Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

2016 Postmortem

Showing Original Post only (View all)

madfloridian

(88,117 posts)
Wed Feb 3, 2016, 12:09 AM Feb 2016

Every time the party's left raises their little pointy heads and makes noises....this stuff happens. [View all]

First off, the meme that we supporters of Bernie Sanders and Bernie Sanders himself are not Democratic enough really needs to stop. It's ridiculous and it's harmful to the party's future success.

Secondly instead of loudly proclaiming victory when the totals for the candidates were only .2% apart, it would be more gracious to acknowledge a worthy opponent for a little while as well as mentioning his supporters enthusiasm. It would not hurt the winner, and it would ease the way for hard feelings to soften.

It's like the party leaders have their standards and rules and talking points, and they don't need the rest of us.

You can't put people down and question their intelligence for a year, and then expect them to be there and fall in line when needed.

I was called "fringe" and worse when my late hubby and I supported Dean. We were accused of being cultlike and True Believers. It wasn't as bad when we supported Obama in 2008.

There has been name-calling by the right wing of the party even as far back as 2000. Gore tried being populist but was dragged back to the right. And they left him hanging along with Florida's hanging chads.

It still goes on. Look at what happened in early December 2013 with the Third Way attack on Elizabeth Warren.

Hunter at Daily Kos wrote about why this happened. He posted a chart showing the Board of Trustees of the Third Way. He labeled it.

Why the Third Way hates Senator Elizabeth Warren

The obsessive centrists of the punditverse were abuzz today with praise for supposed centrist Democratic organization Third Way and their grumbling op-ed condemnation of Democratic liberal populism in abstract and "economic populists" like Sen. Elizabeth Warren in particular.

But why would the Third Way, a very reasonable and centrist organization that just wants both parties to get along and agree to cut Social Security, Medicare, and other social programs be so very worked up about Elizabeth Warren, Wall Street reform, and the mere thought of breaking up large banks? Worked up enough to launch an apparently coordinated effort against those things?




The chart is self-explanatory.

There's a reason that those in the Democratic Party who call themselves "centrists" or "moderates" have had much to say about those of us on the left for years now.

We throw a wrench into their corporate pursuits for the party, and it annoys them.

Howard Dean recognized this in 2010. His words still remain in my mind. He was 100% right.

From the Washington Post 2010:

Dean at progressive conference. Time for Democrats to 'behave like Democrats'

Dean, in a fiery speech Tuesday at the America's Future Now conference, gave voice to frustrations on the left that President Obama and Democratic leaders in Congress have not used their big majorities to pursue a more progressive agenda. "We are done with putting people in office who then forget who got them there," said Dean, a former Democratic National Committee chairman.

"You did your job," Dean added. "You elected Barack Obama. You elected a Democratic Congress. You elected a Democratic Senate. And now it's time for them to behave like Democrats if they want to get reelected. They have forgotten where they came from -- and they haven't been here that long."


Dean echoed other progressive leaders who opened the conference Monday, expressing dismay, even anger, at the White House and Congress, saying they have been too timid and compromising on issues such as health care, the economy, climate change and banking reform.


He went back to being a centrist spokesperson.

I think we have made a difference by not letting these think tanks get away with words against liberals. It seems there is now less of it. I think it is because through the years we called them out on it. With the TPP looming with Democrats' support..we need to speak out and not let them silence us with insults.

Richard Eskow spared no words either right after the 2010 losses.

Resist Wall Street's Shock Doctrine or Keep Listening to the Usual Suspects

After last night's rout, what are these experts advising? You guessed it: more of the same so-called "Centrism." That's an odd word to use for policies that most Americans oppose, like cutting Social Security or allowing bankers to enrich themselves by endangering the economy, but theirs is an Alice-in-Wonderland world.

Real centrists would defend Social Security and do more to rein in Wall Street, since those positions are popular across the political spectrum. It's a good thing the president said today that he wants to spend more time with the American people. Bankers and the Deficit Commission aren't "centrists" where most Americans live.


David Brooks had some strong words for the liberals in the party in 2007. The DLC posted the article prominently at their website. Here is the quote from Brooks at the NYT.

The Center Holds

The fact is, many Democratic politicians privately detest the netroots’ self-righteousness and bullying. They also know their party has a historic opportunity to pick up disaffected Republicans and moderates, so long as they don’t blow it by drifting into cuckoo land. They also know that a Democratic president is going to face challenges from Iran and elsewhere that are going to require hard-line, hawkish responses.


I would have ignored David Brooks and considered the source, but the then alive DLC posted it at their site.

When Tim Kaine was party chairman in 2006 he had some words about blogs and his intention to pay them no attention. Guess he did not realize he was missing out on a lot of good information.

From the Washington Post:

Blogs Attack From Left as Democrats Reach for Center

"Blogs can take up a lot of time if you're on them," Kaine said to reporters Thursday. "You can get a lot done if you're not bitterly partisan."

The Virginia Democrat said he will not adjust his speech to placate the party's base. "I'm not anybody's mouthpiece or shill or poster boy for that matter. I'm going to say what I think needs to be said and they seem very comfortable with that."


From the same article a Democratic lobbyist made it clear that liberals were needed for their money and activism, but the party should not cave to their demands.

"The bloggers and online donors represent an important resource for the party, but they are not representative of the majority you need to win elections," said Steve Elmendorf, a Democratic lobbyist who advised Kerry's 2004 presidential campaign. "The trick will be to harness their energy and their money without looking like you are a captive of the activist left."


And of course Fox News Democratic strategist Kirsten Powers had a lot to say in 2006 about how the liberals were becoming so shrill.

From USA Today:
Election signals decline of old school liberalism

It's more glacial shift than radical revolution, but change is afoot in the Democratic Party.

In a low point in Democratic Party history, Pennsylvania Gov. Bob Casey was banned from speaking at the 1992 Democratic Convention for being opposed to abortion rights. This year, his son, Bob Casey Jr., who holds the same views, was actively recruited by that same Democratic Party and unseated Sen. Rick Santorum, R-Pa.

This was a welcome move in a party that is home to vocal and organized far-left activists and bloggers who have grown increasingly shrill and threatening toward moderate and conservative Democrats. They also have excoriated former president Bill Clinton's brand of centrist politics. They argue for "party discipline," best exemplified by their jihad against Connecticut's Sen. Joe Lieberman for deviating from the party line on the Iraq war. During the past election for Democratic National Committee chair, delegates booed former congressman Tim Roemer of Indiana because he, too, opposes abortion rights.


When they attacked Elizabeth Warren for wanting to expand Social Security, the blogs and posters online hit back hard. That is how it should be. The think tanks who are not really Democrats at all but are led by investment bankers and CEOs will continue to undermine the left, the liberals. But if we speak out they won't be so noisy about it.

There are signs we might be getting across our point that what we really want is for the party to stand up and speak out for the people....not the corporate world.

I guess I'm like a broken record, but it's pretty serious when a party shuts out its left.

I have been a Democrat since the day I could vote for the first time. Bernie may have an I after his name, but he's one of the best and strongest Democrats I've ever seen.

Iowa was an amazing feat for a 73 year old senator from a tiny state. The fact that he raised another million dollars soon after the caucus ended should indicate that he has the funds to be in this for the long run. I know I am.

I would like to once again be considered a Democrat, but then if that's not going to happen I can deal with it.

(Part of this is reposted from a couple of years ago, part is new)

184 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Even Trump was more gracious. Hiraeth Feb 2016 #1
Yes, he was, surprisingly. madfloridian Feb 2016 #2
Didn't think of it at the time but that's true. Jarqui Feb 2016 #3
I just saw Trevor Noah make that point. Yikes. It's true. TwilightGardener Feb 2016 #6
Trevor Noah has established himself as a distinctive and truthful voice in a very short time. Ken Burch Feb 2016 #145
Yep--I've become a fairly regular viewer. TwilightGardener Feb 2016 #149
Will need to watch his show. madfloridian Feb 2016 #183
It's true. senz Feb 2016 #15
She has no humility. She is not humble. She is not salt of the earth. She approaches this as if Hiraeth Feb 2016 #16
It was the same in 2008, as grotesque then as now. senz Feb 2016 #46
She has the common touch of Marie Antoinette hifiguy Feb 2016 #156
I don't think she believes that or has said that but Skidmore Feb 2016 #157
I was looking at footage of her somewhere a few days ago when she was First Lady sabrina 1 Feb 2016 #47
Meh. I think he's just more skilled as a politician. merrily Feb 2016 #49
I gave her the benefit of the doubt for a long time. senz Feb 2016 #54
I just wait for someone to post exactly my thoughts then say +1. Enthusiast Feb 2016 #72
It is sad. senz Feb 2016 #137
+1,000 Pretty much the way I am seeing it also. Bohunk68 Feb 2016 #82
When the righties attacked Hillary for saying, "It takes a village." I would see red. Enthusiast Feb 2016 #164
I honestly think she has an anti-social personality disorder dorkzilla Feb 2016 #75
I'm not a big fan of Hillary, but this is preposterous. BillZBubb Feb 2016 #112
Your disgust is duly noted dorkzilla Feb 2016 #124
... senz Feb 2016 #142
:) dorkzilla Feb 2016 #144
I truly hope you have your head buried in the sand..... pocoloco Feb 2016 #134
LOL --- "Armchair psychologists are always wrong." pablo_marmol Feb 2016 #176
I've had to do quite a bit of research into these things senz Feb 2016 #141
I agree, that’s why I said “personality disorder” in general dorkzilla Feb 2016 #143
another survivor of marriage to NPD here grasswire Feb 2016 #172
That's wrong on so many levels. one_voice Feb 2016 #152
Perhaps. dorkzilla Feb 2016 #155
Really? This is how we win an election? Hekate Feb 2016 #160
I’m not doing anything of the sort dorkzilla Feb 2016 #161
I think people who seek out power and money to the extent Hillary has done, are sabrina 1 Feb 2016 #180
Agreed on all points! nt dorkzilla Feb 2016 #182
Her abused childhood has cast a long, wide and lethal shadow Divernan Feb 2016 #63
Thank you for posting that. If she were private individual I could have compassion for her. Hiraeth Feb 2016 #74
HRC's dad ran as "Democratic leaning independent" & lost. Divernan Feb 2016 #76
two things: (edited) Hiraeth Feb 2016 #81
Thanks Divernan. You put together a lot of information. It's sad and alarming. senz Feb 2016 #151
well, there it is grasswire Feb 2016 #173
He looked terrible arikara Feb 2016 #133
Yes he was. 840high Feb 2016 #21
Indeed he was. Never would I have thought that Trump's campaign was more mature.... George II Feb 2016 #30
Congratulations, you have just crossed over from irritating to irrelevant. Hiraeth Feb 2016 #68
My goodness you are a tolerant person beyond my wildest expectations. A Simple Game Feb 2016 #95
I can understand. and You are right, I am probably too tolerant. Hiraeth Feb 2016 #97
No, don't change I was being hyperbolic, you're fine the way you are. A Simple Game Feb 2016 #104
Ah, thanks Hiraeth Feb 2016 #107
What is telling is that the Oligarchy will do anything to win. We have seen it all before. rhett o rick Feb 2016 #101
"What is telling is that the Oligarchy will do anything to win" And how is that the case.... George II Feb 2016 #109
We are faced with an opponent that has unlimited resources and is not used to losing. rhett o rick Feb 2016 #115
Hillary's loud trumpeting of her "win" lacked maturity. madfloridian Feb 2016 #150
Well, here is her statement from Monday night: George II Feb 2016 #153
True, but he was also a clear second jberryhill Feb 2016 #126
Honestly, that question makes me wonder what would Hillary have acted like if she Hiraeth Feb 2016 #131
Don't worry she'll say nice things humbled_opinion Feb 2016 #178
is that a promise or a threat? Hiraeth Feb 2016 #179
One small correction to your wonderful article. SandersDem Feb 2016 #4
I just saw that! I got that email around 1 am last night...donated then. madfloridian Feb 2016 #10
Sweeeeeet!! InAbLuEsTaTe Feb 2016 #108
Another great OP from you. Thanks! kath Feb 2016 #5
Thanks for the kind words. madfloridian Feb 2016 #168
great post G_j Feb 2016 #7
How very unreasonable of you to actually expect the Democrats to stand for something besides guillaumeb Feb 2016 #8
Oh but of course as soon as we bring up her voting record to prove it VulgarPoet Feb 2016 #77
I believe in evolution. guillaumeb Feb 2016 #116
KnR for visibility. nt tblue37 Feb 2016 #9
Kick ReasonableToo Feb 2016 #11
Kick !! FloriTexan Feb 2016 #12
Recommend. nt Zorra Feb 2016 #13
Kicked and recommended. Uncle Joe Feb 2016 #14
Lawrence O'Donnell said this evening we might not know who actually won Iowa until June Samantha Feb 2016 #17
Didn't the Iowa Dem party refuse to provide the raw data? madfloridian Feb 2016 #20
madfloridian: see the article in Latest Breakings News entitled something like: Samantha Feb 2016 #33
Thanks, I missed that. She just said no. Yes, it's unbelievable. madfloridian Feb 2016 #34
They are treating his supporters as outsiders, too. senz Feb 2016 #56
Given her obvious affiliation with the Clinton campaign, it's surprising she wouldn't winter is coming Feb 2016 #39
Winning is more important to them than appearing fair. DWS has done nothing fair and doesn't rhett o rick Feb 2016 #100
Could he have grounds to sue, then? Liberty Belle Feb 2016 #53
I don't really think so Samantha Feb 2016 #138
I haven't gotten over it either. senz Feb 2016 #48
Honestly, they do not have it all yet Bettie Feb 2016 #111
A lot of states have automatic recounts for differences less than 0.5% or so, iirc. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #79
States have to have their election law rules clearly defined in the State Constitution Samantha Feb 2016 #139
I have so gotten over being a democrat. I was shocked at how easy it was, I told my Autumn Feb 2016 #18
I only came back to being a Democrat so I can vote for Bernie in the primary. Fuddnik Feb 2016 #37
Bernie's the only reason I re registered as one. After I caucus here in CO I'm out again. Autumn Feb 2016 #38
My wife and I ran into the same Mbrow Feb 2016 #73
The Winslow? Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #80
I brought it with. Mbrow Feb 2016 #85
She endorsed a republican opponent? arikara Feb 2016 #135
I left the party 20 or 25 years ago and just came back to vote for Bernie in the primary. A Simple Game Feb 2016 #102
"The trick is to harness their energy & money w/out looking like you're captive to the activis left" 99th_Monkey Feb 2016 #19
I get why the politicians and bankers want to be centrist. cui bono Feb 2016 #22
I began to realize that a youth revolution was about to happen... Peace Patriot Feb 2016 #64
Be glad nobody is calling Martin O'Malley a "spoiler" like Nader. Spitfire of ATJ Feb 2016 #23
Ironically, in Iowa... malthaussen Feb 2016 #114
agreed jham123 Feb 2016 #127
once again, thanks for a great piece mad. k and r! bbgrunt Feb 2016 #24
DLC/Third Way kept identity politics while opening the door to economic predators. senz Feb 2016 #25
Your first sentence is purest gold. hifiguy Feb 2016 #158
Thanks, hifiguy. senz Feb 2016 #162
not much left to say, except K&R mountain grammy Feb 2016 #26
Bernie/we must be scaring the bejeezus out of the corporations/billionaire class. AtomicKitten Feb 2016 #27
Personally i could give a rats ass what the hell they think nolabels Feb 2016 #62
Just like the party of Lincoln hasn't resembled itself in decades, 3rd Way DLCs turned their backs.. MrMickeysMom Feb 2016 #28
I think he decided to come in from the cold. hedda_foil Feb 2016 #40
K&R Armstead Feb 2016 #29
Excellent post...!! PoiBoy Feb 2016 #31
Excellent post as always, MadFlo. Blue_In_AK Feb 2016 #32
K&R Paka Feb 2016 #35
"you did your job"- EXACTLY. And we all remember what happened next, right? Warren DeMontague Feb 2016 #36
Yep, they just kept preaching "bipartisanship." madfloridian Feb 2016 #44
why, it was almost like some of them were uncomfortable without a divided congress as an excuse NOT Warren DeMontague Feb 2016 #58
THANKS For This Great POST... Kicking To get Back To It! n/t ChiciB1 Feb 2016 #41
I love you. Luminous Animal Feb 2016 #42
Back at you... madfloridian Feb 2016 #43
When you're right, you're right! zentrum Feb 2016 #45
Thank you Jack Rabbit Feb 2016 #50
I think Jon Cowan started the Bernie wants fantasy stuff meme. madfloridian Feb 2016 #184
Now, Bernie has a (D) after his name, not an (I). merrily Feb 2016 #51
Excellent post. You smashed it! Nt. Juicy_Bellows Feb 2016 #52
Ooops! Correction: Tim Kaine did not become DNC chair until 2009. madfloridian Feb 2016 #55
Dean did a great job when he was head of the DNC. Unfortunately, Dean has now sold out! Dustlawyer Feb 2016 #86
Still, at one time the Chairperson was elected. Ligyron Feb 2016 #90
Nailed it! Thanks for the post Dretownblues Feb 2016 #57
kick californiabernin Feb 2016 #59
As usual, you've written a really good post. Thanks, madfloridian. nt DisgustipatedinCA Feb 2016 #60
K&R. I have said many times that I will vote for every Democrat JDPriestly Feb 2016 #61
AYUP. Or as we used to say in the Navy: Fucking "A" ditty bag. Bohunk68 Feb 2016 #83
Spot on. There are people who want to care for the least among us. raouldukelives Feb 2016 #65
Hopefully we'll be finished rebuilding the party from the ground up before President Cruz's 2nd term corkhead Feb 2016 #66
K&R grntuscarora Feb 2016 #67
Another great post! Mbrow Feb 2016 #69
Rec to the moon! SusanCalvin Feb 2016 #70
Kicked and recommended! Brilliant! Thank you, madfloridian! Enthusiast Feb 2016 #71
I've been hearing the 'cult' and 'cult leader' accusations Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #78
There is only one woman?! Bet they're all pigment challenged, too. DamnYankeeInHouston Feb 2016 #84
Enthusiastic K&R eom Tom Rinaldo Feb 2016 #87
Afraid to lose their 6 and 7 figure salaries and their inheritor class wealth to their lessers. Festivito Feb 2016 #88
Excellent post once again democrank Feb 2016 #89
Clinton won. Bernie lost. Nitram Feb 2016 #91
do you cut & paste your response to every post?...because it appears your reply islandmkl Feb 2016 #92
Island, your failed attempt at snark is pathetic. The OP wrote... Nitram Feb 2016 #96
well...i have been smacked back...however, you seem to be overly paranoid to think I 'accused' you.. islandmkl Feb 2016 #117
Much as I appreciate your concern for my ability to "absorb its main thrust"... Nitram Feb 2016 #120
Clinton won 2 more national delegates than Sanders. The big winner was the People that rhett o rick Feb 2016 #106
It is Iowa colsohlibgal Feb 2016 #93
Excellent post as usual Mad. Ligyron Feb 2016 #94
Great post and info nyabingi Feb 2016 #98
Great Post - I have been registered as a Democrat Nanjeanne Feb 2016 #99
Great post, thanks. We must get enough votes to overcome the margin of manipulation. rhett o rick Feb 2016 #103
Spot on, as always! Punkingal Feb 2016 #105
As a matter of fact, what you say here isn't true: George II Feb 2016 #110
What happens if Bernie gets the nom., will the Dem party SammyWinstonJack Feb 2016 #113
They will support him for the most part. BillZBubb Feb 2016 #119
The left really doesn't have a home in the Democratic party any more. BillZBubb Feb 2016 #118
Here Here! RoccoR5955 Feb 2016 #121
I'll feel more comfortable when Mr Sanders picks up a few more marginalized demos. malthaussen Feb 2016 #122
Third Way is accepting of corporate money and by extension has protected them, not Jefferson23 Feb 2016 #123
"The trick will be to harness their energy and their money without looking like you are a captive of yodermon Feb 2016 #125
That really got to me badly. madfloridian Feb 2016 #165
That's always the thing, though. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #177
Love your first paragraph! staggerleem Feb 2016 #128
Despite her smarts there's more than a hint of Dunning-Kroeger about HRC GoneOffShore Feb 2016 #129
same for local politics and Dem town committees wordpix Feb 2016 #130
They have been interfering in FL politics for ages now. madfloridian Feb 2016 #132
Sorry that was your experience. The entire political system is designed to truedelphi Feb 2016 #166
K/R UglyGreed Feb 2016 #136
That turd way board of trustees list is all I need to know. Ivan Kaputski Feb 2016 #140
ba-a-a-a-a-a! Jean Genie Feb 2016 #146
K&R stage left Feb 2016 #147
If that cabal of Investment Bankers are DEMOCRATS then the Party is over. Ferd Berfel Feb 2016 #148
Wm Greider says trouble started when party abandoned the working class. He's so right. madfloridian Feb 2016 #154
Great post. You've knocked it out of the park. snagglepuss Feb 2016 #159
The saddest name on that list is Thurgood Marshall, Jr. hifiguy Feb 2016 #163
Always a K&R for you! blackspade Feb 2016 #167
the "Hillary DU Group" probably is the best hope for the Right. :( PatrynXX Feb 2016 #169
Since the racism, sexism stuff is being pushed by Hillary surrogates...they must not need my vote. madfloridian Feb 2016 #170
very good OP Angry Dragon Feb 2016 #171
^ Wilms Feb 2016 #174
DURec # 386. bvar22 Feb 2016 #175
When bvar22 says nice things to me.... madfloridian Feb 2016 #181
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Every time the party's le...»Reply #0