Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

NNadir's Journal
NNadir's Journal
July 6, 2022

Concentrations of trifluoroacetic acid in water have increased 6 fold since 1998 in California.

I will only briefly note this paper I've just come across: Increases in Trifluoroacetate Concentrations in Surface Waters over Two Decades Thomas M. Cahill, Environmental Science & Technology 2022 56 (13), 9428-9434.

I have been very interested in the mechanism of radiolytic degradation of PFAS, a rising toxicological concern coming under the rubric of "forever chemicals." TFA is a potential degradation product of radiolytic degradation, if not carried to completion. TFA is also a potential product of the slow bioremediation and thermal remediation of these compounds.

However in this case, this is not the likely source according to the authors. They suggest it arises from the degradation of some of the HFCs that replaced CFC's because of the Montreal Protocol, the only successful international environmental treaty ever having broad international agreement.

Some text from the introduction of the paper:

Trifluoroacetate (TFA) is an ultrashort-chain perfluorinated alkanoic acid anion that is exceptionally stable in the environment. Initial research focused on the potential for hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants to create TFA in the atmosphere, (1?3) but it has since been shown that TFA arises from many additional sources including fluorochemical production facilities, (4?6) degradation of fluoropolymers, (7) inhaled anesthetics, (8) specific pesticides with a trifluoromethyl group, (9) certain pharmaceuticals, (5) and fluorochemical-based fire-fighting foams. (10) TFA produced from HFC degradation in the atmosphere was expected to partition into water, ionize, and wash out of the atmosphere. Since the main precursor compounds were globally distributed due to their long atmospheric lifetimes (e.g., 14.4 years for HFC-134a), (2) TFA was expected to appear in regions with no local sources of TFA. The concern was that TFA could accumulate in certain terminal waterbodies that lack any significant outflow. (11,12) Since TFA is weakly phytotoxic, (13,14) the concentration of TFA could ultimately achieve toxic concentrations in the future. Furthermore, if problems arise, then the effects could persist for extended time periods due to the stability of TFA.
Attention shifted away from TFA to the longer fluorinated chain acids in the late 1990s and early 2000s when the longer chain perfluorinated compounds, such as perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS), were discovered to be ubiquitous in the environment. Unlike TFA, these longer perfluorinated acids had both high animal toxicity and the potential to bioaccumulate, so they represented a more immediate risk to both humans and the environment. Research into TFA dwindled with only a few recent ambient measurements being reported, (15,16) while most of the remaining research focused on suspected point sources such as fluorochemical production plants (4?6) and fire-fighting training sites. (10)

However, the use of first-generation fluorocarbon refrigerants, such as HFC-134a, continued to rise and the atmospheric concentrations climbed along with them. Between 1998 and 2021, the atmospheric concentrations of HFC-134a increased approximately14-fold from 8.7 to 121 ppt at the Mona Loa Observatory, Hawaii, (17) so the amount of TFA formed in the atmosphere would be expected to increase by a similar value. Furthermore, HFC-134a is being phased out and its apparent replacement, namely hydrofluoroolefin-1234yf (HFO-1234yf), has a higher product yield for TFA (near 100%) (18) compared to HFC-134a (approximately 30% depending on pressure and temperature (19)), which would also suggest that more TFA will be forming in the atmosphere.


Two figures from the text, and a table of results:



The caption:

Figure 1. Location of sampling sites along a transect upwind and downwind of major metropolitan areas in Northern California. The predominant surface wind climatology is marked with the white dashed lines. (27) The open symbols represent streams that were originally sampled in 1998 that were dry in 2021. Satellite photo from Google Earth.




The caption:

Figure 2. TFA concentrations during the two sampling periods and different transect segments. The sample size represents the number of streams sampled with duplicate samples being collected for each stream. A version of this plot with an enlarged 1998 plot is presented in the Supporting Information as Figure S1. Data to generate the 1998 plot was taken from ref (26).


A table of results:


Lovely.

The carbon fluorine bond is one of the strongest known and breaking it generally requires energy at least in the UV range.
July 6, 2022

The "Improved" Siemans Process for Producing Polysilicon for Solar Cells.

I keep hearing over and over and over, year after year, decade after decade, that the world will be saved from climate change by solar cells and batteries. None of this endless talk has prevented the atmospheric concentrations of the dangerous fossil fuel waste carbon dioxide from being over 420 ppm for the last 14 weeks of this year, 2022, less than 10 years after it first went over 400 ppm in 2013.

Of course, one cannot read any scientific journal without hearing about improving batteries, recycling them, and how wonderful the solar nirvana will be some day, "some day" having not come, is not here, and I think, won't come.

The environmental implications of this scheme have escaped much attention in the popular press, but increasingly one sees more and more questions about this topic in the scientific press.

I don't really follow the chemistry of solar cells all that much, since I find the issue to be of low value but occasionally I'll take a peek.

Tonight I came across this paper: A SiCl4-Assisted Roasting Approach for Recovering Spent LiCoO2 Cathode
Mengting Li, Beilei Zhang, Xin Qu, Muya Cai, Dongxu Liu, Fengyin Zhou, Hongwei Xie, Shuaibo Gao, and Huayi Yin
ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 2022 10 (26), 8305-8313.

It contains this text about the production of polysilicon, the most popular component of solar cells, citing an "improved" process:

Silicon tetrachloride (SiCl4) is a byproduct of polysilicon production by an improved Siemens process. (23) It is reported that producing 1 t of polysilicon will generate 10–15 t of SiCl4 byproduct in the improved Siemens process. (24) Additionally, SiCl4 is a highly toxic substance and will immediately decompose into silicate (H2SiO3) and hydrogen chloride (HCl) in wet air, posing a potential threat to human health and the environment. Therefore, the harmless treatment of SiCl4 is necessary and meaningful. Considering the 84% chlorine content of SiCl4, it could possess a strong chlorination effect. Thus, we make an attempt to use SiCl4 as a chlorination agent to recover spent LiCoO2, which simultaneously realizes the harmless treatment and effective recycling of two kinds of waste resources.


Ten to fifteen tons of a highly toxic compound per ton of polysilicon, an "improvement..."

You don't say?

I imagine a few Bhopal type events in there with a leak, which were solar energy to become a significant form of energy - I think it won't - would increase in probability. This won't excite many scare stories over at the Union of Concerned "Scientists" of the ilk that the moron Ed Lyman produces daily about nuclear energy, without a single whimper about the hundreds of millions of deaths from air pollution that took place during his career in insipid whining, but I suspect over all, because of the extremely low energy to mass ratio of solar energy, it would become inevitable were the industry to matter, which it doesn't.

In order for the SiCl4 treatment of LiCoO2 cathodes to treat all of the SiCl4 waste generated, the masses of these products would need to be perfectly balanced, but that won't happen either.

Have a nice day tomorrow.
July 5, 2022

Gender Fluid Person Named to Manage Used Nuclear Fuel.

From Sam Brinton's Linkedin Page:

It’s official. As of June 19th, I now serve my nation as the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Spent Fuel and Waste Disposition in the Office of Nuclear Energy in the Department of Energy. Due to the concern of negative and threatening responses like we saw in my previous announcement as I was offered the role, including more than a hundred death threats and more vitriol than I could have imagined, I held off announcing my official start until I could be safe and secure in my new role.

But goodness is this a time for celebration! It’s really really official! The beautiful irony that the months-long process of getting me into this role culminated in a Pride month start date is not lost on me. As one of if not the very first openly genderfluid individuals in federal government leadership, I was welcomed with open arms into the Department of Energy all the way up to the Secretary whom I shared the stage with in a Pride month celebration panel just today. To clarify, I am not a Biden appointee (despite what was reported) and instead serve as a career employee in the Senior Executive Service - I intend to be serving my country in this role through many many presidencies.

I’ve prepared for this moment in a technical sense for a decade. Graduating with not one but two degrees from MIT led to working at multiple think tanks where I produced the first-of-a-kind reports and maps on consent-based siting and advanced reactor innovation. Being the first employee of one of the world’s first nuclear waste start-up companies led me to innovate and drive the national conversation of nuclear waste management into the future. And now, I lead a staff of hundreds and a budget of millions (with a Nuclear Waste Fund I’m responsible for at over $45 billion) as the leader of the office overseeing the management of the nation’s spent nuclear fuel.

Thank you for being the community who believed in me. You got me through some dark days these past few months and I’m eternally grateful. Now it's time for me to make my mark as the Deputy Assistant Secretary...


Sam Brinton



Q&A with Nuclear Engineer, Presidential Adviser & Conversion Therapy Activist Sam Brinton

I may be an old fat bald straight white guy, but I particularly relate to this remark they made in the above interview:

BEQ: WHAT UNIQUE QUALITIES OR PERSPECTIVE DO YOU BRING TO THE FIELD OF NUCLEAR ENERGY AS AN LGBTQ PERSON?
Brinton: THIS is my best argument for my decision to become a nuclear engineer. Think about this: A nuclear engineer is constantly fighting the misperception that they are Homer Simpson and killing the environment with green glowing goo or about to build a nuclear bomb. They are constantly correcting public perception. And that’s what an LGBTQ person is doing too. We are helping our parents realize their idea of who we would marry isn’t necessarily the same. We are showing the world we are more than the stereotypical identities they see on TV. That’s why I think us LGBTQ nuclear engineers are the best nuclear engineers.
July 5, 2022

Ukrainian mathematician becomes second woman to win prestigious Fields Medal

From Nature News: Ukrainian mathematician becomes second woman to win prestigious Fields Medal

Subtitle:

Maryna Viazovska, who works on the geometry of spheres, is one of four winners of the coveted prize this year.


Davide Castelvecchi, Nature July 5, 2022

Excerpt:

Ukrainian number theorist Maryna Viazovska is among the four winners of the 2022 Fields Medals, one of the highest honours in mathematics that is conventionally awarded to people aged under 40. The other winners are James Maynard, a number theorist at the University of Oxford, UK; June Huh, a specialist in combinatorics at Princeton University in New Jersey; and Hugo Duminil-Copin, who studies statistical physics at the Institute of Advanced Scientific Studies (IHES) near Paris. The International Mathematical Union (IMU) announced the winners at an award ceremony in Helsinki on 5 July.

“All of the medalists are incredibly deserving and talented, showcasing the vibrancy of mathematical research across the globe,” says Bryna Kra, a mathematician at Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois, who is president-elect of the American Mathematical Society.

Viazovska, who is based at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne (EPFL), is the second woman ever to earn the award. She is best known for her solution of the sphere packing problem — finding the arrangement of spheres that can take up the largest portion of a volume — in eight dimensions.

In a three-dimensional space, the most efficient way to pack spheres is the pyramid arrangement, akin to how oranges are packed on trays in a grocer’s shop (proving this mathematically was extremely hard and was the subject of a tour-de-force paper in the 1990s). But in four or more dimensions, very little is known, says Henry Cohn, a mathematician at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge. “It’s this horrific gap in our knowledge — almost embarrassing,” said Cohn in an address following the Fields Medal announcement. Viazovska introduced new techniques into the problem that came from number theory and the theory of symmetries in eight dimensions. “Given how poor our understanding is in other dimensions, it’s really miraculous that Maryna was able to get this exactly,” Cohn added. More recently, Cohn worked with Viazovska and others to extend the result to 24-dimensional space.

“Viazovska invents fresh and unexpected tools that allow her to jump over natural barriers that have held us back for years,” says Peter Sarnak, a number theorist at Princeton University in New Jersey...

... The Fields Medals and other IMU prizes are normally announced at the opening of the International Congress of Mathematicians (ICM), which takes place every four years. This year’s congress was scheduled to begin on 6 July in St. Petersburg, Russia, but the plan was scrapped following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February. Instead, the awards ceremony was moved to Helsinki and the congress will take place as a virtual event.

“We condemn the madness, the injustice, and the irreversibility of war that threatens the very existence of humanity,” wrote four members of what had been the local organizing committee statement on 27 February.

The committee that chooses the Fields winner — whose members’ identities were kept secret until today — reportedly made its decision before the invasion...


Another winner of the Fields medal, June Huh, is also an interesting person. Now a Professor of Mathematics at Princeton, he was a high school drop out in Korea and was rejected at many Universities when he applied to Ph.D. programs because of his poor undergraduate grades, including many failed courses.
July 5, 2022

The Rogue Supreme Court has declared the Constitution unconstitutional.

It is now asserting itself as the inquisition courtesy of Mitch McConnell and his enablers, including Mitt Romney and Susan Collins, both of whom pretend to be "conservative" and both of whom have worked to destroy our Constitutional government.

They must be stopped.

July 1, 2022

Uncovering the Key Features of Dysprosium Flows and Stocks in China

I have just come across this paper: Uncovering the Key Features of Dysprosium Flows and Stocks in China
Shijiang Xiao, Yong Geng, Hengyu Pan, Ziyan Gao, and Tianli Yao Environmental Science & Technology 2022 56 (12), 8682-8690.

There are 14 lanthanide elements, with yttrium making 15 although it is not strictly an "f element" although its chemistry is very similar. Most lanthanide (aka "rare earths" ) deposits are dominated by just two, cerium and yttrium, with the other, with the lighter 6 including cerium as well as lanthanum, praseodymium, neodymium, samarium, and gadolinium dominating the remainder. (Europium can behave differently than most lanthanides and is sometimes depleted in ores. Promethium does not occur naturally; it is radioactive, with a short half life, but can be obtained, in very small quantities - because of its high neutron capture cross section - from used nuclear fuels.)

Dysprosium is a "heavy" lanthanide, and as such is relatively rare. Nevertheless it is in high demand, hence this article.

The largest application, as one can see from the open abstract, is to build wind turbines, which after decades of cheering and the destruction of huge tracts of wilderness to make industrial parks, remains a trivial form of energy, even though the fate of the planet's atmosphere has foolishly been bet on them.

From the opening text of the full article:

Dysprosium (Dy) is considered one of the most critical rare earth elements (REEs). Dy is usually added in neodymium magnets (NdFeB) to improve their heat resistance. (1?4) Due to the high levels of magnetic strength in relative compact sizes, NdFeB magnets have become an indispensable component in several high-tech applications and clean energy technologies, such as industrial robotics, wind turbines, and electric vehicles. (5,6) Demand for Dy has sharply increased since the start of this century. (7) Especially, clean energy technologies are the key to moving toward carbon neutrality, which means that the demand for Dy will further increase in the near future. (8?11) However, the global Dy reserve is limited, leading to concerns on how to achieve sustainable Dy supply. (12,13)

China has the largest REE reserve with an amount of approximate 44 megatons (Mt, 1 Mt = 1,000,000 tons), accounting for 37% of the global reserve in 2019. (14) As for Dy, it is estimated that the global dysprosium oxide (Dy2O3) reserve is 1.62 Mt, referring to 1.41 Mt Dy metallic equivalent. (14) China has the largest Dy reserve with an overall amount of 1.23 Mt, accounting for 87% of the global reserve. (14) Such reserve exists for several common rare earth minerals, such as monazite, xenotime, bastnasite, and ion-adsorbed clays (IACs). In particular, the Dy-rich IACs are distributed only in Southern Chinese provinces, such as Jiangxi, Fujian, Guangdong, and Hunan. However, the accurate flows and stocks of China’s Dy cycle remain unclear.

Material flow analysis (MFA) is one widely recognized method to characterize material flows through the anthroposphere. (15) MFA is capable to track material flows through a specified system boundary and identify how one material transforms and accumulates over its lifecycle based on the principle of mass balance. (16) This method has been employed to analyze most mineral elements and several REEs within different regions and periods, such as aluminum, tungsten, graphite, and neodymium. (17?20) As for the Dy cycle, the existing MFA studies mainly focus on the Dy flows associated with NdFeB in Japan, (1) the impacts of the increasing demand for neodymium (Nd) and Dy on the supply and demand of the host metals and other companion REE in wind power in the US, (12) Dy stocks and flows in NdFeB magnets among 18 various products and its recycling potential by 2035 in Denmark, (21) and the effectiveness of reducing Dy demand from low-Dy NdFeB magnets and promoting NdFeB magnets recycling in Japan for 2010–2030. (22)


The term used in this opening statement, "clean energy" is one I personally find objectionable. There's nothing "clean" about wind and electric cars.

I recently attended an online lecture put on by the Irving Institute at Dartmouth by a scientist whose name escapes me about the "recycling" handwaving that goes on, by the way. She pointed out that in use materials are not available for recycling, and where use is growing rapidly the demand must be met by mining.

Some graphics from the paper:



The caption:

Figure 1. MFA framework for China’s Dy cycle.


Some frame work on the flows:

Based on the principle of mass balance, China’s Dy flows and stocks are classified into five accounting processes from a life cycle perspective.

(1) Domestic flows: domestic flows are the basic Dy flows, covering mining, fabrication, manufacturing, and use stages. They are calculated based on the amounts of primary products, intermediate products, final products, and Dy contents in different products. Various Dy forms are transformed into unique metallic Dy flows. These final products and their Dy contents are listed in Tables S1 and S2.

(2) Trade flows: trade flows reflect the Dy import and export amounts at five stages with various forms. These Dy-containing products are coded by the Harmonized Commodity Description and Coding System of China and listed in Table S3. The trade flows are equal to the traded product amounts multiplied by their corresponding Dy contents.

(3) Loss flows: in this study, the Dy losses are assumed to occur in the R&S stage and fabrication stage, with figures of 10 and 30% respectively. (1,26) These loss flows are calculated by multiplying the production amounts and their loss rates.

(4) Supply-demand flows: Dy flows are calculated by the top-down approach in the R&S stage, while the bottom-up approach is used to estimate the demand for Dy in the fabrication and use stages. Hence, there is a mismatch between the Dy-containing concentrate supply and compound demand, and this gap is considered to be composed of hibernating stock and illegal mining.

(5) In-use stocks: a bottom-up approach is applied to estimate the in-use Dy stocks through the accumulation of net flows since the base year of 2000. (27) The calculation equations are listed as...




The caption:

Figure 2. Cumulative Dy cycle in China from 2000 to 2019 and the annual Dy cycle in 2009 and 2019. Note: IACs: ion adsorbed clays, MRI: magnetic resonance imaging machines, CV: conventional vehicles, EV: electric vehicles, AC: air conditioners, RE: refrigerators, WM: washing machines, WT: wind turbines, EB: E-bikes, DC: desktop computer, LC: laptop computer, MP: mobile phones, LP: loudspeakers, VC: vacuum cleaners, MO: microwave ovens, EL: elevators, CD: CD/DVD players, IR: industrial robots, and OT: others.




The caption:

Figure 3. Final Dy demand and application structure in China from 2000 to 2019.




The caption:

Figure 4. In-use Dy stocks in China from 2000 to 2019.




The caption:

Figure 5. EoL Dy flows in China from 2000 to 2019.





The caption:

Figure 6. Historical evolution of Dy supply and demand (a), hibernating stocks (b), illegal mining (c), and price (d) in China from 2000 to 2019.





The caption:

Figure 7. International Dy trade amounts in China from 2000 to 2019.


According to text in the paper China does not have enough dysprosium to meet its internal demand. (This is surprising to me.)

Several policy recommendations are made since China is both the largest producer and consumer of dysprosium.

One is to crack down on illegal mining - the isolation of lanthanides and their separation is very dirty chemistry, and when wildcatted, it is even worse.

Others are to increase recycling - although as noted above - recycling will not meet supply in a case of rising demand, rising demand being operative in the dysprosium supply.

I would imagine that most people do not think about this element. It's obscure. It is rather amazing however, to recognize how much depends on access to it, even in the case where the world comes to its senses and stops building wind turbines.

The light lanthanides are all fission products; the heavy ones (those past gadolinium) are not.


Profile Information

Gender: Male
Current location: New Jersey
Member since: 2002
Number of posts: 33,563
Latest Discussions»NNadir's Journal