Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Straw Man

(6,625 posts)
56. Perhaps you meant "boar" -- or was that a pun?
Sun Apr 9, 2017, 04:34 AM
Apr 2017
As I said people with guns tend to support oppressive government.

Rarely does one encounter such a vague and unfounded generalization. Guns = Oppression. How much more reductive could you get?

As has been pointed out, many of your historical references are sketchy to the point of being misleading. I have never heard so many rationalizations for an oppressive policy (the disarmament of the general public) couched in so much pseudo-liberationist rhetoric.

The largest revolution in history was led by a little man wearing a diaper whilst preaching non-violence.

Gandhi wasn't facing a Hitler or a Pol Pot. What chance would his non-violent revolution have stood there? And as has been pointed out, many other factors were involved in Indian independence.

Here is Gandhi in 1930:

And why do I regard the British rule as a curse?

It has impoverished the dumb millions by a system of progressive exploitation and by a ruinously expensive military and civil administration which the country can never afford.

It has reduced us politically to serfdom. It has sapped the foundations of our culture, and, by the policy of disarmament, it has degraded us spiritually. Lacking inward strength, we have been reduced by all but universal disarmament to a state bordering on cowardly helplessness.

-- Gandhi's First Letter to Lord Irwin

And I sincerely think that calling Gandhi a "little man wearing a diaper" is at best culturally tone-deaf and patronizing, and at worst ... well, never mind.
So the government still uses muskets? angstlessk Apr 2017 #1
"1. So the government still uses muskets?" wincest Apr 2017 #2
Ever hear of DRONES with WEAPONS? angstlessk Apr 2017 #3
Ever hear of snipers? n/t discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2017 #6
So you think citizens can take on the government angstlessk Apr 2017 #7
I think history speaks for itself discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2017 #9
A few rifles is all it takes to defeat the other guys with rifles guarding the big things that Jonny Appleseed Apr 2017 #51
Ever hear of AFGHANISTAN, as of three weeks ago? friendly_iconoclast Apr 2017 #25
And......crickets.. nt pkdu Apr 2017 #53
Arms in the hands of private citizens Buzz cook Apr 2017 #4
don't care wincest Apr 2017 #5
Arms and rights. Straw Man Apr 2017 #12
Jim Crow was inforced by private citizens Buzz cook Apr 2017 #30
Jim Crow was enforced by racist police departments. Straw Man Apr 2017 #35
The right to bear arms is tits on a bore. Buzz cook Apr 2017 #46
Some of your responses are rather ahistorical, and deserve a fisking friendly_iconoclast Apr 2017 #55
Fisking Buzz cook Apr 2017 #60
Specifically, there is no indication that the Framers of the Amendment gejohnston Apr 2017 #61
Yup gun control has a racist aspect and Buzz cook Apr 2017 #74
Perhaps you meant "boar" -- or was that a pun? Straw Man Apr 2017 #56
Hey thanks for implying that I was a racist Buzz cook Apr 2017 #59
You made your bed. Straw Man Apr 2017 #62
You're showing your ignorance. Buzz cook Apr 2017 #73
Of what? Straw Man Apr 2017 #75
Well I guess then you're Buzz cook Apr 2017 #77
Silly. Straw Man Apr 2017 #78
The reek of weekend warrior is in the air. It must be spring. Squinch Apr 2017 #8
"reek" wincest Apr 2017 #11
So, Eko Apr 2017 #10
You are allowed to have M 249s sarisataka Apr 2017 #13
What a travesty Eko Apr 2017 #14
I don't have any issues sarisataka Apr 2017 #15
So, Eko Apr 2017 #17
It says you have the right to bear arms sarisataka Apr 2017 #18
The infantry Eko Apr 2017 #20
I have already said sarisataka Apr 2017 #21
Yes. Eko Apr 2017 #22
"If" sarisataka Apr 2017 #31
Eh, Eko Apr 2017 #36
I would disagree sarisataka Apr 2017 #39
Thanks!! Eko Apr 2017 #41
Not exactly. needledriver Apr 2017 #47
That statistic comes from a survey. Eko Apr 2017 #48
You forgot to quote this paragraph. needledriver Apr 2017 #49
True, Eko Apr 2017 #50
W/regard to Kleck's methodology: pablo_marmol Apr 2017 #57
The CDC that Democrats hold in such high esteem refutes Hemenway pablo_marmol Apr 2017 #58
Uh huh. Eko Apr 2017 #63
Why quote from some WaPo employee gejohnston Apr 2017 #64
Wrong. pablo_marmol Apr 2017 #68
Pablo, he must have missed the 500+ post re: Okie self defense in GD. nt yagotme Apr 2017 #71
* pablo_marmol Apr 2017 #79
Excuse the intrusion discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2017 #23
No one has said "each". Eko Apr 2017 #24
The 2A/RKBA has been acknowledged as an "individual" right discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2017 #26
It just seems quite odd. Eko Apr 2017 #29
re: "Would that really be where voting is a right?" agreed sort of discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2017 #33
True. Eko Apr 2017 #37
your god damn right wincest Apr 2017 #16
Why even argue with eko Alea Apr 2017 #19
As a history nerd, I have to say muskets were better weapons for an army. That Guy 888 Apr 2017 #27
Somewhat true. Straw Man Apr 2017 #45
For those of us not in CA, what happens to you HeartachesNhangovers Apr 2017 #28
Do you even have to ask haha Alea Apr 2017 #34
I would, but I don't own any firearms still_one Apr 2017 #32
You could buy one ... Straw Man Apr 2017 #38
hmmmm, Is it required by law that I have to buy a firearm? still_one Apr 2017 #40
Ummmm, ... Straw Man Apr 2017 #42
whew........ Thanks still_one Apr 2017 #43
You're welcome! Straw Man Apr 2017 #44
I continue to wonder why grown men still play 'cowboys & Indians' fantasy. nt fleabiscuit Apr 2017 #52
No need to be sexist. Women play, too. yagotme Apr 2017 #67
Only if we can register A1 Tanks and RPGs too , and maybe Nukes? nt pkdu Apr 2017 #54
You can gejohnston Apr 2017 #65
You can buy all the armored vehicles you can afford. However, if you want to have yagotme Apr 2017 #66
IIRC, gejohnston Apr 2017 #69
If that was the case then, yagotme Apr 2017 #70
Demilling the receivers wasn't what I was thinking of gejohnston Apr 2017 #72
Smaller weapons, cut receivers. yagotme Apr 2017 #76
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»how many of you CA reside...»Reply #56