HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Religion & Spirituality » Religion (Group) » Creation » Reply #63
In the discussion thread: Creation [View all]

Response to guillaumeb (Reply #12)

Thu Aug 11, 2016, 11:12 AM

63. What is this free will that you speak of?

 

We are the products of our genetics and environment, neither of which we have any choice at birth. After that, we think and act based on how our brains have developed in our environment. We don't design our own brains, so our conscious selves don't ultimately control our actions and thoughts. If you believe in a god, then this god is responsible for who we are.

Free will is an illusion. We don't understand how our brains work or how they come to their conclusions. Our heads are black boxes.

We experience inputs into our brains and we experience outputs from our brains. What our brains actually do, we can't know. We experience feelings associated with our thoughts and action. This gives us the illusion that our conscious selves actually made the decision. But our feelings only drive our thoughts and actions by forcing our (outside of conscious) brains to act.

Even when you use sequential logic, ultimately your thoughts come out of your black box.

There is no free will. That is just an excuse for this imaginary god for not being able to see the future and the flaws in creation. God says, the buck don't stop here.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 120 replies Author Time Post
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 OP
exboyfil Aug 2016 #1
TexasProgresive Aug 2016 #2
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #5
cleanhippie Aug 2016 #9
3catwoman3 Aug 2016 #66
cleanhippie Aug 2016 #8
cilla4progress Aug 2016 #59
rogerashton Aug 2016 #101
Jerry442 Aug 2016 #3
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #4
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #6
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #10
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #13
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #23
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #45
trotsky Aug 2016 #50
whatthehey Aug 2016 #52
cleanhippie Aug 2016 #11
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #14
pokerfan Aug 2016 #19
trotsky Aug 2016 #7
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #12
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #15
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #16
trotsky Aug 2016 #17
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #18
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #25
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #31
trotsky Aug 2016 #46
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #49
trotsky Aug 2016 #51
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #53
trotsky Aug 2016 #54
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #57
trotsky Aug 2016 #60
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #61
trotsky Aug 2016 #65
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #24
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #32
cleanhippie Aug 2016 #39
Leontius Aug 2016 #67
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #69
trotsky Aug 2016 #70
Leontius Aug 2016 #71
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #72
edhopper Aug 2016 #28
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #34
edhopper Aug 2016 #36
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #48
Act_of_Reparation Aug 2016 #64
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #75
edhopper Aug 2016 #83
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #84
edhopper Aug 2016 #85
trotsky Aug 2016 #89
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #91
edhopper Aug 2016 #104
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #106
edhopper Aug 2016 #107
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #108
edhopper Aug 2016 #109
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #111
edhopper Aug 2016 #113
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #115
edhopper Aug 2016 #116
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #117
edhopper Aug 2016 #118
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #88
cleanhippie Aug 2016 #38
Humanist_Activist Aug 2016 #40
LineLineReply What is this free will that you speak of?
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #63
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #74
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #77
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #78
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #79
rug Aug 2016 #80
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #81
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #82
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #86
trotsky Aug 2016 #90
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #92
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #93
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #94
trotsky Aug 2016 #95
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #98
trotsky Aug 2016 #120
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #97
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #99
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #100
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #102
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #103
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #105
cpwm17 Aug 2016 #110
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #112
Warren Stupidity Aug 2016 #87
immoderate Aug 2016 #20
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #21
immoderate Aug 2016 #22
edhopper Aug 2016 #26
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #33
edhopper Aug 2016 #37
whatthehey Aug 2016 #56
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #58
whatthehey Aug 2016 #62
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #73
trotsky Aug 2016 #76
True Dough Aug 2016 #55
exboyfil Aug 2016 #27
bulloney Aug 2016 #29
guillaumeb Aug 2016 #35
Humanist_Activist Aug 2016 #41
trotsky Aug 2016 #47
edhopper Aug 2016 #42
pokerfan Aug 2016 #43
grubbs Aug 2016 #30
struggle4progress Aug 2016 #44
DetlefK Aug 2016 #68
Angry Dragon Aug 2016 #96
DetlefK Aug 2016 #114
Oneironaut Aug 2016 #119
Please login to view edit histories.