Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

panfluteman

(2,075 posts)
16. Astrology is a science, but it is a different kind of science than reductionistic modern science.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 10:08 AM
Nov 2019

It's more holistic and metaphysical in its orientation. And using astrology, I have been able to find out very specific things and information that has been very useful in helping my clients - and many times, they have asked me, "How the heck did you know that?" And my answer is that I read the stars - call it stellar literacy, if you will. And the degree of precision you can get in the information you obtain depends on how well your stellar literacy skills are developed and honed - it's just like how well you can read a book depends on how literate you are. I spend several hours on peparation and basic planetary calculations before giving a consultation, and believe me, it's hard and intricate work, but absolutely necessary if you want to do a good job as an astrologer.

You talk about astronomy evolving our of astrology, but in truth, before the Age of Enlightenment, both sciences were one. Johannes Kepler was the last astronomer who was also an astrologer - and now, the leading astrology school in the United States, Kepler University, in Seatlle Washington, which is where I learned how to play the panflute, is named after him. Sir Isaac Newton was also a student and practitioner of astrology, and of alchemy as well. When his friend Mr. Haley, the discoverer of Haley's Comet, derided him for his belief in astrology, Newton basically told him to shut up and not pontificate about something he knew nothing about, saying to him, "You haven't studied astrology; I have."

Why Astrology Isn't Real Science [View all] Quixote1818 Nov 2019 OP
I'm an Aries with Capricorn rising. This perhaps explains my disdain for astrology. Beakybird Nov 2019 #1
She is right on the money! CaliforniaPeggy Nov 2019 #2
Astrology is not science, but it has a historical relationship to science. Lionel Mandrake Nov 2019 #3
astrology's right up there with alchemy eShirl Nov 2019 #8
It's several notches down from even alchemy Major Nikon Nov 2019 #14
Astrology is a science, but it is a different kind of science than reductionistic modern science. panfluteman Nov 2019 #16
Astrology is a pseudoscience Major Nikon Nov 2019 #23
As an astrologer, you have a vested interest in this nonsense. Lionel Mandrake Nov 2019 #28
Here's another huge problem with Americans PJMcK Nov 2019 #4
And That Daily Horoscope Column Is Not Worth the Paper It is Printed On. panfluteman Nov 2019 #17
when are you going to update scarytomcat Nov 2019 #25
Yeah, yeah, yeah - The Same Tired Arguments Against Astrology panfluteman Nov 2019 #5
honestly, it sounds more like a religion than a science eShirl Nov 2019 #9
Yeah, yeah the same tired arguments trying to validate another pseudoscience Major Nikon Nov 2019 #12
Every time astrology is called on to provide actual (gasp) EVIDENCE... Archae Nov 2019 #15
The OP details several of those failures Major Nikon Nov 2019 #18
Twins courtjester Nov 2019 #6
Donald Trump Horoscope: What His Astrology Chart Reveals dalton99a Nov 2019 #7
That so-called astrologer has a veneer of astrological knowledge, but most of it is BS panfluteman Nov 2019 #19
Oh Yeah - and Another Thing About Trump's Uranus panfluteman Nov 2019 #22
That it has to be even explained is crazy Woodwizard Nov 2019 #10
Pseudoscience will always have adherents Major Nikon Nov 2019 #13
Not calling my practice a science bobnicewander Nov 2019 #11
Umm, astrology isn't "real" science because it isn't real science. 'Nuff said. Nitram Nov 2019 #20
People like bullshit that "explains" everything. Archae Nov 2019 #21
At least you didn't include homeopathy Major Nikon Nov 2019 #24
Many people look for certainty in an uncertain world dlk Nov 2019 #26
Carl Sagan said it so well... Thunderbeast Nov 2019 #27
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Video & Multimedia»Why Astrology Isn't Real ...»Reply #16