Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Aristus

(66,366 posts)
20. The inaccuracies in 'Gladiator' are, you should pardon the pun, legion.
Thu Feb 27, 2014, 08:27 PM
Feb 2014

- Roman cavalry using stirrups, which wouldn't appear in the West for another few centuries.

- speaking of horses, the horses Romans used were very small by today's standards; not the big bays used in the film.

- The Emperor and his entourage wearing deep bluish-purple colors to denote royalty. 'Purple' in Ancient Rome, was closer to what we today call maroon.

- Young Lucius' hairstyle was appropriate for a beach party in the 1970's. But in Ancient Rome, his hair would have been clipped short.

- Nobody would have used the term "Senator Gaius". 'Gaius' was a given name, his praenomen. He would have been referred to by his nomen and cognomen out of respect, or just his cognomen among friends.

- Maximus would not have been submissive or deferential to the senators in his camp. As a Roman general, even as a Spaniard, he would have been of the Senatorial class, and therefor the same rank. In fact, his auctoritas would have been higher than theirs, as a successful field commander talking to civilians.

- The Praetorian Guard did not wear the highly fascistic black armor depicted in the film. They were proud of their shiny, expensive, highly-polished armor that was a privilege of the job.

- Commodus ruled for eleven years, not the year or so depicted in the film, and was highly popular in his day, at least with the common people.

- Nearly every detail of the emperor's palace in the film is wrong. I'll leave it at that.

OTOH, they got an awful lot right, but I'll save that for another time...

Kelly's Heroes! longship Feb 2014 #1
Saw it. Aristus Feb 2014 #2
Sorry. As you can tell, I am ignorant of tank warfare. longship Feb 2014 #3
I've never seen the Battle of the Bulge all the way through, Aristus Feb 2014 #5
I appreciate historic accuracy. longship Feb 2014 #9
Have to disagree Aristus. Nitram Feb 2014 #14
Thanks for the input. Aristus Feb 2014 #15
I guess they werre libertarians :-) Nitram Mar 2014 #29
The beast is awesome!!! grahamhgreen Feb 2014 #4
I agree. Aristus Feb 2014 #7
We'll, you got me googling around... I came up with grahamhgreen Feb 2014 #10
I concur. OnyxCollie Feb 2014 #12
"Sahara" (1943) Paladin Feb 2014 #6
I have vague recollections of a movie, probably from the '90s... ret5hd Feb 2014 #8
That's The Beast. OnyxCollie Feb 2014 #13
I checked IMDB... catnhatnh Feb 2014 #11
I forgot "Courage Under Fire", which opens with the scene of a tank battle from The Gulf War. Aristus Feb 2014 #16
Let me make what I hope is a constructive suggestion: Paladin Feb 2014 #17
I try not to. It depends on the film. Aristus Feb 2014 #18
Glad to hear it. Paladin Feb 2014 #19
The inaccuracies in 'Gladiator' are, you should pardon the pun, legion. Aristus Feb 2014 #20
I read Caesar's accounts of the Gaelic wars in high school Latin.... Paladin Feb 2014 #22
No. Actually 'Gladiator' and the miniseries 'Rome' come the closest. Aristus Feb 2014 #26
Tank Girl? flying rabbit Feb 2014 #21
Yeah. I keep meaning to see it. Aristus Feb 2014 #23
I actually found it to be pretty enjoyable mindless entertainment. flying rabbit Feb 2014 #24
Two things: Aristus Feb 2014 #25
I'll bet this is about tanks. valerief Feb 2014 #27
Saw it. Aristus Feb 2014 #28
Lebanon--2009 kairos12 Mar 2014 #30
Got it on DVD. Aristus Mar 2014 #31
White Tiger (2012) onager Mar 2014 #32
I've had the DVD of "9th Company" for a couple of years now. Aristus Mar 2014 #33
Not on my OnDemand, yet. onager Mar 2014 #34
My primary encounters with Soviet-built tanks was when I was stationed in Europe. Aristus Mar 2014 #35
My DVD copy of "White Tiger" arrived in the mail today. Aristus Mar 2014 #38
These? brooklynboy49 Mar 2014 #36
Welcome to DU! Aristus Mar 2014 #37
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Movies»Can anyone recommend a go...»Reply #20