Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Science
In reply to the discussion: A Minor Problem For Sound Science of the Effect of Offshore Windfarms on Seabirds: There Isn't Any. [View all]Eko
(7,299 posts)18. Yes you have said that many times.
There's nothing clean about gas. Using it as fuel, at any rate, only adds to carbon dioxide and methane in the atmosphere.
Why do you bring this up? I never said it was clean or a good thing at all.
I think your giant windmills are ugly ineffective bling on the natural gas industry, like some garish $100 protective cover on a brand new iPhone. That's not progress.
If we didn't have them we would just be using more natural gas, is that better?
Unlike NNadir, I've no hostility toward neighbors who install solar panels on their roofs -- they are probably powering my 20 watt internet ramblings whenever the sun shines.
Probably? You don't know? Where are you getting your energy from?
The only way out of this hole we've dug is to reverse human population growth and that can only be accomplished by education and birth control, starting with the people who are the most active participants in the high energy consumer economy.
Well, that sounds really good. I believe we need to do that for quite a few reasons. But while we are trying to get our own country to do that (we are down from 2% in the 60's to 1.17% now) how are we going to get other countries to do that in enough time? Also, realize we are the highest energy users in the world. It is the reason our standard of living is so high. How are we going to get other countries to have a lower energy usage per person than us and accept a lower standard of living? By force?
If monster windmills are economically justified in our consumer economy, that's probably a bad thing.
I'm not buying what you are selling.
Windmills dont enable natural gas, without windmills we would just use more natural gas. Windmills decrease the use of natural gas. Its that simple.
Why do you bring this up? I never said it was clean or a good thing at all.
I think your giant windmills are ugly ineffective bling on the natural gas industry, like some garish $100 protective cover on a brand new iPhone. That's not progress.
If we didn't have them we would just be using more natural gas, is that better?
Unlike NNadir, I've no hostility toward neighbors who install solar panels on their roofs -- they are probably powering my 20 watt internet ramblings whenever the sun shines.
Probably? You don't know? Where are you getting your energy from?
The only way out of this hole we've dug is to reverse human population growth and that can only be accomplished by education and birth control, starting with the people who are the most active participants in the high energy consumer economy.
Well, that sounds really good. I believe we need to do that for quite a few reasons. But while we are trying to get our own country to do that (we are down from 2% in the 60's to 1.17% now) how are we going to get other countries to do that in enough time? Also, realize we are the highest energy users in the world. It is the reason our standard of living is so high. How are we going to get other countries to have a lower energy usage per person than us and accept a lower standard of living? By force?
If monster windmills are economically justified in our consumer economy, that's probably a bad thing.
I'm not buying what you are selling.
Windmills dont enable natural gas, without windmills we would just use more natural gas. Windmills decrease the use of natural gas. Its that simple.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
38 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
A Minor Problem For Sound Science of the Effect of Offshore Windfarms on Seabirds: There Isn't Any. [View all]
NNadir
Sep 2017
OP
I live in California. The hills are littered with dead Enron-era wind turbines...
hunter
Sep 2017
#6
Here, too, is another picture from Nature, of the realities of the wind industry.
NNadir
Sep 2017
#5
The same sorts of processes that decrease the bioavailability of toxins like arsenic and lead...
hunter
Oct 2017
#20