Why Astrology Isn't Real Science

[bobnicewander]

11. Not calling my practice a science

My reply in: Religion & Spirituality » Astrology, Spirituality & Alternative Healing (Group) on Oct 25:

https://www.democraticunderground.com/122018537#post2 in "Hard transits to 2017 inauguration"

"bobnicewander (97 posts)

2. From previous posts

For those who have little or no knowledge of astrology (and for many who do) - there is no way to know what any aspect may coordinate with. Think about the horoscopes of multiple birth siblings - twins, triplets, etc.. They have virtually the same charts (as we say in astrology) but not the same experiences at the same time - getting married, having babies, suffering major injuries or illnesses and on and on. The marriage of one is a happy experience shared by all in some manner but no astrologer, without inside information, could say which one it would be or even name the event looking at the charts perhaps 3 years before. All that could really be seen in them would likely be a positive or easy or happy time in them.

That is why there have been no astrologers, no matter how famous, that can be shown to have a string of exact predictions despite the great number of practitioners through thousands of years. If anybody thinks differently I have a chart covering almost 79 years and would like them to prove their case by telling me what exactly occurred when and where I experienced even 1 aspect in my life.

I can determine when tRump may experience difficult times but as to what event it may coordinate with if any is known about (because we experience some things on a psychological level which we may not share with anyone and/or on a cellular level like when a tumor is growing that we ourselves do not know about) the best that might be done is to get in the ballpark or get lucky with our guess based on some knowledge [like the date and time of a court appearance] and get it right.

I chose the January 2020 time for tRump's leaving office because of the transits to his natal chart then coupled with his current and what I presume will be an ongoing situation."

and posted in that group on January 13th in "My tRump Astrology and Info Posts" https://www.democraticunderground.com/122018291

"An event that precipitates September 18th and 19th station occurs on about July 25th. this year."

My November 15, 2016, post elsewhere about tRump's troubles this coming January:

By: Bob on November 15th, 2016, at 10:57 pm

'Charts showing Donald’s and Donald Jr.’s charts engaged by the total solar eclipse in August 2017 and the Saturn and Pluto conjunction in January of 2020. It looks like a family affair.

http://imgur.com/a/UyQXj