Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

NanaCat

(2,332 posts)
20. South Korea's at least requires all males to serve
Sun May 26, 2024, 03:06 AM
May 2024

Before they turn 30. Doesn't matter how rich or famous you are. The only exception is a serious medical condition. And even that has to be one that can make you drop dead at any second. That is not a joke.



That guy is Kyuhyun, lead singer of the boy band Super Junior. In 2014, he was in a near-fatal car accident that shattered his hip, broke several ribs and caused his lungs to collapse. Doctors gave him only a 20% chance of surviving. It took him nearly a year to recuperate and go back to performing.

Despite those injuries, he still had to serve. He did 'light duty,' but, still, he had to serve despite his former injuries.

This is his bandmate, Siwon, who also had to serve:



Siwon's family is one of the wealthiest in Korea, and he's their sole heir. There was no buying his way out. He had to serve, same as anyone else.

If everyone had to serve, save for the rare exceptions of adverse health conditions, then maybe people wouldn't resist the idea of national service. There's a case for selling it as everyone pitching in and doing their share for the greater good; that's how Korea presents it, but East Asian societies in general are far more receptive to the idea than other places.

The West in general isn't open to that kind of selfless thinking. The US especially will never accept national service after the favoritism shown to the well-to-do for mandatory service in Vietnam. The anger and resentment of that epic fail has never died down to any significant degree. Probably never will.

Well that's one way to attract the youth vote... mwooldri May 2024 #1
I suppose it depends on how much solidarity there is from the older siblings muriel_volestrangler May 2024 #3
I doubt it will work out well. Baitball Blogger May 2024 #15
Fotced to volunteer? tirebiter May 2024 #21
Well, the post clearly says E. Normus May 2024 #27
I totally agree. "National Service" can be a good idea if done well. RandomNumbers May 2024 #35
I was elected to our local school board in the late 1990's. I tried to get Community Service program for a High School.. usaf-vet May 2024 #41
The OP failed to include the fact that this is in the UK not the USA. littlemissmartypants May 2024 #45
it is obviously about the UK Celerity May 2024 #47
I thought it was obvious when I read the snip in the OP. Igel May 2024 #53
it is frustrating Celerity May 2024 #55
I'm not going to untrash the thread but thanks for the clarification. ❤️ littlemissmartypants May 2024 #54
We had a name for this in the military... Shipwack May 2024 #48
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing PatSeg May 2024 #6
IKR?! sheshe2 May 2024 #18
I resemble that....don't give them any ideas. walkingman May 2024 #28
Yes, be sure to repel every possible demographic PatSeg May 2024 #29
Head of the repukes didnt serve in the military. Mr Bone Spur lied about an injury Trueblue1968 May 2024 #44
Good thing this is Britain jimfields33 May 2024 #52
The tories already have only a small chance ... Tennessee Hillbilly May 2024 #2
Oh, well. At least Rishi has his wife's money laundering to keep him in curry. peppertree May 2024 #34
This can't be! I thought conservatives were against big government? /nt progree May 2024 #4
I think these are British conservatives... reACTIONary May 2024 #7
National Service (the Draft) Now That's a Vote Winner! PM Hacker wanted the same. Sir Humphrey thwarted him- SorellaLaBefana May 2024 #5
"Yes, Minister" and "Yes, Prime Minister" markodochartaigh May 2024 #10
Two of the best shows ever ZonkerHarris May 2024 #39
Seems reasonable since it does have options other than military service . cstanleytech May 2024 #8
It's deeply stupid, and a desperate attempt at pandering from a political incompetent Emrys May 2024 #17
Those are all very valid concerns and before I would prove other of course I'd want to see concrete plans. cstanleytech May 2024 #19
In the UK, many 18-year-olds are leaving secondary school Emrys May 2024 #25
You're raising some valid issues and problems with the idea that had not occured to me, thank you :-) cstanleytech May 2024 #32
No worries. Emrys May 2024 #33
If I understand UK politics correctly, and I don't know nearly as much tornado34jh May 2024 #9
UK voters will see it as a last gasp stunt of a doomed government. speak easy May 2024 #13
South Korea's at least requires all males to serve NanaCat May 2024 #20
They make a few exceptions in Korea. LisaM May 2024 #24
Or they can do it the way the South Koreans do it. Baitball Blogger May 2024 #11
"I think this is a better system." speak easy May 2024 #14
Maybe that will finally kick the Tories out of office for a while Warpy May 2024 #12
Yeah, right. I'll believe that when I see it. They dont't want their own sons and daughters drafted so they'll Martin68 May 2024 #16
We need something similar here. oldsoftie May 2024 #22
I agree. H2O Man May 2024 #40
Good idea. James48 May 2024 #23
I've always been supportive of this idea aeromanKC May 2024 #26
I agree, but to do it correctly will require a huge expenditure RandomNumbers May 2024 #36
What the first day will be like ArkansasDemocrat1 May 2024 #30
Deputy PM Salvini (Italy) JustAnotherGen May 2024 #31
Are we sure Republicans won't go for this? ificandream May 2024 #37
Oy! LudwigPastorius May 2024 #38
I think Democrats would stand back and let them do that. It would lose them the election. Martin68 May 2024 #42
I worked for decades and the government took part of the money, every payday. Seems to me like, well, public service. twodogsbarking May 2024 #43
Trashed. littlemissmartypants May 2024 #46
Unless you have bone spurs. Sneederbunk May 2024 #49
Here's the UK MoD's official stance rejecting this stupid idea from last Thursday in Parliament Emrys May 2024 #50
Getting Ready for Putin's war........** NGeorgian May 2024 #51
Come on people... this is a UK article. WarGamer May 2024 #56
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Conservatives plan to bri...»Reply #20