Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

apnu

(8,756 posts)
12. But you are being an asshole
Thu Oct 12, 2017, 01:40 PM
Oct 2017

You're doing the atheist thing that makes atheists all look like dicks.

Because you're so outside the Catholic world you see it as a giant monolith, when its actually a carnival of colors and beliefs, some subtle some not so much. You also appear to be applying American ideas of liberalism and conservationism to an international organization.

Ratzinger was by all Catholic standards I know of, hard-core right wing. And yes he was John Paul II's chief spook who swept priest abuses under the rug. John Paul II said a lot of nice things but did little. Pope Francis is actually doing what he's saying. John Paul II was just talk, 30 odd years of talk.

His homeless shelter in Rome is just one thing. He's got significant issues with poverty, in 3rd world countries and that's a major issue of his that goes way beyond John Paul II.

But you seem to be ignoring the point I was trying to make that the guy is steering a Church that's the size of the Titanic with half the rudder. No matter what Pope Francis does he's not going to turn the whole Church around in his life time. Its too big and complicated and too resistant to change to suddenly snap in another direction all because a progressive Pope is leading it. His struggles are the same as Obama's. And his results will be about the same. Some progress in the end, a whole lot of pissed off people (especially conservatives who chafe at change and progressives frustrated that change didn't happen fast enough).

But my main take away with Francis, as an atheist, is he appears to be actually living what he preaches. I think religion is bunk, don't get me wrong on that. But to see a Christian actually behaving like a Christian, at least one following his God's actual message in the New Testement? That's a breath of fresh air.

So take a shit on him if you want, that's your right to do so, but know you're taking a shit on a guy trying to turn the boat around. Maybe give him a little human respect. And if you respect education and science at all, know that he's a Jesuit, so he comes from the science minded side of the Catholic Church and isn't stupid.

The guy even went to bat for us atheists, which he didn't have to do and I don't recall John Paul II doing either.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-pope-atheists/pope-suggests-better-to-be-atheist-than-hypocritical-catholic-idUSKBN1621I3

That's kind of funny since his church used to burn people at the stake for saying mean things. AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #1
Yeah. They did that 600 years ago. We all know about it. Ken Burch Oct 2017 #2
I think it makes it a bit irrelevant. AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #5
My take is that it's an anti-hypocrisy step. Ken Burch Oct 2017 #7
I thought the anti-execution thing was much older, like John Paul II era 'please don't do that' sort AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #8
I got to wrap my head around this. yallerdawg Oct 2017 #3
What can I say. When a religious org makes a half-hearted positive noise about ONE issue I care AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #6
The Catholics also reject assisted suicide and euthanasia. Mosby Oct 2017 #4
Divorce the Pope saidsimplesimon Oct 2017 #9
Well, didn't Jesus hang around with the dregs of society also? Lokilooney Oct 2017 #18
He also had saidsimplesimon Oct 2017 #19
Yes Lokilooney Oct 2017 #23
I'm an atheist but I dig this Pope. apnu Oct 2017 #10
Name one specific issue he's progressive on that isn't copy/paste from pope John Paul II. AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #11
But you are being an asshole apnu Oct 2017 #12
John Paul II had significant issues with poverty as well. AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #14
His recent very controversial letter about the family, that got him slapped down pnwmom Oct 2017 #13
This qualifies as 'progressive'? AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #15
I hear you, AtheistCrusader. sandensea Oct 2017 #20
Climate Change-He's way ahead of the U.S. policies, not that hard these days Dread Pirate Roberts Oct 2017 #16
The RCC (not the USCCB) is divesting of carbon stocks. AtheistCrusader Oct 2017 #22
This is a huge source of fighting between Catholics in this country. Willie Pep Oct 2017 #17
figured this would be a tough sell in the USA rurallib Oct 2017 #21
And all the hard-line social conservative Catholics Vogon_Glory Oct 2017 #24
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Pope Francis Demands Cath...»Reply #12