Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Asperger's dropped from revised diagnosis manual [View all]proverbialwisdom
(4,959 posts)69. Off-topic, sorry, but that's inaccurate according to JAMA. Please research it.
http://www.ageofautism.com/2012/09/letter-to-the-twincitiescom-editor-take-seriously-concerns-about-vaccine-injury.html
September 12, 2012
...Parenthetically, even the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is admitting that this year's increase in cases of whooping cough is not due to unvaccinated children. It is due to short-lived coverage from the pertussis vaccine.
For example, in California's pertussis surge last year -- in cases where immunization history is known -- 83 percent of the people diagnosed with pertussis had been immunized. In Minnesota in 2010, of the 252 cases of pertussis in infants and children through age 6, 71 percent had received at least the full primary series of three doses of vaccine
September 12, 2012
...Parenthetically, even the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is admitting that this year's increase in cases of whooping cough is not due to unvaccinated children. It is due to short-lived coverage from the pertussis vaccine.
For example, in California's pertussis surge last year -- in cases where immunization history is known -- 83 percent of the people diagnosed with pertussis had been immunized. In Minnesota in 2010, of the 252 cases of pertussis in infants and children through age 6, 71 percent had received at least the full primary series of three doses of vaccine
http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/08/pertussis-vax-effectiveness/
Is Childhood Pertussis Vaccine Less Effective Than We Thought?
By Maryn McKennaEmail Author
August 1, 2012
Delicately and cautiously, health authorities in the United States and other countries are beginning to open up a difficult topic: Whether the extraordinary ongoing epidemic of whooping cough, the worst in more than 50 years, may be due in part to unexpected poor performance by the vaccine meant to prevent the disease.
That possibility, captured in several recent pieces of research one published last night is being raised so carefully because it might lead vaccine opponents to claim incorrectly that pertussis vaccination does not work. That fear contains a deep irony: The current vaccine, in use for about 20 years, replaced an older and more effective one that went out of use because vaccine critics charged it had too high a rate of side effects.
In the most recent research, a letter published Tuesday night in JAMA, researchers in Queensland, Australia examined the incidence of whooping cough in children who were born in 1998, the year in which that province began phasing out whole-cell pertussis vaccine (known as there as DTwP) in favor of less-reactive acellular vaccine (known as DTaP)...
<>
Is Childhood Pertussis Vaccine Less Effective Than We Thought?
By Maryn McKennaEmail Author
August 1, 2012
Delicately and cautiously, health authorities in the United States and other countries are beginning to open up a difficult topic: Whether the extraordinary ongoing epidemic of whooping cough, the worst in more than 50 years, may be due in part to unexpected poor performance by the vaccine meant to prevent the disease.
That possibility, captured in several recent pieces of research one published last night is being raised so carefully because it might lead vaccine opponents to claim incorrectly that pertussis vaccination does not work. That fear contains a deep irony: The current vaccine, in use for about 20 years, replaced an older and more effective one that went out of use because vaccine critics charged it had too high a rate of side effects.
In the most recent research, a letter published Tuesday night in JAMA, researchers in Queensland, Australia examined the incidence of whooping cough in children who were born in 1998, the year in which that province began phasing out whole-cell pertussis vaccine (known as there as DTwP) in favor of less-reactive acellular vaccine (known as DTaP)...
<>
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
115 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
PREDICTION: "Autism isn’t a separate mental condition, it is a medical disorder. Big difference."
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#49
Check it out. Wouldn't you like to know whether his input ended after this came to light?
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#2
I'm sorry, the guy's indictment for fraud isn't woo, nor his involvement in redefining autism. nt
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#6
Treating this guy's wrong-doing as evidence for anti-vax BS is a red herring...
Odin2005
Dec 2012
#9
Meanwhile, largely thanks to antivac woo, pertussis is on the rise and killing people.
Warren Stupidity
Dec 2012
#55
Off-topic, sorry, but that's inaccurate according to JAMA. Please research it.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#69
If you had any scientific evidence of a link, you wouldn't have to rely on character assassination.
jeff47
Dec 2012
#82
Three are leading establishment autism researchers. Why don't you look for their publications?
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#99
Obfuscate all you want, but it's clear answers are forthcoming. Start with confusing 2 with 21.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#103
On the contrary, AoA writers are ALL adamant no study has ever been done comparing the two groups.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#104
"WE HAVE NOT STUDIED VACCINATED VS UNVACCINATED," CDC's Dr. Coleen A. Boyle @ minute 2:34.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#106
Nope. I'm providing analyses by experts for the layperson, and it's absurd to require otherwise.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#110
Nonsense and about those 'criminal fraud charges,' just give it a little time.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#112
'Trifles make perfection, but perfection is no trifle.' -Michelangelo.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#114
So true Odin2005- and some of the comments are SO inappropriate and insensitive.
BeHereNow
Dec 2012
#32
psychiatry and psychology are a very inexact studies - they really cannot be called science
Douglas Carpenter
Dec 2012
#10
How is this late breaking news. This change has been known to the mental health profession for years
olddad56
Dec 2012
#18
Talk about a branch of idiocy based on non-science. The scientific method is NEVER used
LittlestStar
Dec 2012
#21
"Any single person could walk into a shrinks office and get diagnosed with anything..."
greiner3
Dec 2012
#22
(Off topic) Seen this? Rare, but really ugly relatively recent allegations supporting tama's post.
proverbialwisdom
Dec 2012
#97
Scientific method never used? Tell that to B.F. Skinner or Roger Sperry (Nobel laureate)
NoodleyAppendage
Dec 2012
#33
The real problem is that doctors who are NOT QUALIFIED to make mental health diagnoses...
slackmaster
Dec 2012
#43
Same is true for any doctor. If I insist to my GP I have pain in my back, he'll give me meds
Happyhippychick
Dec 2012
#46
No, anti-vaxers deserve summary dismissal based on previously established lack of scientific merit
Occulus
Dec 2012
#80
It may seem like a social construction to you, but if you ever have the misfortune of being in...
slackmaster
Dec 2012
#45
Neither Race nor Gender Constitute an Intrinsic Threat to Survival of the Individual
Demeter
Dec 2012
#48
so true. it is this medical model that prevents people from going into this career field...
olddad56
Dec 2012
#66
I doubt very much that you will lose any benefits because of your son's condition being re-named
slackmaster
Dec 2012
#89