #94
your reaction proves you have no argument Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #122
Your thread proves you are a conspiracy theorist GarroHorus Jun 2012 #123
This is the very definition of an anecdotal argument 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #93
Rise in Autism proven by statistics. The rebuttle 'they didn't diagnose it' is a joke Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #96
"Rise in Autism proven by statistics" 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #103
With the millions of kids getting vaccinated every year some will be diagnosed with autism cpwm17 Jun 2012 #99
I'm sure there were people who got vaccinated, stepped outside the doctors office 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #104
Courts, even in Italy, do not conduct MineralMan Jun 2012 #75
*facepalm* sakabatou Jun 2012 #83
If we demand that the anti-evolutionists use reasoned, scientific thought processes to refute... randome Jun 2012 #89
Do anecdotes count in place of evidence? 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #90
Actually, anecdotes SHOULD count. If they numbered in the thousands, maybe. randome Jun 2012 #100
Ok but are we taking in to account cup size? 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #105
I demand a scientific explanation for the rise in Autism- 'didn't diagnose it' is not scientific Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #97
Global warming is on the rise. Obesity is on the rise. The price of grape jelly is on the rise. randome Jun 2012 #101
Don't give them ideas 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #107
you might be on to something- Study Finds High-Fructose Corn Syrup Contains Mercury Ghost of Huey Long Jun 2012 #124
Groan . . . 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #125
Can you acknowledge the fact that it was not defined as a disorder 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #106
What we have to look forward to due to the idiot anti-vaxxers GarroHorus Jun 2012 #95
Ugh. I feel strange saying 'Thanks' for these photos. randome Jun 2012 #102
Don't understand the hostility to making sure vaccines are safe CleanLucre Jun 2012 #108
That's not really the issue 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #110
The reality is that there are still some things we don't know Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #115
From your articles: 4th law of robotics Jun 2012 #116
You indicated we know how vaccines work. Ms. Toad Jun 2012 #119
This is the same country charging seismologists with manslaughter for not predicting an earthquake NickB79 Jun 2012 #109
Please stop calling the parents idiots! tova Jun 2012 #117
Egg allergies are the single most common food allergy for infants/toddlers. They are not a factor Godhumor Jun 2012 #118
Reaction to shots tova Jun 2012 #120
There are guidelines for who should not get them Godhumor Jun 2012 #121
Jesus mother fucking christ pscot Jun 2012 #127
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Independent: Italian ...»Reply #8