Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Economy
In reply to the discussion: Weekend Economists Ask: R WEE Donne? January 8-10, 2016 [View all]Proserpina
(2,352 posts)26. The Death of the Professional: Are Doctors, Lawyers and Accountants Becoming Obsolete?
Adapted from the new book The Future of the Professions by Richard Susskind & Daniel Susskind (Oxford University Press, 2015).
http://www.alternet.org/books/death-professional-are-doctors-lawyers-and-accountants-becoming-obsolete
The end of the professional era is characterized by four trends: the move from bespoke service; the bypassing of traditional gatekeepers; a shift from a reactive to a proactive approach to professional work; and the more-for-less challenge.
The Move From Bespoke (Custom) Service
For centuries, much professional work has been handled in the manner of a craft. Individual experts and specialistspeople who know more than othershave offered an essentially bespoke service (bespoke is British for custom). In the language of the tailor, their product has been made-to-measure rather than off-the-peg. For each recipient the service has been disposable (used once only), handcrafted ordinarily by a solitary scribe or sole trusted adviser, often in the spirit of an artist who starts each project afresh with a blank canvas...Our research strongly suggests that bespoke professional work in this vein looks set to fade from prominence, as other crafts (like tailoring and tallow chandlering) have done over the centuries. Significant elements of professional work are being routinized: in checklists, standard form materials, and in various sorts of systems, many of which are available online. Meanwhile, the work that remains for human beings to handle conventionally is often not conducted by individual craftspeople, but collaboratively in teams, sometimes collocated, but more often virtually. And, with the advance of increasingly capable machines, some work may not be conducted by human beings at all.
Just as we witnessed the death of gentlemanly capitalism in the banks in the 1980s, we seem to be observing a similar decline in bespoke professionalism.
The Bypassed Gatekeepers
In the past, when in need of expert guidance we turned to the professions. Their members knew things that others did not, and we drew on their knowledge and experience to solve our problems. Each profession acted as a gatekeeper of its own, distinct body of practical expertise. Today this set-up is under threat...We are already seeing some work being wrested from the hands of traditional professions. Some of the competition is coming from within. We observe professionals from different professions doing each others work. They even speak of eating one anothers lunch. Accountants and consultants, for example, are particularly effective at encroaching on the business of lawyers and actuaries. We also see intra-professional friction, when, for example, nurses take on work that used to be exclusive to doctors, or paralegals are engaged to perform tasks that formerly were the province of lawyers. But the competition is also advancing from outside the traditional boundaries of the professionsfrom new people and different institutions. We see a recurring need to draw on people with very different skills, talents, and ways of working... communities of experience, as we call them, are springing up across many professions (for example, PatientsLikeMe and the WebMD communities in medicine). We say more about them in a moment. More radical still are systems and machines that themselves generate practical expertise. These are underpinned by a variety of advanced techniques, such as Big Data and artificial intelligence. These platforms and systems tend not to be owned and run by the traditional professions. Whether those who do so will in turn become new gatekeepers is a subject of some concern.
more
it still won't save us
http://www.alternet.org/books/death-professional-are-doctors-lawyers-and-accountants-becoming-obsolete
The end of the professional era is characterized by four trends: the move from bespoke service; the bypassing of traditional gatekeepers; a shift from a reactive to a proactive approach to professional work; and the more-for-less challenge.
The Move From Bespoke (Custom) Service
For centuries, much professional work has been handled in the manner of a craft. Individual experts and specialistspeople who know more than othershave offered an essentially bespoke service (bespoke is British for custom). In the language of the tailor, their product has been made-to-measure rather than off-the-peg. For each recipient the service has been disposable (used once only), handcrafted ordinarily by a solitary scribe or sole trusted adviser, often in the spirit of an artist who starts each project afresh with a blank canvas...Our research strongly suggests that bespoke professional work in this vein looks set to fade from prominence, as other crafts (like tailoring and tallow chandlering) have done over the centuries. Significant elements of professional work are being routinized: in checklists, standard form materials, and in various sorts of systems, many of which are available online. Meanwhile, the work that remains for human beings to handle conventionally is often not conducted by individual craftspeople, but collaboratively in teams, sometimes collocated, but more often virtually. And, with the advance of increasingly capable machines, some work may not be conducted by human beings at all.
Just as we witnessed the death of gentlemanly capitalism in the banks in the 1980s, we seem to be observing a similar decline in bespoke professionalism.
The Bypassed Gatekeepers
In the past, when in need of expert guidance we turned to the professions. Their members knew things that others did not, and we drew on their knowledge and experience to solve our problems. Each profession acted as a gatekeeper of its own, distinct body of practical expertise. Today this set-up is under threat...We are already seeing some work being wrested from the hands of traditional professions. Some of the competition is coming from within. We observe professionals from different professions doing each others work. They even speak of eating one anothers lunch. Accountants and consultants, for example, are particularly effective at encroaching on the business of lawyers and actuaries. We also see intra-professional friction, when, for example, nurses take on work that used to be exclusive to doctors, or paralegals are engaged to perform tasks that formerly were the province of lawyers. But the competition is also advancing from outside the traditional boundaries of the professionsfrom new people and different institutions. We see a recurring need to draw on people with very different skills, talents, and ways of working... communities of experience, as we call them, are springing up across many professions (for example, PatientsLikeMe and the WebMD communities in medicine). We say more about them in a moment. More radical still are systems and machines that themselves generate practical expertise. These are underpinned by a variety of advanced techniques, such as Big Data and artificial intelligence. These platforms and systems tend not to be owned and run by the traditional professions. Whether those who do so will in turn become new gatekeepers is a subject of some concern.
more
it still won't save us
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
43 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
45 Million Americans Live in Poverty,but You Wouldn’t Know It From Watching (election) 2016 Coverage
Proserpina
Jan 2016
#10
Those people sinking back into poverty haven't had any time to recoup from their previous stay
Proserpina
Jan 2016
#11
I've seen it and the thought is scary. I suggest everyone keep some of their money...
Hotler
Jan 2016
#17
I read about the bail-ins probably a year ago. What I find most stunning this time around
magical thyme
Jan 2016
#30
The Death of the Professional: Are Doctors, Lawyers and Accountants Becoming Obsolete?
Proserpina
Jan 2016
#26