Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

progree

(10,928 posts)
17. In my case, yes, for the IRA RMDs (Fidelity) and Roth conversions (Vanguard)
Sat Mar 14, 2020, 07:43 PM
Mar 2020

that I do (the Roth conversions are done via a transfer of shares from the Vanguard traditional IRA account to the Vanguard Roth IRA account.

The IRA RMD's can ???? <- (question marks edited in later) be done via a direct transfer of shares from a Fidelity IRA account to a regular taxable Fidelity account, though like I said in #15, I've been doing the Fidelity thing via sell-transfer-buy as part of an annual reallocation plan). EDITED TO ADD: Well, I actually tried to do an IRA RMD via direct transfer of shares like described above, I tried twice about 4 hours apart, and I seem not to be able to do it, so I have egg on my face here. It just asked for a dollar amount -- didn't let me specify a certain holding like a mutual fund, let alone a number of shares of it -- and then when I tried to go further, it said " (MMMH2000) Your transaction cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later, or call a Fidelity Representative at 800-544-6666." )

But I've transferred shares between financial firms many times -- when I inherited (several accounts at several firms), also, Smith Barney -> Vanguard (an IRA), transferring my Xcel Energy 401 K and my ESOP to a Vanguard IRA.


EDITED TO ADD -- my memory is vague on the details -- the Xcel stuff (it was NSP back then) was in 2000 or so. Smith Barney, maybe 2007. The inheritance stuff was 2005 and my sister (the executor of the estate) did much of the work. There were certainly phone calls and long discussions involved and actual old-fashioned snail mail paperwork involved, medallion signature guarantees where I had to go to a bank, crap like that, I just don't remember.

Many more edits for clarity made around 650p - 700p central time.

Edited to add 1213a central time 3/15 the stuff on trying to do a Fidelity IRA RMD via direct transfer of shares and not succeeding.

Sounds like a good idea, but I'm not a trader, elleng Mar 2020 #1
And that is fair enough.... A HERETIC I AM Mar 2020 #2
I agree, but won't have 'spare dollars' for a month or so; elleng Mar 2020 #4
A month from now (or two months from now) lastlib Mar 2020 #11
I think so too. elleng Mar 2020 #12
Yes, for those who have some spare cash, this is a good time to start buying. PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 2020 #3
Sorry, but things have changed in the past few days. question everything Mar 2020 #14
yep. I'm considering dollar cost averaging my way back in. Pobeka Mar 2020 #5
Loud and clear!! Kilgore Mar 2020 #6
My "circuit breaker" got triggered today. With S&P 500 closing down 25% from all-time high. progree Mar 2020 #7
Perhaps the Consumer Cyclicals. A HERETIC I AM Mar 2020 #8
Thanks! I'm surprised it didn't pass through my mind, considering I had "cycles" in mind! but yeah progree Mar 2020 #9
As Rothchild said "the time to buy is when there is blood in the streets" nt mitch96 Mar 2020 #10
COSTCO, Procter and Gamble (the makers of Charmin TP) question everything Mar 2020 #13
One does not have to sell equities in order to make IRA withdrawals (RMD's or otherwise) progree Mar 2020 #15
Are both the IRA and the taxable account held by the same firm? question everything Mar 2020 #16
In my case, yes, for the IRA RMDs (Fidelity) and Roth conversions (Vanguard) progree Mar 2020 #17
Update: I just tried Fidelity IRA RMD withdrawal via direct transfer of shares to a regular progree Mar 2020 #18
Well, will take my time. Obviously will have to do it by phone so will wait. question everything Mar 2020 #19
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Personal Finance and Investing»This may very well be sta...»Reply #17