Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

2016 Postmortem

In reply to the discussion: Let's talk reparations. [View all]

HeiressofBickworth

(2,682 posts)
3. I think the idea of reparations is fraught with problems
Tue Jun 24, 2014, 04:37 AM
Jun 2014

How would payments be made, individuals or communities?
If individuals, must they be able to trace their ancestors to slavery in the US.
Not all black people are descendents of slaves -- President Obama isn't, for example.
If not required to trace ancestors to slavery, how would individuals be singled out for payment?
How black do they need to be? President Obama is 50% (one parent).
How about someone who has only one grandparent who is black?
Or one great-grandparent?
If payable to a community, what would be the criteria for the community to be eligible for reparations?
Percentage of black population in the community?
Percentage of black unemployment in the community?
Percentage of black-owned businesses?

My personal preference would be to create scholarships -- full ride -- room, board and tuition -- for kids who graduate from high school.
Or, if the child prefers, full tuition, plus living expense, for a technical or trade school.

A check-in-hand would be gone in no time, but an education would pull people out of poverty for life.

P.S. It occurs to me that some may object to my use of the word "black". My wonderful, but now deceased, friend always referred to himself as black. He and I discussed reparations once. He wasn't sure how it would actually work.

Let's talk reparations. [View all] cilla4progress Jun 2014 OP
Lets don't and take reparations off the table, marble falls Jun 2014 #1
Why and why? eom. 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #6
What portion does that white supremist who found out he was 18% black get? marble falls Jun 2014 #11
Nothing ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #17
would reparations go to current black americans, or to the decendents of actual slaves? unblock Jun 2014 #26
I'll answer a question with a (couple) question(s) ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #28
well that is the question, isn't it. what exactly are "reparations" for? unblock Jun 2014 #30
Well, since ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #38
point well taken regarding the "50% black/white" unblock Jun 2014 #45
400+ years of enslavement, second-class citizenship and being treated worse than animals noiretextatique Jun 2014 #51
i'm not disputing that reparations are justified. unblock Jun 2014 #54
i propose compensation for jim crow noiretextatique Jun 2014 #55
You've got it exactly right in my book. brush Jun 2014 #2
Cuz nothing rights Kharma like a big ol' pile of cash. marble falls Jun 2014 #12
I made a correction in my post brush Jun 2014 #13
I suspect the objection is the frequent DU refrain ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #29
I agree.nt bravenak Jun 2014 #52
Except-- YarnAddict Jun 2014 #32
There are many descendants of those enslaved . . . brush Jun 2014 #36
I think the idea of reparations is fraught with problems HeiressofBickworth Jun 2014 #3
Fraught with problems? Or, ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #7
a big +1. Undiscussed solutions nails it. cali Jun 2014 #19
Thank you ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #21
thank you for the link. cali Jun 2014 #22
It's a solvable problem brush Jun 2014 #14
Yeah, give everybody reparations that needs it, make it a permanent program. bemildred Jun 2014 #4
I agree ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #8
Sadly it doesn't work that way. tavernier Jun 2014 #5
Maybe, had the Roman Empire ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #9
I would love it if the Soviets tavernier Jun 2014 #10
I would love that, too; but ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #16
C'mon, you have to know about . . . brush Jun 2014 #15
The reparations to Japanese-Americans YarnAddict Jun 2014 #33
I stand corrected on the date . . . brush Jun 2014 #35
Reparations YarnAddict Jun 2014 #37
I understand . . . brush Jun 2014 #39
You are limiting it YarnAddict Jun 2014 #42
You seem to be able to think . . . brush Jun 2014 #50
Yes, we should pay reparations to those who were slaves or to their living children. Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #18
What about those that suffered under jim crow ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #31
Pay it. I don't owe it, however. nt Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #40
Do you "owe" the pensions of those that fought in WWI, or WWII? ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #41
What about them? Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #44
My point was ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #46
I have no idea. Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #47
Which is WHY we need to pass HR. 40 ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #48
Hundreds? I doubt that. nt Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #56
LOL ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #57
I don't see much in the way of actual economic analysis. Dreamer Tatum Jun 2014 #58
Google still is your friend ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #59
So that's it? brush Jun 2014 #43
which why they were never paid noiretextatique Jun 2014 #53
It should be seriously discussed and considered. cali Jun 2014 #20
Yet it's still not that simple. Igel Jun 2014 #25
Okay ... 1StrongBlackMan Jun 2014 #34
Thanks for this robust discussion. cilla4progress Jun 2014 #23
This statement: TBF Jun 2014 #49
A couple informative links cilla4progress Jun 2014 #24
my mother actually has received reparations unblock Jun 2014 #27
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Let's talk reparations.»Reply #3