Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

localroger

(3,626 posts)
9. This is all well documented by Richard Rhodes
Mon Jun 10, 2019, 08:00 PM
Jun 2019

...in The Making of the Atomic Bomb. The Germans didn't know at the time their carbon was contaminated with boron, so mistakenly came to the conclusion that carbon couldn't be used as a moderator at all, and yes, the British bombed the Norsk Hydro heavy water plant in Norway and sank the last ferry out at our behest to deny them that approach. So they didn't "almost" build a reactor; they built a test article that never came close to sustaining a reaction, and they didn't have the resources to build an expanded version. It didn't help that they had chased away many of their best physicists for the crime of being Jewish. They did have a fair stockpile of uranium on hand which ended up being processed through US production plants to make plutonium after we captured it.

You will also sometimes hear such "almost had a reactor/bomb" claims about the Japanese, but while they had a couple of people who were aware of the possibility of atomic energy their feeble efforts in that direction were even more laughable and hopeless than the Germans'.

Was not the distruction Wellstone ruled Jun 2019 #1
I was thinking this as well, but now it seems it was more of an organizational problem. hunter Jun 2019 #5
Forgot about the Boron Wellstone ruled Jun 2019 #7
There's a fascinating TV miniseries, The Heavy Water War, The Velveteen Ocelot Jun 2019 #2
I'll look for it. hunter Jun 2019 #8
Depleted uranium zipplewrath Jun 2019 #3
Depleted uranium is used because there are huge stockpiles left over from uranium enrichment. hunter Jun 2019 #4
One of my Dad's favorite jokes SCantiGOP Jun 2019 #6
Every "alternative history" following the success of the Trinity Test is moot. hunter Jun 2019 #10
"The U.S.A. would have kept dropping atomic bombs on Japan until they surrendered" Javaman Jun 2019 #16
Caution zipplewrath Jun 2019 #11
This is all well documented by Richard Rhodes localroger Jun 2019 #9
It's harder than one thinks zipplewrath Jun 2019 #12
I remember when I first read about this, still amazes me that it was allowed to happen... Javaman Jun 2019 #18
To quote from the article posted: hunter Jun 2019 #15
Actually it was laughable localroger Jun 2019 #20
that was such a brilliant book. Probably my favorite. nt Javaman Jun 2019 #17
The real irony SCantiGOP Jun 2019 #13
I read a lot of alt history and I always wondered... Javaman Jun 2019 #19
Many Russians were willing to embrace the Germans as saviors localroger Jun 2019 #21
In 1943, after his famous meeting with Heisenberg, Neils Bohr escaped Denmark to England... NNadir Jun 2019 #14
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»The Nazis almost built a ...»Reply #9