Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Latest Breaking News

Showing Original Post only (View all)

BumRushDaShow

(128,920 posts)
Fri Jul 30, 2021, 01:14 PM Jul 2021

CDC study shows three-fourths of people infected in Massachusetts covid-19 outbreak were vaccinated [View all]

Source: Washington Post

A sobering scientific analysis published Friday of an explosive Massachusetts covid-19 outbreak fueled by the delta variant found that three-quarters of the people who became infected were fully vaccinated. The report, from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, bolstered the hypothesis that vaccinated people can spread the more transmissible variant and may be a factor in the summer surge of infections. The data, detailed in the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, provided key evidence that convinced agency scientists to reverse recommendations on mask-wearing and advise that vaccinated individuals wear masks in indoor public settings in some circumstances.

Critically, the study found that vaccinated individuals carried as much virus in their noses as unvaccinated individuals, and that vaccinated people could spread the virus to each other. The CDC was criticized this week for changing its mask guidance without citing unpublished data. The report released Friday contains that data. "This finding is concerning and was a pivotal discovery leading to CDC's updated mask recommendation," CDC director Rochelle Walensky said in a statement. "The masking recommendation was updated to ensure the vaccinated public would not unknowingly transmit virus to others, including their unvaccinated or immunocompromised loved ones."

Scientists said the Provincetown outbreak and other recent data on breakthrough infections make clear that the vaccines do work, as hoped, against severe illness and death, but do not offer blanket protection against any chance of infection. Only a handful of people in the outbreak were hospitalized, but four of them were fully vaccinated. A CDC internal document obtained by The Washington Post estimated that 35,000 vaccinated people a week are having symptomatic breakthrough infections out of a vaccinated population of more than 162 million. Vaccination coverage is higher than average in Massachusetts, with nearly 70 percent of residents fully vaccinated.

"This shows the delta is formidable," said Larry Corey, a virologist at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center. "We can't take one report of packed bars and extrapolate and say the sky is falling. The sky is not falling. But it does say the vaccine is not infallible. "Common sense has to be used," Corey said. "It's a learning moment, it's a teaching moment. You can't overlook the vast data we have on the effectiveness of the vaccine."

Read more: https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/07/30/provincetown-covid-outbreak-vaccinated/



I know there was mention at the CDC telecon presser that the data would be released.

ETA - here is a link to their report - https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7031e2.htm?s_cidmm7031e2_w

ETA 2 - Here was Fauci discussing the problem with Delta this past Wednesday -

158 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Public Health Officials need to be clear on the message that vaccines stop mucifer Jul 2021 #1
Maybe, but I think there is a leap in your reasoning TimeToGo Jul 2021 #38
reread my post I was clear. I said almost always stops severe illness or death with delta mucifer Jul 2021 #39
Two weeks ago it was reported 79 fully vaccinated died in Mass womanofthehills Jul 2021 #75
Over 4 million fully vaccinated cannabis_flower Jul 2021 #84
Those percentages would be meaningful if all the vaccinated were infected with the Delta variant. NH Ethylene Jul 2021 #97
0.0019 percent Major Nikon Jul 2021 #85
In Illinois it's a few hundred people. They mostly have pre existing conditions and 6 million mucifer Jul 2021 #87
I was going by this line: TimeToGo Jul 2021 #102
just like the flu vaccine agingdem Jul 2021 #82
Fauci clarified this today in an NPR interview. wnylib Jul 2021 #89
I don't think "only" is accurate as to earlier variants - Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #99
I'm pretty sure that, before delta, Fauci wnylib Jul 2021 #104
Again. I'm pretty sure transmission is possible in breakthrough cases Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #108
I agree that many people do speak wnylib Jul 2021 #118
You do recall his early statements on masks, don't you? Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #119
And that the vaccines were developed for the ORIGINAL strain oldsoftie Jul 2021 #69
Long haul also can, and often does, occur in fully vaxed folks SheltieLover Jul 2021 #2
Really? First I've heard of this. Can you provide a link? Dream Girl Jul 2021 #5
Talk to OhioChick SheltieLover Jul 2021 #14
Thanks. In order to have "long haul" I'm assuming one would have to be symptomatic and pretty Dream Girl Jul 2021 #26
The way I understand it, SheltieLover Jul 2021 #28
Long haul COVID does occur in mild, even asymptomatic, cases. Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #33
You are so right! Tadpole Raisin Jul 2021 #58
One of my friends in Provincetown, and a friend of his Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #66
Totally agree that people on DU are buying into wnylib Jul 2021 #100
They don't Rebl2 Jul 2021 #95
Thanks. You beat me to it, and from the same sources. wnylib Jul 2021 #98
They seem to conflate people who were not hospitalized with "asymptotic" people, then they drag in Dream Girl Jul 2021 #106
Check out the link at post #33 for the wnylib Jul 2021 #122
I appreciate the info hueymahl Jul 2021 #27
Pls talk to OhioChick SheltieLover Jul 2021 #29
So, no links? hueymahl Jul 2021 #31
OhioChick was very helpful with me when BigmanPigman Jul 2021 #88
Yes SheltieLover Jul 2021 #111
Oh no, I had no idea. BigmanPigman Jul 2021 #121
Yes. SheltieLover Jul 2021 #126
People should listen to her experiences BigmanPigman Jul 2021 #129
Read some of the pushback I've gotten on this thread. SheltieLover Jul 2021 #130
I appreciate your message and your efforts here SayitAintSo Aug 2021 #149
It's actually pretty easy to find doing a google search. Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #34
Thank you!!! hueymahl Jul 2021 #35
This is a limited sub sample (nine cases) that can't be generalized without further research Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #43
Yes, in the Israel study, it seems like only 2 out of orginal 39 people developed true long COVID LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #54
I didn't make the claim it was often. Ms. Toad Jul 2021 #70
I heard a story on NPR the other dasy regarding this oldsoftie Jul 2021 #71
Read mstoad's #33. She cites the wnylib Jul 2021 #115
Thx Wyn. SheltieLover Jul 2021 #127
I didn't see that post. I don't know what that wnylib Jul 2021 #135
OMG! What a coincidence! wnylib Jul 2021 #139
Yup SheltieLover Aug 2021 #150
It's true."Those who are vaccinated did everything right, but some are going to go on to long-COVID" PSPS Jul 2021 #36
I was just going to post that -- here is the original article in NEJM LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #52
I have read this, too. I read so many studies wnylib Jul 2021 #90
Same here, Wyn. SheltieLover Aug 2021 #151
"often does"? LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #8
Pls see post #14 SheltieLover Jul 2021 #17
Also #36 SheltieLover Jul 2021 #48
19% in one study. NH Ethylene Jul 2021 #113
Thx! SheltieLover Jul 2021 #128
"Often" is a false statement. Nt Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #13
It most certainly is not SheltieLover Jul 2021 #16
Without proof, your assertion is worthless. Nt Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #18
Your choice SheltieLover Jul 2021 #19
Lord have mercy......... oldsoftie Jul 2021 #72
Please read all of post #4 here: SheltieLover Jul 2021 #21
Absolutely nothing in that post supports your assertion Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #40
You might have to search his tweets SheltieLover Jul 2021 #41
So, you refuse to retract your unsupported false statement? Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #44
It is not a false statement SheltieLover Jul 2021 #46
The plural of anecdote is not data Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #53
You are most welcome to ignore my posts, my friend SheltieLover Jul 2021 #57
I am more concerned about others in the DU community who may accept your claims as facts. Nt Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #59
I'd rather they think its more often than never nt oldsoftie Jul 2021 #73
Does "rarely" work for you? "Occasionally"? maxsolomon Jul 2021 #93
You should indeed provide support for claims that can cause unnecessary panic FBaggins Jul 2021 #144
Stop playing games. Just put on a mask for Pete's sake. Jakes Progress Jul 2021 #79
Put on a mask? Wat does the have to do with anything. Someone posted that asymptotic Dream Girl Jul 2021 #103
Read the thread. Jakes Progress Jul 2021 #143
this is bs Kali Jul 2021 #23
No, it is not. SheltieLover Jul 2021 #24
YOU made the claim, the burden of proof is on YOU Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #45
Read #36 SheltieLover Jul 2021 #47
Read #34 and #54 Fiendish Thingy Jul 2021 #56
you need to link to whatever it is you are claiming Kali Jul 2021 #123
I am not spreading lies SheltieLover Jul 2021 #125
no, when I see someone make unsubstantiated claims Kali Jul 2021 #131
Again, feel free to ignore my posts SheltieLover Jul 2021 #132
nah, I try to encourage accuracy when I see it isn't there Kali Jul 2021 #137
Once again, feel free to ignore my posts. SheltieLover Jul 2021 #138
In medical parlance, "long haul" is being called "PASC" (Post-Acute Sequalae of SARS-COV-2) BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #107
And many docs are telling patients "it's all in your head" SheltieLover Jul 2021 #116
From your cited study's origin BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #120
No doubt! SheltieLover Jul 2021 #124
Trump supporters not vaccinating allowed it to get this bad. Eliot Rosewater Jul 2021 #3
Even Hannity telling people every nite to get the shot oldsoftie Jul 2021 #78
Theory. roamer65 Jul 2021 #4
If it was neutralized, how would it reproduce in the host at the same rate as in the unvaccinated? JudyM Jul 2021 #10
Could just be the active replicating... roamer65 Jul 2021 #32
Has to invade cells in order to actively replicate. JudyM Jul 2021 #61
Good question. roamer65 Jul 2021 #63
Ha! Okay. JudyM Jul 2021 #64
Really good post by intrepidity. roamer65 Jul 2021 #65
Skimmed it, good info to read more later. JudyM Jul 2021 #83
211 people Deminpenn Jul 2021 #6
"what subset these 211 people belong"? LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #11
Of the total number of people cited in the study Deminpenn Jul 2021 #15
Sounds like they tested asymptomatic people too LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #22
There is zero reasons to believe those vaccinated patients are an exception. LisaL Jul 2021 #25
PCR tests cannot detect viral loads Deminpenn Jul 2021 #96
"211 people" - is now up to 882 total so far, with 653 (74%) fully vaccinated BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #49
No, the 211 people are the cohort on which the CDC based its guidance Deminpenn Jul 2021 #92
Yes, but those are the people who were most likely just the residents of Provincetown BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #114
Having read your link to the actual CDC study, Deminpenn Jul 2021 #140
Since research is continually on-going BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #142
More here about 1000 times more contagious than the variant we dealt with earlier. JudyM Jul 2021 #7
And more contagious than smallpox! SheltieLover Jul 2021 #20
Hard to tell how meaningful this is... Happy Hoosier Jul 2021 #9
there is a link to the WMMR article which gives a lot more details LymphocyteLover Jul 2021 #12
CDC is full of great people hueymahl Jul 2021 #30
Correct. By itself, the 3/4 figure is meaningless. You'd need to know... thesquanderer Jul 2021 #60
Did you actually look at the research link? BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #68
"clear that the vaccines do work, as hoped, against severe illness and death" IronLionZion Jul 2021 #37
Duh progressoid Jul 2021 #42
Well good that I'm still taking precautions here. Delta is Tadpole Raisin Jul 2021 #50
Hmmm...males who were fully vaccinated..... LeftInTX Jul 2021 #51
Apparently it's time for Pride parades in MA. LisaL Jul 2021 #55
Provincetown has always been a welcoming place and hangout BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #74
I'll stay masked and watch for announcement on boosters. Fact is that while science is doing a good Hoyt Jul 2021 #62
I know two people back home who got infected post-vaccination Phil the Kilibuster Jul 2021 #67
Howdy uppityperson Jul 2021 #133
Howdy right back atcha! Unless you mean CAPTAIN Howdy Phil the Kilibuster Aug 2021 #147
I'm very concerned about this, yikes nt LittleGirl Jul 2021 #76
It really seems that it was foolhardy if not downright irresponsible for the CDC to change their CentralMass Jul 2021 #77
That's it then. Cinnamonspice Jul 2021 #80
And what? What should I do with this information? Jon King Jul 2021 #81
I'm among those that used my concept of common sense and continued to wear a mask. CentralMass Jul 2021 #86
The CDC Director promised to publish info for state, County, and local Health Departments BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #91
CDC FAQs on PCR tests Deminpenn Jul 2021 #94
We are going off the deep end here, none died and only 4 were hospitalized Jon King Jul 2021 #101
You make some good points, however, totodeinhere Jul 2021 #109
Agree Deminpenn Jul 2021 #112
When the CDC changed their guidelines on masks the other day I started wearing a mask again. totodeinhere Jul 2021 #105
This message was self-deleted by its author bucolic_frolic Jul 2021 #110
This is very sobering.................. secondwind Jul 2021 #117
Vaccines are not a forcefield. They never were... TomCADem Jul 2021 #136
Key thing to remember Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Jul 2021 #134
If the viral load is the same between vaccinated and not vaccinated, then there is no reason to LisaL Jul 2021 #141
CDC Says New Mask Guidelines Informed by Cape Cod Outbreak mahatmakanejeeves Jul 2021 #145
There was another outbreak in Wisconsin which showed similar findings BumRushDaShow Jul 2021 #146
What's the definition of "high" and "low"? Deminpenn Aug 2021 #148
FDA publishes a reference standard for the current EUA-approved tests BumRushDaShow Aug 2021 #154
Fine, but what's the "high" and "low" for this Deminpenn Aug 2021 #155
That's not how it correlates BumRushDaShow Aug 2021 #156
Disagree here Deminpenn Aug 2021 #157
I figured you were going to try to argue BumRushDaShow Aug 2021 #158
Not surprising, been seeing this at work madville Aug 2021 #152
Good God. orangecrush Aug 2021 #153
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»CDC study shows three-fou...